Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Axxle]

vote: no lynch.
scum'll either get rid of me or robz, or one of the suspects iwll be down.

If it's best to no lynch, it's probably also best for scott to no kill.

Vote: Scott

[Axxle]

vote: no lynch.
scum'll either get rid of me or robz, or one of the suspects iwll be down.

If it's best to no lynch, it's probably also best for scott to no kill.

Vote: Scott

Especially since I have to convince TWO people he's scum, rather than just one.

[Robz888]

robz, why aren't you dead.

Because scum wants us to start considering the possibility he's scum, it's just WIFOM.  Also, because killing the doc is safe.

No, that's not why. Killing shraeye was scum's optimal move, no matter what. Shraeye was a one-shot Doc. No one knew whether shraeye had used that shot or not. Scum can't both block mail-mi AND shraeye. Scum NEEDS to block mail-mi and shoot the one person shraeye can't protect, which is shraeye himself.

I believe Axxle would have certainly thought of this, but Scott--a relative newbie--might not have. So I guess that's another small, small point in favor of lynching Axxle.

But regardless, I'm just going to keep my promise. My reads have been sufficiently off, anyway. Whereas shraeye has been right on about everything, and we now know he is town.

Vote: Axxle.

(I'm sure this means it's actually Scott, because that will be the most demoralizing thing, but oh well.)

[mail-mi]

well. i guess I'm deciding, huh?

robz, why aren't you dead.

Because scum wants us to start considering the possibility he's scum, it's just WIFOM.  Also, because killing the doc is safe.

No, that's not why. Killing shraeye was scum's optimal move, no matter what. Shraeye was a one-shot Doc. No one knew whether shraeye had used that shot or not. Scum can't both block mail-mi AND shraeye. Scum NEEDS to block mail-mi and shoot the one person shraeye can't protect, which is shraeye himself.

I believe Axxle would have certainly thought of this, but Scott--a relative newbie--might not have. So I guess that's another small, small point in favor of lynching Axxle.

But regardless, I'm just going to keep my promise. My reads have been sufficiently off, anyway. Whereas shraeye has been right on about everything, and we now know he is town.

Vote: Axxle.

(I'm sure this means it's actually Scott, because that will be the most demoralizing thing, but oh well.)

your'e right, and scott probably would be too newbish to figure that out,

still harboring doubts tho,

what shoudl I do, auuuugggh!

[Axxle]

Scott said "Because killing the doc is safe"

He figured it out to at least that extent.

[Robz888]

Well, nice to know for sure you're not scum.

I'd say just lynch Axxle. We can't not do what shraeye wants after all that, unless we were so overridingly convinced about Scott. And we won't be.

[Robz888]

Well, nice to know for sure you're not scum.

I'd say just lynch Axxle. We can't not do what shraeye wants after all that, unless we were so overridingly convinced about Scott. And we won't be.

This was in reference to mail-mi's post.

[Robz888]

Scott said "Because killing the doc is safe"

He figured it out to at least that extent.

That's true.

Still, shraeye has been right about everything and we promised him and I don't see how we could not listen to him, especailyl when I'm basically 50/50 on them at this point.

[Axxle]

Vote: No Lynch

That's a hammer I believe.

[Axxle]

Sorry, I can't risk mailmi losing the game here. This buys a bit more time.

[mail-mi]

Well, nice to know for sure you're not scum.

I'd say just lynch Axxle. We can't not do what shraeye wants after all that, unless we were so overridingly convinced about Scott. And we won't be.

This was in reference to mail-mi's post.

ah ah ah ah i don't know hwt to do....

[mail-mi]

Vote: No Lynch

That's a hammer I believe.

no it's not. 3 to lynch.

unvote

[mail-mi]

Well, nice to know for sure you're not scum.

I'd say just lynch Axxle. We can't not do what shraeye wants after all that, unless we were so overridingly convinced about Scott. And we won't be.

This was in reference to mail-mi's post.

ah ah ah ah i don't know hwt to do....

*what

[Axxle]

I've been thinking of the kills each day, and there is no way I'd have advocated them. Andrew was a newbie that wouldn't have done much during the game even if he was a strong power role. Then Eevee seemed like a stroke of luck although he might have been approaching IC status because of robz's comments at the end of the day? Not sure. Shraeye not dying even though he pegged yuma early would not have been something I let go. People forget the dead's reads so much more than living players.

[Axxle]

Vote: No Lynch

That's a hammer I believe.

no it's not. 3 to lynch.

unvote

3 to lynch, that means 2 people is all that it takes to agree to no lynch before a lynch is impossible. (I haven't No Lynched on this site before so maybe we do it differently here)

[Robz888]

We generally do "No Lynch" as taking the same amount of votes as Lynch.

[Robz888]

Mail-mi, please hammer Axxle now.

[mail-mi]

AAAAAHHHHH i hate being in this position!

shraeye has been so right about everyone else...but he was completely wrong on me...

I had a earlier scumread on scotty....

Robz didn't die,...

UUUGGGGHHHH.

[Robz888]

Okay, mail-mi, I understand what you are saying but like you gotta just hammer Axxle now. We promised, and there's no reason to think shraeye was wrong.

[Axxle]

Mailmi, your instincts have been pretty spot on all game too. You were on scum days 1 and 2 and didn't mislynch mcmc. I wish I trusted myself on scott earlier too.

Robz. We've been on mislynch after mislynch after you've stated these hard facts on what we are doing today without budging an inch. It'd be helpful if you listened to the other players this game.

[Axxle]

"but now I'm listening to shraeye"
no. You're listening to yourself and just happen to have shraeye there as an excuse.

[Robz888]

Mailmi, your instincts have been pretty spot on all game too. You were on scum days 1 and 2 and didn't mislynch mcmc. I wish I trusted myself on scott earlier too.

Robz. We've been on mislynch after mislynch after you've stated these hard facts on what we are doing today without budging an inch. It'd be helpful if you listened to the other players this game.

I am listening to the other players now. That's why I am lynching you. I listened to no one else for the last two days and was wrong--despite my own certainty--both times.

[Robz888]

"but now I'm listening to shraeye"
no. You're listening to yourself and just happen to have shraeye there as an excuse.

This is simply not true.

[Teproc]

Vote Count 5.1:

Axxle (2) : scott_pilgrim, Robz888
No lynch (1) : Axxle

Not Voting (1): mail-mi

With 4 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.

Day 5 will end in ten days, on April 2 at 5:40 p.m.

[mail-mi]

Mailmi, your instincts have been pretty spot on all game too. You were on scum days 1 and 2 and didn't mislynch mcmc. I wish I trusted myself on scott earlier too.

Robz. We've been on mislynch after mislynch after you've stated these hard facts on what we are doing today without budging an inch. It'd be helpful if you listened to the other players this game.

axxle is making some pretty good points.

auggh i hate this so much. well, I'm glad i survived (that doesn't usually happen) but i hate this position.