Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Roadrunner7671]

If we don't lynch scum here, D2 we'll only need 2 town votes to lynch.

This assumes someone dies in the night. Which could be unlikely

Why?

[J Reggie]

If we don't lynch scum here, D2 we'll only need 2 town votes to lynch.

This assumes someone dies in the night. Which could be unlikely

No it doesn't.

[gkrieg13]

If we don't lynch scum here, D2 we'll only need 2 town votes to lynch.

This assumes someone dies in the night. Which could be unlikely

No it doesn't.

Good point. I actually don't like this statement. Well only need two votes. Sounds slightly like you are talking like we as in the mafia. Anyway, I doubt that scum would all get on the same wagon together.

[Dylan32]

If we don't lynch scum here, D2 we'll only need 2 town votes to lynch.

This assumes someone dies in the night. Which could be unlikely

No it doesn't.

Good point. I actually don't like this statement. Well only need two votes. Sounds slightly like you are talking like we as in the mafia. Anyway, I doubt that scum would all get on the same wagon together.

I agree with that.

[2.71828.....]

Not a huge fan of pulling out the "we" in Reggie's statement as "we the mafia"

I mean, that is how it reads, but I don't see it as some sort of slip.  "we the town" lynch mafia, then "we the scum" need two town votes.  I just think it is likelier that "we" is being used much more generally than that.  Like, "we the players of the game" rather than a certain faction.

[Dylan32]

What other case would some arbitrary "we" only need 2 town votes to lynch someone on D2 on the condition that all 4 scum are still alive? I don't mean for this to sound like sort of a gotcha question or something like that, I just really haven't been able to think of another case where that statement makes sense.  So if there is a good reason why the town would only need 2 votes to lynch tomorrow, please explain it.

[J Reggie]

Not a huge fan of pulling out the "we" in Reggie's statement as "we the mafia"

I mean, that is how it reads, but I don't see it as some sort of slip.  "we the town" lynch mafia, then "we the scum" need two town votes.  I just think it is likelier that "we" is being used much more generally than that.  Like, "we the players of the game" rather than a certain faction.

That is how I intended it. Why would I say something that one would say in the mafia cutie in the main thread?

Also, why would I make that warning as mafia? Wouldn't I want town to not think about that?

[gkrieg13]

Not a huge fan of pulling out the "we" in Reggie's statement as "we the mafia"

I mean, that is how it reads, but I don't see it as some sort of slip.  "we the town" lynch mafia, then "we the scum" need two town votes.  I just think it is likelier that "we" is being used much more generally than that.  Like, "we the players of the game" rather than a certain faction.

That is how I intended it. Why would I say something that one would say in the mafia cutie in the main thread?

Also, why would I make that warning as mafia? Wouldn't I want town to not think about that?

Ya but it doesn't matter that much and reminding gives you town points. That's why Faust generally does pro town things as scum that have little consequence or why people reminding of deadlines are usually scum

[Roadrunner7671]

Hello? Why isn't it likely for someone to die tonight? What did I miss?

[J Reggie]

The reason I think you're scum, gkrieg, isn't just because you're confident. It's because you're fluffy and confident about being fluffy.

Hello? Why isn't it likely for someone to die tonight? What did I miss?

Scum can only half-kill someone, at least as a factional ability. Although it's likely they will have other weapons to add to that.

[Roadrunner7671]

The reason I think you're scum, gkrieg, isn't just because you're confident. It's because you're fluffy and confident about being fluffy.

Hello? Why isn't it likely for someone to die tonight? What did I miss?

Scum can only half-kill someone, at least as a factional ability. Although it's likely they will have other weapons to add to that.

Oh I see. I read most of the setup but I didn't get that far. Doesn't that seem unfair? I'm pretty sure weapons are one shot

[gkrieg13]

The reason I think you're scum, gkrieg, isn't just because you're confident. It's because you're fluffy and confident about being fluffy.

Hello? Why isn't it likely for someone to die tonight? What did I miss?

Scum can only half-kill someone, at least as a factional ability. Although it's likely they will have other weapons to add to that.

When have I been any of those things as scum?  You literally just played a game where we were partners together.

[gkrieg13]

The reason I think you're scum, gkrieg, isn't just because you're confident. It's because you're fluffy and confident about being fluffy.

Hello? Why isn't it likely for someone to die tonight? What did I miss?

Scum can only half-kill someone, at least as a factional ability. Although it's likely they will have other weapons to add to that.

Oh I see. I read most of the setup but I didn't get that far. Doesn't that seem unfair? I'm pretty sure weapons are one shot

You should just read the rest of the setup

[gkrieg13]

Not a huge fan of pulling out the "we" in Reggie's statement as "we the mafia"

I mean, that is how it reads, but I don't see it as some sort of slip.  "we the town" lynch mafia, then "we the scum" need two town votes.  I just think it is likelier that "we" is being used much more generally than that.  Like, "we the players of the game" rather than a certain faction.

That is how I intended it. Why would I say something that one would say in the mafia cutie in the main thread?

Also, why would I make that warning as mafia? Wouldn't I want town to not think about that?

Well they would say something that is supposed to be in the mafia QT in the game thread if it was a scumslip

[gkrieg13]

I mean in response to the fluffiness, we have gone over this before, from a previous game where faust was being fluffy, it doesn't mean that you are scum.  It can be an indicator that you're scum if all of the posts that you have lack content, which is not the case with me.  I have just as much content as everyone else, but I have been posting a lot more to try to get into the game and make it fun.  I just got out of two scum games that were very exhausting and I felt like I didn't have any opportunities to talk about fluff because that is what town seemed so intent on being a scum indicator.  Let me have my fluff please.

[2.71828.....]

Vote: mail-mi

[mail-mi]

Vote: mail-mi

Reason?

[SpaceAnemone]

Yeah, I could happily go back to voting Mail-mi.

[2.71828.....]

Vote: mail-mi

Reason?

It felt like the right time to move my vote

[silverspawn]

Oh I see. I read most of the setup but I didn't get that far. Doesn't that seem unfair? I'm pretty sure weapons are one shot

This town slip is silver-approved.

[silverspawn]

I thought that I also commented that there wasn't really that much content in Ghacob's posts?

Commenting on the quantity of the content is not the same as commenting on the content of the content. And yes, it's vague hints rather than concrete statements, but for those of us who only know our own alignment/thing/weapons, it's more than nothing, while for scums, it's probably significantly less interesting, because they already have four times as much information... which is why dismissing it seems iffy to me.

I was thinking gkireg is scummy this game and then Space perfectly explained why.

[silverspawn]

I also approve of the mail-mi wagon. Not at all a fan of how his reaction to votes and RR turning on him was "yeah RR is towny kayletsmoveon"

[Roadrunner7671]

I also approve of the mail-mi wagon. Not at all a fan of how his reaction to votes and RR turning on him was "yeah RR is towny kayletsmoveon"

RR is just a G

[silverspawn]

Silver Count Vote Silv Thing

silverspawn (2): gkrieg13, chairs
gkrieg13 (1): J Reggie
mail-mi (3): EFHW, Roadrunner7671, e
chairs (2): Ghacob, SpaceAnemone
EFHW (1): silverspawn

Not Voting (1): mail-mi

I also approve of the mail-mi wagon. Not at all a fan of how his reaction to votes and RR turning on him was "yeah RR is towny kayletsmoveon"

RR is just a G

i.. know? 

[silverspawn]

vote: mail-mi