Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Witherweaver]

I mean, it kind of feels like he's actilurking. What do others think?

I think it's kind of like you're wrong.

[Calamitas]

My gut tells me WW is scum but I'm not sure if that's enough to warrant a vote: WW. But this early in the game I guess it's better than nothing.

I shall wear your vote as a badge of honor.

Was there a GoT themed RMM?

[J Reggie]

My gut tells me WW is scum but I'm not sure if that's enough to warrant a vote: WW. But this early in the game I guess it's better than nothing.

I shall wear your vote as a badge of honor.

Was there a GoT themed RMM?

Is that that old facebook game Gardens of Time? Or is there something else that's GoT...

Wait I just realized what you mean nevermind

[iguanaiguana]

I mean, it kind of feels like he's actilurking. What do others think?

It always feel like this from him. Have you played with him? He's a bit obtuse; he makes a lot of very clever remarks.

I'm good at reading him, I think. I'll let you know later whether he's your scumpartner or not.

[iguanaiguana]

J reggie, question for you:

If you aren't scum, how can you be so sure that there are 4 mafia?

[Witherweaver]

Obtuse and clever; that's a good combination.  Must come from all of my out-of-the-box thinking.

[iguanaiguana]

Obtuse and clever; that's a good combination.  Must come from all of my out-of-the-box thinking.

You're a fun guy to play with!

[iguanaiguana]

Obtuse and clever; that's a good combination.  Must come from all of my out-of-the-box thinking.

You're a fun guy to play with!

It'll be a while until we can put this in the out-of-context thread.

[EFHW]

Plus, look at Fruit Ninja. Every time I did something dumb I shut my mouth and no one noticed.

That's what I do.

[sudgy]

How does so much happen in a couple hours?  Anyway, first, Vote: J Reggie.  I noticed the scumslip instantly, and while he maybe could have saved it, I feel like he was flailing a lot more than he would as town.  I find this post scummy as well.

Also, with iguanaiguana, I have no idea if I believe that he's town.  He wouldn't do this if he wasn't from Guilds, but could he maybe be the SK?  I don't know.  I don't think we should treat him as an IC (or anybody, just based on a game claim).  I don't think game claims are good at all, and I don't think this one was either.

Also, consider this: Mail-mi probably was trying to get the most interesting roles from each game.  What's the most interesting role in Guilds?  The SK, 100%.  I wouldn't be surprised if most players are one of the more central roles from their respective games.

[iguanaiguana]

I do not think all roles could be the central role of its game. Plus, Moriarty died before the game started. (Who read the flavor?)

[J Reggie]

J reggie, question for you:

If you aren't scum, how can you be so sure that there are 4 mafia?

I don't know that at all, in fact I think there probably aren't.

[faust]

sudgy: Why do you think iguana's claim was bad?

[J Reggie]

How does so much happen in a couple hours?  Anyway, first, Vote: J Reggie.  I noticed the scumslip instantly, and while he maybe could have saved it, I feel like he was flailing a lot more than he would as town.  I find this post scummy as well.

Have you read any of my scum games?

Also, with iguanaiguana, I have no idea if I believe that he's town.  He wouldn't do this if he wasn't from Guilds, but could he maybe be the SK?  I don't know.  I don't think we should treat him as an IC (or anybody, just based on a game claim).  I don't think game claims are good at all, and I don't think this one was either.

Also, consider this: Mail-mi probably was trying to get the most interesting roles from each game.  What's the most interesting role in Guilds?  The SK, 100%.  I wouldn't be surprised if most players are one of the more central roles from their respective games.

I don't think that's the case. I think interesting roles yes, but central roles well you can only have so many per game.

[iguanaiguana]

J reggie, question for you:

If you aren't scum, how can you be so sure that there are 4 mafia?

I don't know that at all, in fact I think there probably aren't.

Why'd you say this then?

Any thoughts on anything, like game-origin claiming?

I think like normal, I am against such early claims. I'll start considering mass claims D2, but again, those aren't usually a good idea.

What are the odds for multiple town/scum/3rd party teams in this game, considering the size of 14 players?

Seems unlikely, 4 mafia plus an SK is a lot.

[Haddock]

The downside of game claiming is that it gives scum a chance to fakeclaim from more games than just their own.

Only if they claim last, surely.  Seems like a reasonable risk.

I dunno that I like the Reggie wagon.  I come down on the side of believing that his "slip" was intentional.

[J Reggie]

J reggie, question for you:

If you aren't scum, how can you be so sure that there are 4 mafia?

I don't know that at all, in fact I think there probably aren't.

Why'd you say this then?

Any thoughts on anything, like game-origin claiming?

I think like normal, I am against such early claims. I'll start considering mass claims D2, but again, those aren't usually a good idea.

What are the odds for multiple town/scum/3rd party teams in this game, considering the size of 14 players?

Seems unlikely, 4 mafia plus an SK is a lot.

