Faust reread:
His beginning posts are copying old quotes. J Reggie notices first:
So Faust is going through and repeating his opening lines from previous RMM games, which seems appropriate. I wonder if he'll continue or stop now that I've noticed this.
I love the flavor! This is going to be a fun game. I'm going to try to be towny as town for once.
vote: WW
I'd say that makes J Reggie less likely to be scum, though we already believe that.
Game-claiming seems bad methinks. We give up information (that is pretty useless for now), and scum isn't even required to restrict their fakeclaim pool.
Though thinking a bit... there was this one RMM that only had a SK and lots of townies. If someone is from that game (Guilds Mafia I think), claiming is probably a good idea.
First idea. Somewhat interesting now that Faust knew this is not accurate. I don't think that actually changes anything.
A vote for Seprix:
vote: Seprix
I think scum!Seprix is more likely to notice my "scumslip" than town!Seprix, so that paid off in the end.
That's a terrible argument. I rechecked the main thread, because I didn't see how many scum were revealed. You said 4, so I checked again. There was nothing. And then you backpedaled, and then started telling me how you did it on purpose. How is anyone falling for this? We caught scum red handed with the hand in the cookie jar. This is as clear cut as it gets!
You did all that in under a minute
Now that's a much better point.
Vote: Seprix
Continues to question Seprix some on the timing and degree of Seprix rereading the setup.
And now I have to figure out which of these stories makes less sense.
On Sperix v J Reggie.
Seprix's story now mostly checks out, and the fact that he didn't flail under pressure is townie for him methinks. unvote
Now do I want to vote for Reggie again?
Okay, so J Reggie supposedly did it on purpose. Ugh. I mean. Why are you even saying
I'm going to try to be towny as town for once.
if you continue to play intentionally scummy?
I forgot. It's hard to be towny as town, it's a lot more fun to do weird stuff. But I'm fine now, don't worry. You can expect nothing but towniness from here on out.
On the other hand, this also looks townie. Maybe there is nothing here.
This is by the way when I thought Faust was scum, because both these assignments feel arbitrary. (I have a post in my QT about it.) Makes Seprix partner slightly more likely, I think.
A Gkrieg vote:
Hey, gkrieg is here. He is very low profile. His latest post looks kinda scummy. Vote: gkrieg I want to see more stuff from you.
Again:
I trust iguana's claim for now. If there is evidence of SK, he is who I will be lining up to lynch first.
You do realize this makes no sense?
Who am I voting for? I forgot. Vote: gkrieg
I trust iguana's claim for now. If there is evidence of SK, he is who I will be lining up to lynch first.
You do realize this makes no sense?
Who am I voting for? I forgot. Vote: gkrieg
It doesn't make no sense, just little sense. Why is not making sense scummy?
I suppose.
Scum wants to keep iguana a viable lynch candidate, both because they don't want an IC and they don't want to use their nightkill on the SK.
I'd just expect town!gkrieg to see that iguana's play doesn't make a ton of sense for a SK. Why he would look at him first for a SK is beyond me.
I'd say this interaction makes Gkrieg less likely, though it could be done to a partner. He continues this line of discussion with Gkrieg a bit more.
First reads list:
So where are we?
iguana is IC.
J Reggie, sudgy, Seprix are towny.
Witherweaver, EFHW and RR are somewhat towny.
silver is minimally towny.
gkrieg and Archetype are somewhat scummy.
I think that's everyone I have an opinion on. The rest really need to step up their game.
Hmm.. Gotta be a parnter in there somewhere. Seprix, Sudgy, EFHW, Silver, RR?... I think this is the first time he mentions RR and EFHW, and possibly Silver as well.
Response to LaLight voting J Reggie:
Man, that is really bad. The thing I can't figure out is how scummy LaLight is for this. But he has played before, so I have to assume that he understands these kind of things.
I think that was the 'fake hammer' thing.
Here's the move towards Arch:
Vote: Archetype
[/quote
J Reggie is hovering around L-2, L-1 for a while.. possible partner scenario, Faust thinks J Reggie will get lynched anyway and wants to put some early distancing in, but the Arch wagon takes off and he stays committed to it? Possible but I don't think it's very likely.
A bit later (r552) he makes a case against Arch with quotes and stuff.. not too indicative of bussing.
In response to J Reggie proposing GKrieg:
Hummm... it's tempting. But Archetpe is scummy too, and I just spent all this time compiling a nice case on him.
Has a bit to say about Calamitas' claim.. mostly nullish to non-partner on Calamitas from this I think.
On EFHW:
EFHW is meh. I think she'd be more active as scum.
Switches to Calam:
Well. Vote: Calamitas
But I think here Arch is not even possible. Scum!Faust would probably have gone away from partner!Arch sooner. I think all our leading D1 wagons (Arch, J Reggie, Calam) were town.
Basically brings us to end of day.
There is not a whole lot here. Faust voted:
Seprix,
Gkrieg,
Archetype
Interaction-wise I'd say Seprix looks worse. EFHW does look likely as well.. oh, RR claimed that neighborhood with Faust.. Faust said very little about RR throughout the day.
Author
Topic: RMM35: Rewind Mafia (Game over!) (Read 212963 times)