Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[silverspawn]

so, whoever wants to reread hydrad, it has never been easier than now.

[liopoil]

Unvote

[silverspawn]

well the most surprising thing for me is that i found him scummy in day 1 tbh. strong town read now.

i hope this doesn't look like i'm defending my scum buddy. it might be something i would do as scum. although you could come to different conclusions by rereading him, so maybe i wouldn't. in any case, he seems towny to me.

so, i'll cross hydrad cus of what i just said, me because i know im town, kingzog because he also seems towny, lio because chairs was literally just lurking the entire time, so we have zero information about him, and lynching lio now seems like a pure random, and we should do better than that, sudgy and TA because they're dead, and SK cus he's a mason

1. Robz888
2. Hydrad
3. silverspawn
4. jotheonah
5. Eevee
6. Kingzog3
7. Witherweaver
8. liopoil
9. Voltaire
10. XerxesPraelor
11. sudgy
12. SK
13. Twistedarcher


that leaves

1. Robz888
4. jotheonah
5. Eevee
7. Witherweaver
9. Voltaire
10. XerxesPraelor

[silverspawn]

oh yea and unvote

I should probably just do the same thing on one of the remaining 6. not including robz, because there's not much to go on. if voltaire is scum, he has played it really well, but we can't really lynch him based on that.

[KingZog3]

(All of hydrads posts)

So, you post all of his posts but don't offer your opinion on any of them? I mean, this could just be a kindness to make things easy for everyone, but why do it only for one guy and then not even comment on even some of the posts? "Here's" all his posts, clearly they're scummy so vote him!" is what that says to me and I don't really like that from a town perspective. I'd rather some reasons to accompany the posts. I'm not changing my vote yet, but maybe if you post some comments about those Hydrad posts I'll could see if you're town or not and if Hydrad is too.

[Robz888]

voltaire said, just assuming you are town is the worst thing ever, don't you see that?

maybe i'm too used to these? i didn't even realize it was a triple neg., it just read like a normal sentence to me

But it's a straw man because I didn't ask him to just assume I'm town, I insisted I was town and offered a rationale for that. If he thinks, for whatever reason, it's best to just assume I'm scum, okay lynch me, there's nothing I can say. That thinking is, uh, wrong though.

[silverspawn]

(All of hydrads posts)

So, you post all of his posts but don't offer your opinion on any of them? I mean, this could just be a kindness to make things easy for everyone, but why do it only for one guy and then not even comment on even some of the posts? "Here's" all his posts, clearly they're scummy so vote him!" is what that says to me and I don't really like that from a town perspective. I'd rather some reasons to accompany the posts. I'm not changing my vote yet, but maybe if you post some comments about those Hydrad posts I'll could see if you're town or not and if Hydrad is too.

well, that's what i wanted to do originally, and then i realized that they the compilation is too long to do that (i have to go in exactly 1 hour, and have to do some packing), so i wasn't even sure if I should post it at all, which i wrote too. but in the end there is no reason not to post, you can just ignore it if you want. so i just read through it really quickly and posted my conclusion. which, of course, is the opposite of what you are saying.

[liopoil]

My initial inclination is to vote for XP. Robz's post today was entirely accurate and I have no idea why he hasn't been lynched yet... but I have not yet read every post in this thread (I've read most of them I think), so I'll wait until later. Robz is also pretty scummy.

[liopoil]

Really I would have hammered XP yesterday as soon as he claimed doctor.

[silverspawn]

you are a watchtower, so i you hammer XP, does he go on top of your deck?

[silverspawn]

*if

[silverspawn]

to clarify, i was trying to do a "I'm not even getting the card mechanics right, this is so stupid" joke. it doesn't seem to be funny though, maybe it gets funnier by explaining it? no? okay :c

[Witherweaver]

Unvote

Robz you have to realize the "I'm town, I wouldn't play this poorly as scum" defense is not a very convincing one.  And that you make that defense as town means you would make it as scum, too.

[Eevee]

vote: Hydrad

thank you for reminding me, silverspawn.

I think silverspawn is playing a very towny game here.

[Witherweaver]

vote: Hydrad

thank you for reminding me, silverspawn.

I think silverspawn is playing a very towny game here.

So, what do you think Hydrad is?  I think Mafia doesn't claim 1-shot Vig.  SK may.

[Voltaire]

Catching up now.

joth, that's about the 54,221th time you've said you "feel unsure" about me and need to re-read me. Are you loving the idea of mislynching Volt but don't want to press a fakecase if you don't have support? Because it's really starting to feel that way.

[silverspawn]

well if im not funny im at least towny. cant have everything.

i'll go now but i'll have internet where i go... i hope. and think. if not, I'll probably miss the deadline. i'll come back on sunday.

bye

[jotheonah]

vote: Hydrad

thank you for reminding me, silverspawn.

I think silverspawn is playing a very towny game here.

I'm starting to feel like silverspawn is trying too hard, actually. Sometimes he seems REALLY towny. Other times he seems to have an almost ... forced joviality. I think I find him scummy.

No idea what to make of Robz, as usual.

Liking Voltaire less and less and starting to see how WW might be scum, too (he's posted a lot in a very towny way, but what has he really contributed? What stands has he really taken?

So, liopoil, why do you think XP is lying? If you do think XP is lying, why do you think he named such a weird protection target?

[Voltaire]

Okay.
Why are we voting chairs if he is going to be replaced?
And…Robz is right, he deserves to be lynched. Then he goes on to say that hes town because he was lurking? Aka he is town because he is acting anti-town? This is either bad policy, or scum. I really dont care about his meta. vote: Robz

This, Robz, is a more clear version of what I was saying. Except I think you're using your meta to hide unapologetic scum play.

[Voltaire]

Wait people are voting for silver and Hydrad now? what is going on

[jotheonah]

Catching up now.

joth, that's about the 54,221th time you've said you "feel unsure" about me and need to re-read me. Are you loving the idea of mislynching Volt but don't want to press a fakecase if you don't have support? Because it's really starting to feel that way.

I think it's the third time, but thanks for making it clear that you feel more pressure on yourself than actually exists. That is the classic-ist of scum tells.

Honestly, I just haven't gotten around to actually doing the re-read yet. But you know what? Vote: Voltaire

[Voltaire]

vote: Hydrad

thank you for reminding me, silverspawn.

I think silverspawn is playing a very towny game here.

No, this is very bad. Hydrad is the IC who is not actually an IC but really is person in this game. There's no way the way his claim went down it's not true. At least no way that we should seriously consider today. I think this is a very bad place to vote.

[Voltaire]

joth, that's about the 54,221th time you've said you "feel unsure" about me and need to re-read me. Are you loving the idea of mislynching Volt but don't want to press a fakecase if you don't have support? Because it's really starting to feel that way.

I think it's the third time, but thanks for making it clear that you feel more pressure on yourself than actually exists. That is the classic-ist of scum tells.

Honestly, I just haven't gotten around to actually doing the re-read yet. But you know what? Vote: Voltaire

I actually don't feel any pressure on my self at all, thank you very much. Just noticed a weird hedging you were doing about me, and felt it needed to be called out. Also, WW started doing the same thing I believe, so no, it's not just you.

Also, I would like everyone to note that what joth did here is OMGUS after I pointed out his behavior.

vote: joth

[Voltaire]

also I am back to silver is 99% town, don't anyone dare vote him.

[Voltaire]

This is beautiful.