So here is a thought I recently had when looking at the voting pattern. 3 governments so far have been approved by 7 players (Archetype/ghost, Tables/EgorK, and Hydrad/gkrieg), I'd claim that in each of those there is at least one fascist. That leaves one fascist for faust/ADK/Grujah or a government could have been formed by two fascists.
Let's look into the options in detail
Archetype: He might be Hitler that got unlucky and drew FFF. He is probably a regular fascist that more or less resigned after getting his job done (enact a fascist law). If he is liberal, he probably cost us the game by being so inactive. Furthermore, we would need to explain why the fascists approved a liberal president, when the next player in line (Tables) is fascist (a liberal Archetype requires fascist!Tables).
ghost: Apparently I'm bad at communicating, because the consensus is that I'm fascist. At least two players consider me more fascist than Archetype, even though he enacted a fascist law. For me fascist!Archetype and fascist!ghost only makes sense if the plan was to get some credit for enacting a liberal law. I doubt that it is a good strategy, but most of the rest of the players seem to have a different idea how to play this game anyway.
Tables: It is near impossible that both he and EgorK are fascist. At that point they were ahead, so it seems ridiculous they would stage a fight compromising both. For the same reason, I doubt that either of them is Hitler. The main question is why the fascists approved Tables if he is liberal. So I maintain that liberal!Tables would imply that ADK and/or me are fascist.
EgorK: If he is fascist, he made a very dumb move that outed both Archetype and himself and will possibly get him shot. I agree that his posts appear scummy, for example his recent defense of Archetype or his small number of posts after Tables accusations. But it may be that he just suffered from being the less active and less articulate player.
Hydrad: He enacted a liberal law, so it is likely that he is not a regular fascist (though he might have drawn FLL and not have a choice). It is possible that he is Hitler, so I would avoid putting him on the government. Imho, his voting patterns are strange, but that might be his way of playing.
gkrieg: He enacted a liberal law at a point, where I guess a regular fascist would have sacrificed to get a fascist law in play, so probably not a regular fascist. Similar to Hydrad, he may be Hitler playing liberal. Because he didn't get approved in round 1, I have a better opinion of him than of Hydrad.
Of the remaining players, I expect the fascist rather among faust/ADK, because they were approved whereas Grujah was not involved in any government, yet. It may be that Grujah is Hitler though. Which of faust/ADK is fascist depends on the alignment of Tables.
Summarizing my reads
Regular fascist: Archetype > Tables >> faust > EgorK >> ADK > Grujah > Hydrad > gkrieg
Hitler: Hydrad > gkrieg >> Grujah > faust > ADK >> Archetype >> Tables > EgorK
@Grujah: So while I would prefer EgorK to Tables as chancellor, in the interest of proposing a government that actually gets a majority, I'd ask you to appoint Tables.
Author
Topic: Secret Hitler I [Round 12] (Read 73309 times)