Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Witherweaver]

I think Xerxes is reiterating the question of why Sudgy is voting for Silverspawn with a seemingly genuine vote.  I asked the same question, and I don't think Sudgy ever answered.

I don't like the case on Xerxes here.  I'm going with town for now.  Slight suspicion on Joth, somewhat null on Zog.

Let's lynch Hydrad?

[KingZog3]

I think Xerxes is reiterating the question of why Sudgy is voting for Silverspawn with a seemingly genuine vote.  I asked the same question, and I don't think Sudgy ever answered.

I don't like the case on Xerxes here.  I'm going with town for now.  Slight suspicion on Joth, somewhat null on Zog.

Let's lynch Hydrad?

By pointing this out, it looks like XP is trying to build a case on sudgy. Except I think it's safe to assume Sudgy is a mason, since that claim is to ballsy is both sudgy and SK are scum, and I don't think they would be willing to risk that much on a move like that (although it's brilliant if they are scum, since it has people convinced). It just doesn't feel relevant to the defence he had before, which isn't even a big defence since he falsely claimed he told us about the masons. He didn't tell about the sudgy/SK connection. I can't find  post where he tells us about it, or even addresses it directly, so until he can explain why he said that, I'm keeping my vote on him.

Since I'm gone for the weekend, leaving tomorrow, if he doesn't reply tonight, don't examine my continued vote on XP for the weekend if I'm still voting for him. I won't have internet access so I'll change it Monday if he replies on the weekend.

[silverspawn]

I don't think the case on Xer is that bad. however, I'll rather vote:Twistedarcher until he does a little bit more/stops being overly cautious.

[sudgy]

I agree with the case on Xerxes, and his defense seemed a little long, so Vote: XerxesPraelor

[XerxesPraelor]

I quoted that post as an example of a post I made that joth called RVS.

[XerxesPraelor]

KingZog,

I noticed the sudgy/SK connection and thought it meant they were scum partners defending eachother. This was before the accidental mason claim. Eevee deserves very little credit for pointing something that obvious out.

[XerxesPraelor]

I agree with the case on Xerxes, and his defense seemed a little long, so Vote: XerxesPraelor

What kind of reason is that?

[XerxesPraelor]

Sudgy/SK scumteam??

Here's where I mentioned their connection. I had no reason to think they were masons at that point (masons are rather unlikely) so I concluded a scumteam would be a possible explanation.

[XerxesPraelor]

Rereading my non-sudgy voters, joth looks scummy partially for driving the sudgy wagon, as well as miscellaneous things like "if I were scum" and other stuff I'll make clear later while KingZog's OMGUS incident is very towny to me.

[Eevee]

Not sold on Xerxes, although I don't have town read either.

Vote: Hydrad He feels off. I haven't reread though.

[jotheonah]

unofficial vote count, just because there has been a lot of voting since the last one:

Eevee (2): Hydrad, XP
Robz888 (2): chairs, Voltaire
Hydrad (2): Witherweaver, Eevee
jotheonah (1): SK
XerxesPraelor (3): jotheonah, Kingzog3, sudgy
TwistedArcher (1): silverspawn

Not Voting (2): Robz888, Twistedarcher

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

Day 1 ends at 6:00pm FT on September 2nd.

[Hydrad]

Not sold on Xerxes, although I don't have town read either.

Vote: Hydrad He feels off. I haven't reread though.

Hmm I find it interesting that you think I feel "off". If you do find weird posts I can try to adrress them but there really shouldn't be anything different about my play as I'm still town.

[silverspawn]

you always feel off to me because of your avatar. it looks scummy.

[Hydrad]

Vote: xp

I think the case on him is pretty good for day1 interactions.

But now I'm just going to wait because I'm sure ww will find this vote scummy somehow

[XerxesPraelor]

Vote: xp

I think the case on him is pretty good for day1 interactions.

But now I'm just going to wait because I'm sure ww will find this vote scummy somehow

What's wrong with my defense?

[silverspawn]

Vote: xp

I think the case on him is pretty good for day1 interactions.

But now I'm just going to wait because I'm sure ww will find this vote scummy somehow

What's wrong with my defense?

it's scummy

[XerxesPraelor]

II'm not getting anywhere, am I?

[Witherweaver]

II'm not getting anywhere, am I?

You're convincing me you're town!

[jotheonah]

Would it be too much trouble to ask the Hydrad voters to lay out their case in one post so we can compare the merits of the two cases more easily? I'm certainly not against a Hydrad lynch, but I do think I like XP better right now.

[Hydrad]

Would it be too much trouble to ask the Hydrad voters to lay out their case in one post so we can compare the merits of the two cases more easily? I'm certainly not against a Hydrad lynch, but I do think I like XP better right now.

I would also like to know. Eevee is pretty much voting me because I feel weird. And not 100% sure why ww is so ready to lynch me.

[Eevee]

Reread Hydrad. Basically all his posts after RVS are about the mason claim, which means his biggest contribution is the weird suspicion on me that still doesn't make sense to me. Very little actual content, and even that quite scummy. I like my vote.

[Witherweaver]

Would it be too much trouble to ask the Hydrad voters to lay out their case in one post so we can compare the merits of the two cases more easily? I'm certainly not against a Hydrad lynch, but I do think I like XP better right now.

I would also like to know. Eevee is pretty much voting me because I feel weird. And not 100% sure why ww is so ready to lynch me.

I'm sure if you go check you're alignment PM you'll figure it out!

[Hydrad]

Would it be too much trouble to ask the Hydrad voters to lay out their case in one post so we can compare the merits of the two cases more easily? I'm certainly not against a Hydrad lynch, but I do think I like XP better right now.

I would also like to know. Eevee is pretty much voting me because I feel weird. And not 100% sure why ww is so ready to lynch me.

I'm sure if you go check you're alignment PM you'll figure it out!

Went back and checked for you. Still saying town!

[Witherweaver]

Would it be too much trouble to ask the Hydrad voters to lay out their case in one post so we can compare the merits of the two cases more easily? I'm certainly not against a Hydrad lynch, but I do think I like XP better right now.

I would also like to know. Eevee is pretty much voting me because I feel weird. And not 100% sure why ww is so ready to lynch me.

I'm sure if you go check you're alignment PM you'll figure it out!

Went back and checked for you. Still saying town!

Maybe you're misreading.. and color blind.

[Hydrad]

Reread Hydrad. Basically all his posts after RVS are about the mason claim, which means his biggest contribution is the weird suspicion on me that still doesn't make sense to me. Very little actual content, and even that quite scummy. I like my vote.

Hmm so I guess i'll explain why I thought you calling out the masons was weird. This is probably with my inexperience with this game so I could be totally wrong but here is what I would of done.

So if you figured out they are masons I guess what I would of done if I noticed that was keep quiet and see how people react. Maybe there will be a couple people that will try pushing a SK/sudgy scum team trying to get a easy mislynch? Or we might even get lucky and scum might not realize they are masons and SK and sudgy might be able to stay alive longer into the game where the mason claim will help out even more.

But I realize this relys heavily on the fact that other people wouldn't notice that they were masons. For me it made sense to not call them out right away because I didn't even consider them being masons as a option. So I do think I agree now with your choice of calling them out. I guess I just thought it was less obvious then it really was and was just hoping scum wouldn't figure it out.