relevant and totally wrong imo. of course scumslips do exist. if a new player is scum in his first game, and does the first vote with <b>vote: twilight</b>, that would be a massive scumslip. this is the reason why, in fish mafia, ash actually posted a warning about brackets in the QT.
Also, I did read your post about scum slips a while ago, and you're not really arguing for why they don't exist so much as for why they are really rare. That's why people disagreed with you despite saying that you made the better argument. To be more specific, #3 in your post is the reason why scum slips are super rare, #2 doesn't apply here and #1 is, well, the thing.
In this game, if it weren't for the other thing, i would instantly vote for you. as is, I'm not sure. I don't like your reaction though, I would have preferred it if you made the argument about the other thing instead of saying scum slips don't exist.