ok have a little bit of time to spend on this game. Full reread and thoughts:
Seprix response to the mass claim seems too calculated to me.
J Reggie realizing what faust was doing is a little strange to me. Just how many old games have you read? That was pretty Sherlock of you!
Wow I really don't like the J Reggie scumslip after actually reading it. I didn't realize that those two posts were right next to each other! Seprix's handling of it seems townie though.
So I think we've heard from half of the players so far. We're definitely out of rvs now. Seprix is the one who looks the scummiest, which isn't good because he's an easy lynch as town or scum. But I think Faust and lalight are probably town.
This post from J Reggie looks even worse. It looks like he is trying to be extra super townie to make up for the scumslip.
LaLight looks town here.
It is nice to play with faust again. Let's keep him around for at least a little bit.
Then Reggie talks about all of the things he does as scum and how it is different here. I just don't really like it.
I trust iguana's claim for now. If there is evidence of SK, he is who I will be lining up to lynch first.
......and I caught up reading! So I'm done for now.
Let's lynch Reggie. And maybe hear from the other players who haven't seen the thread yet ^^
vote: ii a quick D1 is very beneficial to scum.
I mean even this post is scummy. Just trying to say things that are townie doesn't make you town.
I disagree with sudgy that players will be central roles from their games. I'm not.
I guess I had already commented on J Reggie.
EFHW seems town. I think she is more active when she is scum. She usually doesn't fly under the radar this much.
On the fence about silver from his reads list, but apparently I found him townie yesterday for doing his weird stuff again.
I still don't like LaLight's case on me, but it shows him trying to scum hunt genuinely, so town on him again.
Notable stuff about this game:
1. All roles will be taken from previous RMM games! There will be a maximum of 1 role taken from each game. Most RMM games up through RMM33 are eligible to be represented in this game. Game-specific mechanics may or may not be included, depending on how difficult they would be to implement. All roles that have a secret component have been changed slightly, to keep the secret component a secret. Other changes may be made to roles at the mod's discretion.
4. All scum/third parties may safely fake claim a town role from the game their role is from.
7. Resurrection: Due to mechanics that may or may not be present this game, it is fully possible for players to come back from the dead. Dead players will not have access to the speccy. If the chance for resurrection or other interaction with the game drops to zero, I will give them the speccy link. Resurrected players are not guaranteed be of the same alignment as before they died.
(1) implies that the alignment from the game in which the role is taken need not be consistent, but (4) implies it probably is. (7) implies that this is probably the only way in which alignment can change. Though, there could be something like a Cultist and it just isn't mentioned in the setup post.
I think (7) is about the arrested development mafia where people died twice (I think? It has been a long time since I read that game!)
I agree with WW that sudgy likes to fly under the radar as scum. I think I've only played one game with him, and he was scum in it.
Iguanaiguana is town guys. Definitely today, if not forever!
This is the only RR post I remember, which isn't good.
Haddock's long post is the nullest of nulls.
vote: J Reggie.
Author
Topic: RMM35: Rewind Mafia (Game over!) (Read 211896 times)