Interactions of other people with XP :
None to speak of before ash claims. So let's phrase this differently : day 2 analysis.
Vote: XP
This is immediately after ash's claim. I find this scummy. As scum, you kind of assume PRs will be believed because, well, they're right. So you can either shut up and wait to see where things go, or immediately vote. Trying to talk things out is pretty dangerous because, well, faking a town perspective is hard enough as it is, it gets even harder when it gets to believing PRs.
Obviously there's the "argue against it" option as well... anything I might say about that would amount to WIFOM, so I'll leave it there.
Okay, I know I said I wouldn't talk because I just need to crawl in a corner and die, but this is honestly stupid.
Ash seems really scummy (not that I know, cause my reads are Grade-A trash) especially with the pick A or B crap. You're not confirmed town. You'd like to think you are, but you're not. You've been a very scummy 'cop,' and Teproc makes good points. But I'm not voting until we hear from Xerxes.
PPE
Scummy as well. At this point ash is udner suspicion from me only, but that's still something scum can grasp onto, especially since RR is just putting this on me here (which, fair enough, but still I'd expect on-wagon scum to have done that to hope for another mislynch later). It's a little hedgier than I'd expect from scum though, and hesitation is townie. Not sure where RR lands here.
The hammer was not scummy. Tell me how it was scummy.
It was the shift from this, where you are very non-committal and seemingly uninspired about a Hydrad lynch:
Eh, I don't think I'd hammer. Maybe I would. Dunno.
I think I'm anti-PR claim at this point if we don't have a specific lying policy in place to WIFOM scum with.
to this, where you take Hydrad's guilt as a given and start speculating about other people with the given that Hydrad would flip scum:
I actually think only one scum would be bussing here, at most. It's early, no one would really expect a lynch to happen, no urgency to be on the wagon.
PPS with the fake vote due to fear of hammer is probably scummiest looking here.
I like awaclus as the other partner.
Hydrad - Awaclus - PPS - SS scumteam.
I would vote Hydrad. But I do not want to end the game. And seeing how ash is in the background, I would not be a bit surprised if he hammered once Hydrad is at L-1.
Oh, it was faust who said that. And he really did vote.
So town points there.
My impression is that you are being "mistakenly certain" in order to seem towny.
PPE: a bunch of posts I didn't read yet
Pretty townie. Doesn't actually adress the claim itself, focuses on my arguments against ash in general, which I think is a pretty townie approach. EFHW isn't trying to take a stance for the future, she's just trying to assess how likely ash is to be scum. Well, not so much in this post, but that's the feeling I get from it.
Okay, I know I said I wouldn't talk because I just need to crawl in a corner and die, but this is honestly stupid.
Ash seems really scummy (not that I know, cause my reads are Grade-A trash) especially with the pick A or B crap. You're not confirmed town. You'd like to think you are, but you're not. You've been a very scummy 'cop,' and Teproc makes good points. But I'm not voting until we hear from Xerxes.
PPE
You have now heard from me. What more do you want to hear? I can talk about whatever, but I'm busy and I don't want to waste time on something nobody will read.
PPE 2
I'd sort of like to hear a claim, but maybe not until someone else votes for you. You mentioned redirection, I wonder what Ashersky thinks about that...
PPE
Getting worse for RR here. Seems like he's saying *psst, remeber how we didn't lynch contradicting claims because of redirection recently ? Mabe that's our narrative to get out of this !*
Has ashersky answered Teproc's question about why he chose to investigate XP? I know he has evaded the one about what role he had that allowed him to investigate.
See above re: EFHW.
vote: ashersky
A decisive vote, as it leads ash to self-vote immediately after that. Pretty bold, but I think scum!silver is capable of it. Still, leaning town here.
Sigh...
In response to ash's self-vote. As I have the benefit of knowing I'm town, EFHW having the same reaction as me is a further indication of her towniness.
I'll ignore EFHW hereafter because she comes out the towniest out of all of this, clearly.
Vote: ash
Well, Awaclus is Awaclus, so of course he'd do this as town. Basically I think town!Awaclus has a 50% chance of posting this in taht situation (the other option being the same post with XP instead of ash), whereas scum!Awaclus has a 100% chance of postig this. Scummy then.
Okay, Teproc, I guess life goes on. Now I'm going to Vote: Ashersky. He's been a very, very scummy 'PR.'
PPE
L-1 on ash. A little bold for scum!RR I think.
And then ash self-hammers.
So :
- EFHW is obvtown
- RR is null-ish
- Awaclus and EgorK are scummy
Author
Topic: Mafia 74 - X-Shots 2 - Apocalypse Now! (Game Over) (Read 113361 times)