Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Archetype]

I trust iguana's claim for now.  If there is evidence of SK, he is who I will be lining up to lynch first.

You do realize this makes no sense?

Who am I voting for? I forgot. Vote: gkrieg

It makes sense - he is assuming iguana is probably one of the town characters, but if it looks like there is an SK in the game he will revisit that assumption.

Phrasing it as "lining up to lynch first" does come across as scummy though I lean towards it being too scummy to be scum. There's really not that much to go off of D1 though.

Fixed to make gkreig seem less eager to eat.

[EFHW]

See, this is why I like subbing in - you can skip Day 1.  I'd say lynch a lurker, except that would be me and I don't like that idea at all! 

People I don't want to lynch today:
me, iguana, gkrieg, faust

People I have vague suspicions of and would therefore consider lynching:
Haddock, Calamitas, maybe Archetype, maybe WW.

Person I don't particularly suspect but who would be informative to lynch: JReggie

Everyone else: NULL.

[J Reggie]

yay we're back!

Hey, EFHW, it would not be informative to lynch me. 

[Witherweaver]

Post.

[Witherweaver]

And boo to EFHW

[J Reggie]

Post.

I'm pretty sure we don't get prods if the forum's been down.

[Seprix]

That was such a long wait. F.ds is always down these days. I wonder if it is  secret message by Theory. Like morse code or something. He's probably telling me to get a life.

[faust]

So where are we?

iguana is IC.
J Reggie, sudgy, Seprix are towny.
Witherweaver, EFHW and RR are somewhat towny.
silver is minimally towny.

gkrieg and Archetype are somewhat scummy.

I think that's everyone I have an opinion on. The rest really need to step up their game.

[Calamitas]

That was such a long wait. F.ds is always down these days. I wonder if it is  secret message by Theory. Like morse code or something. He's probably telling me to get a life.

It can't be SOS for sure, we all wouldn't stand the '---' part

Will re-read soon, sorry for letting you wait. I'm quite busy right now and this game here is just to ridiculous to allow contributions when you are not sufficiently available.

PPE

[gkrieg13]

Will contribute later

[silverspawn]

Vote: faust

Hi. I have something to say.

Noone should vote for me in this game, ever.

Haha totally didn't read this.

Not changing my vote.

 

Any thoughts on anything, like game-origin claiming?

I think like normal, I am against such early claims. I'll start considering mass claims D2, but again, those aren't usually a good idea.

What are the odds for multiple town/scum/3rd party teams in this game, considering the size of 14 players?

Seems unlikely, 4 mafia plus an SK is a lot.

I mean, I don't know that there are 4 mafia, but you know.

That's actually hilarious.

Seprix being all over the scumslip could be disingenuous. I actually think it's pretty clearly faked. No scum accidentally says 'by the way there are n mafia'

But scum doesn't say this:

You post this right after. Look, if you're town, this is really unfortunate, but it looks really really bad, and if I did this, you'd be voting for me as well. I hope you understand.

town on Seprix

25 seconds is well enough time to recognise and then post, especially if you consider the style of the second message. It seems to be posted hastily, if this was well planned you might have used the clipboard as well.
vote: Reggie

scum on Calamitas

also town on faust for playing the best town game so far. which might not be alignment indicative. mhhh

How does so much happen in a couple hours?  Anyway, first, Vote: J Reggie.  I noticed the scumslip instantly, and while he maybe could have saved it, I feel like he was flailing a lot more than he would as town.  I find this post scummy as well.

Also, with iguanaiguana, I have no idea if I believe that he's town.  He wouldn't do this if he wasn't from Guilds, but could he maybe be the SK?  I don't know.  I don't think we should treat him as an IC (or anybody, just based on a game claim).  I don't think game claims are good at all, and I don't think this one was either.

Also, consider this: Mail-mi probably was trying to get the most interesting roles from each game.  What's the most interesting role in Guilds?  The SK, 100%.  I wouldn't be surprised if most players are one of the more central roles from their respective games.

This does not compute. last time we lynched sudgy for those reasons he was town.

I'm actually going to Vote: sudgy. That latest post just doesn't seem to be very legitimate. concern. It'd obviously be crazy for the same SK from that game to be included on its own in this game.

This is also towny. Everyone is towny this game.

Maybe there are no scum and we win by not lynching more than 2 times or something? Come to think of it, I also didn't draw scum. Suspicious!

Seprix response to the mass claim seems too calculated to me.

It is nice to play with faust again.  Let's keep him around for at least a little bit.

Does scum say this?

bah, after that reread, haddock is still the only player who is mildly scummy. Granted,  skipped over some parts as I got bored. maybe WW looks a bit worse than before.

[silverspawn]

wait I forgot Calamitas. Let's go vote: Calamitas

Maybe tonight he'll bodyguard someone whom a town vig shoots and because the vig also bodyguarded him the vig commits suicide and we blame a mafia who is not there

[silverspawn]

Claim Time. I am not a bodyguard vig who plans on targeting Calamitas.

[J Reggie]

Claim Time. I am not a bodyguard vig who plans on targeting Calamitas.

What? Then again, neither am I.

[silverspawn]

what a coincidence! Are you also town?

[Roadrunner7671]

Claim Time. I am not a bodyguard vig who plans on targeting Calamitas.

What does that even mean? Does that just mean you can commit suicide any night?

[Archetype]

Checking in. Will have more to say here on Sunday as I'll have limited access tomorrow.

[J Reggie]

what a coincidence! Are you also town?

Yeah! Assuming you're town; otherwise the also doesn't apply. 

[iguanaiguana]

what a coincidence! Are you also town?

He's scum maybe since he did a real scum slip for real

[Roadrunner7671]

what a coincidence! Are you also town?

He's scum maybe since he did a real scum slip for real

I might put him to L-something. What do you think about that Mr. IC?

[iguanaiguana]

what a coincidence! Are you also town?

He's scum maybe since he did a real scum slip for real

I might put him to L-something. What do you think about that Mr. IC?

Let them eat cake, and have it, too.

[Roadrunner7671]

Vote: J Reggie

I think?

[mail-mi]

Vote Count 1.4

faust (2): Haddock, Witherweaver
Calamitas (2): EFHW, silverspawn
sudgy (1): Archetype
J Reggie (7): Seprix, Lalight, Calamitas, gkreig13, iguanaiguana, sudgy, Roadrunner7671
gkreig13 (2): faust, J Reggie

Not Voting (0):

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch.  Day 1 ends at 2:00 PM FT on Tuesday, September 13th.

[Roadrunner7671]

Partially unannounced L-1. So yeah. That's L-1 on J Reggie

[LaLight]

well, the forum is up!

I don't like the whole Silver's passage about "no mafia" and no-lynching twice. it looks really scummy to me. and it looks like rather unusual for Silver somehow. Why is Calamitas scummy?

And I do like L-1 on JReggie because there 10 or more pages after his scunslip and I continue to be sure it was a scumslip in fact. So

Vote: JReggie