So I had this plan, what if I faked a scumslip, how would people react? Come to think of it I should have talked about it earlier or breadcrumbed it but the opportunity seemed too ripe. But it got people talking and there are now more posts to create reads from, you're welcome.

I think if my wagon gets too scary I could claim and town would realize they shouldn't lynch me, but I'd rather not.

Ppe

[sudgy]

I do not think all roles could be the central role of its game. Plus, Moriarty died before the game started. (Who read the flavor?)

Moriarty was just flavor.  I don't think he was supposed to be a role.

Anyway, I made Guilds mafia, and I barely remember any roles other than the SK.  I think the Herald is the only other role I can remember right now.  There were some vigilantes as well, and other things?  Can't remember.  The SK was what the whole setup was built around, so he would be the obvious choice for a role from that game.


Anyway, a question for you J Reggie: if you planned your scumslip, how long did you have it planned for?

And, a question for iguanaiguana: I have a plan.  Does your role let you get any type of deathproofs (including bulletproof and lynchproof)?  You don't need to answer, but we could maybe find a way to confirm your town-ness with it.

PPE:

sudgy: Why do you think iguana's claim was bad?

Mainly because I think that it's bad for town to claim games, even in that situation.  I will admit that he does look town from some of his other posts, but I don't like the claim and I feel like mafia would be more inclined to claim like that in his situation.

[iguanaiguana]

J reggie, question for you:

If you aren't scum, how can you be so sure that there are 4 mafia?

I don't know that at all, in fact I think there probably aren't.

Why'd you say this then?

Any thoughts on anything, like game-origin claiming?

I think like normal, I am against such early claims. I'll start considering mass claims D2, but again, those aren't usually a good idea.

What are the odds for multiple town/scum/3rd party teams in this game, considering the size of 14 players?

Seems unlikely, 4 mafia plus an SK is a lot.

So I had this plan, what if I faked a scumslip, how would people react? Come to think of it I should have talked about it earlier or breadcrumbed it but the opportunity seemed too ripe. But it got people talking and there are now more posts to create reads from, you're welcome.

I think if my wagon gets too scary I could claim and town would realize they shouldn't lynch me, but I'd rather not.

Ppe

In general, if you're not Joseph2302, faking a scum claim is a bad idea. So I don't recommend going that far in your quest to appear scummy and be the center of attention.

[J Reggie]

Anyway, a question for you J Reggie: if you planned your scumslip, how long did you have it planned for?

I thought at the beginning of this game it might be a good thing to do, and then when Seprix posted that thing about third parties I realized knowing the number of mafia is kind of the perfect scumslip. Like it's something I can't back out of; either I faked it or I know it, it's not vague.

[J Reggie]

J reggie, question for you:

If you aren't scum, how can you be so sure that there are 4 mafia?

I don't know that at all, in fact I think there probably aren't.

Why'd you say this then?

Any thoughts on anything, like game-origin claiming?

I think like normal, I am against such early claims. I'll start considering mass claims D2, but again, those aren't usually a good idea.

What are the odds for multiple town/scum/3rd party teams in this game, considering the size of 14 players?

Seems unlikely, 4 mafia plus an SK is a lot.

So I had this plan, what if I faked a scumslip, how would people react? Come to think of it I should have talked about it earlier or breadcrumbed it but the opportunity seemed too ripe. But it got people talking and there are now more posts to create reads from, you're welcome.

I think if my wagon gets too scary I could claim and town would realize they shouldn't lynch me, but I'd rather not.

Ppe

In general, if you're not Joseph2302, faking a scum claim is a bad idea. So I don't recommend going that far in your quest to appear scummy and be the center of attention.

Yeah, I need to learn how to not be the center of attention as town. You hit the nail on the head ii, thanks!

[J Reggie]

We have a pretty active lineup of players I believe, which is super good for us. No notorious lurkers here.

[gkrieg13]

I think if my wagon gets too scary I could claim and town would realize they shouldn't lynch me, but I'd rather not.

Ppe

I think this is something you would say more as scum than as town.  Desire to claim doesn't get you very far seeing as each of our roles are going to be at least kind of cool.

[iguanaiguana]

Anyway, I made Guilds mafia, and I barely remember any roles other than the SK.  I think the Herald is the only other role I can remember right now.  There were some vigilantes as well, and other things?  Can't remember.  The SK was what the whole setup was built around, so he would be the obvious choice for a role from that game.

And, a question for iguanaiguana: I have a plan.  Does your role let you get any type of deathproofs (including bulletproof and lynchproof)?  You don't need to answer, but we could maybe find a way to confirm your town-ness with it.

Shouldn't I not answer this based on your own logic about it being bad for town to claim anything D1? Also, I don't think I like to claim any more about my role when you are the only one who seems to think I might be a serial killer? (who I just looked up and would be 1 x bulletproof, 1 x deathproof and have other powers of manipulation as well... How can I possibly be this crazy overpowered role?)

[Seprix]

Where has Silverscum been this game?