Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Ichimaru Gin]

I've never played IRL Mafia and I don't really have any desire to.

What, specifically do you find less enjoyable/not enjoyable about forum mafia? This is just one game after all, they tend to vary a fair amount due to who is playing and the setup, etc.

Also, that kind of sucks if you stopped playing to your wincon. If what you say is true, it's pretty difficult to differentiate that motivation (or lack thereof) from scum. It's not even something that would be on my radar. Why didn't you say anything earlier?

[LibraryAdventurer]

I've never played IRL Mafia and I don't really have any desire to.
What, specifically do you find less enjoyable/not enjoyable about forum mafia? This is just one game after all, they tend to vary a fair amount due to who is playing and the setup, etc.

For one thing, the game takes weeks instead of an hour or two. hmmm, probably the thing I like most about IRL mafia is the hanging out with people I like while playing a game. And hanging out on a forum just doesn't compare to hanging out with people IRL (not that I don't like the people here).

Also, that kind of sucks if you stopped playing to your wincon.

sorry. But as I said I can't read who's lying by words on a page, especially when I don't know these people. I still haven't a clue who's really mafia, so it's kinda hard to play to my wincon.

If what you say is true,

Which thing was that? I've said contradicting things...

it's pretty difficult to differentiate that motivation (or lack thereof) from scum. It's not even something that would be on my radar. Why didn't you say anything earlier?

say anything about what now? 
you mean claim mafia?  As I said, I was offered my choice of food so I claimed mafia. Now that I've eaten (and on deathrow where it doesn't matter much anyway), I revert to claiming town.

[Ichimaru Gin]

I mean say anything about how you weren't really enjoying the game so much. I don't know about others, but that wouldn't have especially bothered me. It's probably for the best you got lynched if you weren't having fun, and it's likely you would have gotten lynched regardless. Still, having the knowledge that you weren't really interested in the game anymore could have been helpful.

Eh. It probably worked out for the best, I'll be dissapointed if you're town though. Not dissapointed in you, just that sad you didn't flip scum when I was sure you would.

[faust]

Well, regardless of alignment, I really don't like the attitude, if you're not having fun, you can always replace out instead of hurting the faction you're supposed to play with. If you're town, that seriously sucked for us. And if you're scum, well that's still not the way I want to win games.

Oh, and of course vote: No lynch

[silverspawn]

+++

[xxpittip]

<enjoys his steak and lobster in the meantime>

So... now that I've had my meal, I'll confess I only claimed mafia for the food. I'm really town.

Vote: Library
We can still NoLynch later, there is no reason to keep a claimed scum player alive.

[silverspawn]

<enjoys his steak and lobster in the meantime>

So... now that I've had my meal, I'll confess I only claimed mafia for the food. I'm really town.

Vote: Library
We can still NoLynch later, there is no reason to keep a claimed scum player alive.

I think you're a page behind

[Seprix]

<enjoys his steak and lobster in the meantime>

So... now that I've had my meal, I'll confess I only claimed mafia for the food. I'm really town.

Vote: Library
We can still NoLynch later, there is no reason to keep a claimed scum player alive.

Witherweaver claimed D1. I'm pretty sure nobody but me cared. Why do people care about jokes now?

[Hydrad]

<enjoys his steak and lobster in the meantime>

So... now that I've had my meal, I'll confess I only claimed mafia for the food. I'm really town.

Vote: Library
We can still NoLynch later, there is no reason to keep a claimed scum player alive.

Witherweaver claimed D1. I'm pretty sure nobody but me cared. Why do people care about jokes now?

Well to me joking day 1 in while nothings happened isn't very scummy. It can get scummier as the game progresses. But thats just my opinion so not sure how everyone else feels about it.

[silverspawn]

Mod: do we get a confirmation of whether or not the lynch was successful?

[LibraryAdventurer]

Well, regardless of alignment, I really don't like the attitude, if you're not having fun, you can always replace out instead of hurting the faction you're supposed to play with. If you're town, that seriously sucked for us. And if you're scum, well that's still not the way I want to win games.

Man, I didn't stop trying until I was already being lynched.  I don't see why that's so bad.
I really am sorry if I messed up the game for anyone.

[Hydrad]

Well, regardless of alignment, I really don't like the attitude, if you're not having fun, you can always replace out instead of hurting the faction you're supposed to play with. If you're town, that seriously sucked for us. And if you're scum, well that's still not the way I want to win games.

Man, I didn't stop trying until I was already being lynched.  I don't see why that's so bad.
I really am sorry if I messed up the game for anyone.

I think thats fine. I don't think you messed anything up.

[silverspawn]

note that scum has a lot of motivation to keep pretending until he is lynched, which means we can't entirely trust LA. Unfortunately, though, I think it sounds rather sincere.

In that case, we should consider having the page claim. If it's on a scummy player, we might want to double lynch after all, because 0/2 loses the game.

[faust]

note that scum has a lot of motivation to keep pretending until he is lynched, which means we can't entirely trust LA. Unfortunately, though, I think it sounds rather sincere.

In that case, we should consider having the page claim. If it's on a scummy player, we might want to double lynch after all, because 0/2 loses the game.

Eh. Page claiming pretty much makes the whole point of choosing Page pointless though. I mean, we chose it to get a pseudo-Cop N3. Having him claim now nullifies that.

...I said Page wasn't a great card, right?

Anyway, lynching the Page guarantees another Day, I guess, so Grey must be in love with that plan. But if the Page is on scum, they of course can simply not claim. In which case we know what's what at least.

Man, I feel like both choices are equally bad.

[Witherweaver]

I'm VLA for the next few weeks (until May 22).  I will still have some access.

Faust, are you certain that No Lynch is better than lynching your top scum read?

For now,

Vote: No Lynch

[silverspawn]

I'm VLA for the next few weeks (until May 22).  I will still have some access.

Faust, are you certain that No Lynch is better than lynching your top scum read?

For now,

Vote: No Lynch

is your avatar change permanent? I identified you so much with your old avatar.

[Witherweaver]

Now you may identify me with my new avatar.

Old avatar did have the fundamental flaw that no one could read it.

[silverspawn]

Now you may identify me with my new avatar.

Old avatar did have the fundamental flaw that no one could read it.

there was text on it?

[Witherweaver]

[Ichimaru Gin]

I remember asking you about it when you first got an avatar. You linked me to a larger version of it; iirc it was from a tv show?
Wow, that must have been all the way back in House of Cards

[GreyICE]

Yay, so we didn't lynch the guy with the obvious fakeclaim, and instead lynched town.  Faust makes a nice long speech about how it sucks to win as scum that way, then votes No Lynch - in the situation that if page is scum, we have now lost.

Vote: Silverspawn

[faust]

Yay, so we didn't lynch the guy with the obvious fakeclaim, and instead lynched town.  Faust makes a nice long speech about how it sucks to win as scum that way, then votes No Lynch - in the situation that if page is scum, we have now lost.

Vote: Silverspawn

I don't quite understand how your vote is tied to the paragraph before it.

[XerxesPraelor]

LibraryAdventurer is successfully lynched, but the sun hangs suspended just over the horizon. There's still some day left - enough for another lynch!

[silverspawn]

good. except we don't another lynch.

[Seprix]

We don't?