Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Teproc]

The above was in responde to WW.

[Witherweaver]

What makes you think EFHW is town?

[Roadrunner7671]

Entirely possible.

If anyone is scum among those three, it's you by the way. I think.

Who is this addressed to? And which 'three?'

[Roadrunner7671]

The above was in responde to WW.

Facepalm!

[Roadrunner7671]

What makes you think EFHW is town?

She's nullish. What makes you think she isn't town?

[Roadrunner7671]

Can someone point me to a game where EFHW was scum and acted similiar to her behavior now? If that makes any sense.

[Awaclus]

PPE2 : No but you should reconsider what you think to be obvious when it turns out to be wrong. And that second thing is only true if you're very confident about your initial analysis, so much so that you don't take the time to double-check by looking at the other narrative.

Basically you act as if verything was pretty simple and clear-cut, when you have been proven wrong so, so many times.

I haven't been proven wrong that many times. A lot of the times when I was "wrong", I was actually scum so those don't count. I have also been right a fair number of times.

You're not trying to find scum.

Well, I've already found scum so I don't have to try too hard until we have to find the last one.

You and Egor were both at L-2.

I wasn't under any real pressure at that point, however, while Egor could have gotten hammered if, say, I had chosen to make that happen.

Unvote
Awaclus is scummy now. Not to the point where I'd start a wagon on him, but anti-town play is...you know, anti town. Why do we think SS is scum here? Cause he's quiet?

I'm not scummy and refusing to not vote for anyone except for the scum is not anti-town (I also did that yesterday and it turned out pretty well for town).

[EgorK]

So, I believe WW because if he is scum he made situation so much worse. Suppose he is not retracting his clai, we are evntually counterclaimed, and there are 1 scum among 3 claimed PRs and 1 among 4 claimed VTs. Now worse case scenario for town other PR just claim. We'd have 2 scum among 5 claimed VTs and 2 IC. Much better for town

So you're suggesting the other PR should claim?

No, I am not, that's worst case scenario if remaining PR.

I'd like more feedback on my original post from everyone please

PPE: 2 pages

[Witherweaver]

PPE2 : No but you should reconsider what you think to be obvious when it turns out to be wrong. And that second thing is only true if you're very confident about your initial analysis, so much so that you don't take the time to double-check by looking at the other narrative.

Basically you act as if verything was pretty simple and clear-cut, when you have been proven wrong so, so many times.

I haven't been proven wrong that many times. A lot of the times when I was "wrong", I was actually scum so those don't count. I have also been right a fair number of times.

You're not trying to find scum.

Well, I've already found scum so I don't have to try too hard until we have to find the last one.

You and Egor were both at L-2.

I wasn't under any real pressure at that point, however, while Egor could have gotten hammered if, say, I had chosen to make that happen.

Unvote
Awaclus is scummy now. Not to the point where I'd start a wagon on him, but anti-town play is...you know, anti town. Why do we think SS is scum here? Cause he's quiet?

I'm not scummy and refusing to not vote for anyone except for the scum is not anti-town (I also did that yesterday and it turned out pretty well for town).

Good job voting for confirmed scum.  Let me dig out my town of the fucking year sticker for you.

[Witherweaver]

What makes you think EFHW is town?

She's nullish. What makes you think she isn't town?

I don't believe I said that she wasn't.

[Roadrunner7671]

Is this going to be a repeat of the Ash thing? Cause that's where this looks like it's headed.

Or let's consider this for two seconds: this is a mock fight between two scum
PPE

[silverspawn]

uhhh meep

[Roadrunner7671]

uhhh meep

Obviously a scum slip.

[Witherweaver]

Is this going to be a repeat of the Ash thing? Cause that's where this looks like it's headed.

Or let's consider this for two seconds: this is a mock fight between two scum
PPE

Do you think that's likely?  Which one would you rather lynch?

[silverspawn]

well, I agree with this

and that WW is town. RR is town too and I think I found EFHW towny for a particular post that she did at some point. so that only leaves a couple of players.

who am I voting for right now? unvote

[Witherweaver]

So, I believe WW because if he is scum he made situation so much worse. Suppose he is not retracting his clai, we are evntually counterclaimed, and there are 1 scum among 3 claimed PRs and 1 among 4 claimed VTs. Now worse case scenario for town other PR just claim. We'd have 2 scum among 5 claimed VTs and 2 IC. Much better for town

So you're suggesting the other PR should claim?

No, I am not, that's worst case scenario if remaining PR.

I'd like more feedback on my original post from everyone please

PPE: 2 pages

Don't we have to have a remaining PR? 

[Witherweaver]

well, I agree with this

and that WW is town. RR is town too and I think I found EFHW towny for a particular post that she did at some point. so that only leaves a couple of players.

who am I voting for right now? unvote

Can you explain why you voted Ash?

[silverspawn]

I think awaclus is good... he's remaining after PoE and he's not me.

[EgorK]

So, I believe WW because if he is scum he made situation so much worse. Suppose he is not retracting his clai, we are evntually counterclaimed, and there are 1 scum among 3 claimed PRs and 1 among 4 claimed VTs. Now worse case scenario for town other PR just claim. We'd have 2 scum among 5 claimed VTs and 2 IC. Much better for town

So you're suggesting the other PR should claim?

No, I am not, that's worst case scenario if remaining PR.

I'd like more feedback on my original post from everyone please

PPE: 2 pages

Don't we have to have a remaining PR?

Oops. That was going to be "if remaining PR is under treat of lynching"

[silverspawn]

Can you explain why you voted Ash?

yes. we can't let someone get away with quickhammering people whenever he likes to. it was a policy vote on a null read

[Teproc]

Can you explain why you voted Ash?

yes. we can't let someone get away with quickhammering people whenever he likes to. it was a policy vote on a null read

You do policy votes ?

[Teproc]

What makes you think EFHW is town?

Take a look at my post earlier today (game day) where I looked at reactions to ash vs XP. EFHW came off extremely townie in that. I thought she was scummy before doing that actually.

Also her completely flipping her read on me. A wise man once said only town does that. He's not so wise anymore, but he was (mostly) right there.

[Witherweaver]

Can you explain why you voted Ash?

yes. we can't let someone get away with quickhammering people whenever he likes to. it was a policy vote on a null read

Why not?  He's effectively hammered scum that way before.

What makes you think EFHW is town?

Take a look at my post earlier today (game day) where I looked at reactions to ash vs XP. EFHW came off extremely townie in that. I thought she was scummy before doing that actually.

Also her completely flipping her read on me. A wise man once said only town does that. He's not so wise anymore, but he was (mostly) right there.

Right.  That was my first reaction as well.  Though, EFHW would be the kind of player to plan that behavior in the scum QT.

[silverspawn]

Can you explain why you voted Ash?

yes. we can't let someone get away with quickhammering people whenever he likes to. it was a policy vote on a null read

Why not?  He's effectively hammered scum that way before.

that's not a justification. Of course he hit scum at some point. He also said I was scum when I was last scum. does that justify tunneling me every game?

I think I made my intentions pretty clear day 1.

What makes you think EFHW is town?

Take a look at my post earlier today (game day) where I looked at reactions to ash vs XP. EFHW came off extremely townie in that. I thought she was scummy before doing that actually.

Also her completely flipping her read on me. A wise man once said only town does that. He's not so wise anymore, but he was (mostly) right there.

Right.  That was my first reaction as well.  Though, EFHW would be the kind of player to plan that behavior in the scum QT.
[/quote]

[silverspawn]

well that second half was not supposed to be quoted there.