Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[pingpongsam]

That yuma hasn't posted is a great sign.

[Robz888]

It is a great sign. You aren't obvscum but you are definitely the leading scum candidate, and if yuma IS scum we can afford like a million mislynches, starting with you, then mcmc, etc.

[Axxle]

But really I don't want have this conversation right now. Or any other. Flip please?

Isn't ash one of those Australian blokes? Probably just getting up.

[ashersky]

Thread locked.

[ashersky]

Day 2 Final Vote Count:

yuma (6): shraeye, mail-mi, Robz888, Eevee, Axxle, pingpongsam
PPS (2): mcmcsalot, yuma

Not Voting (2): scott_pilgrim, A Drowned Kernel

With 10 alive, it took 6 to lynch.

[ashersky]

Everyone was sooooo sure of themselves, now that they had figured out the way to solve this terrible mystery.  After all, the Ice King had been evil, and they kicked him out of the party right away!  So there was little discussion today.

"It's her!  That big, long horse girl!  She was just a little too nice to the Ice King," someone yelled.

They were talking about Lady Rainicorn.  She looked at them sideways, a bit upset and huffy to be pointed at like that.  "Well I never!  What a horrible thing to say.  You know, I don't even want to be at your party anymore, Finn!  I have to go to visit my friend the Princess of VLAnd anyway.  You won't hear from me for days!"  Lady Rainicorn was headed for the door.

"Oh no you don't!  You are drinking this first!"  Finn rushed at Lady Rainicorn and made her drink the brown goo...

yuma, inhabiting the body of Lady Rainicorn, has been sent to sleepy town!  He was the Mafia Godfather!

[ashersky]

Night 2 has begun.  Night actions are due in 24 hours.  Day Three will begin 24 hours (or so) after that.

[ashersky]

Night action submission deadline has passed.  Day 3 in 24 hours.

[ashersky]

It was another nice night of sleep in the treehouse, what with one more bad guy removed from the party.  Everyone was feeling pretty great about things when the sun came up.

Everyone, that is, except The Lich.

Thing is, he was gone.  The Lich is pretty big, so his body not being immediately noticed was somewhat odd.  Jake and Finn took a look at the door, and saw Smudge standing there.

"He's ours now, man.  This dude knows just a little too much about...apples."

Eevee, inhabiting the body of The Lich, was removed from the party at night!  He was a Cop!

[ashersky]

Day 3 has begun.  It ends in 10 days.

[pingpongsam]

Son of Balls!. We needed the cop so effing bad and I am almost certain he copped me last night which was exactly the plan to get some ICs on board for the win. Now we just have a disheveled mess.

I'm not 100% Robz isn't scum. His early play looks awfully Towny but his must lynch PPS position has me on edge. I would not put it past Robz to bus both his partners D1 and D2 but at this point I won't lynch him because I think there are way better possibilities.

The only good news from the Eevee flip is that he was one of the remaining players I was really on the fence about. scotty is the other one.

Vote: ADK

I feel he is practically certain to be scum.

Really bummed our copped got sniped because his results today were going to win this game for us.

[pingpongsam]

I had prepared a rebuttal to Robz' lynch PPS position but had become certain we were gonna get cop results today and I was certain I'd get copped and no way Mafia would NK me because I am the easy mislynch today.

I will work on repositing my reasons why autolynching me is not a good idea because I am clearly not the one behaving as scum, just erratically.

Also, I will reiterate a clear case on ADK, I know it began with looking off-wagon D1 and an earlier re-read pushed him to the top of my list. I remember Eevee was interested in an ADK lynch and I think that might be why he was chosen for the NK.

[Axxle]

Vote: PPS

Robz is confirmed

robz is definitely a town read though.

[pingpongsam]

Vote: PPS

Robz is confirmed

robz is definitely a town read though.

Good pick up on Eevee's Robz result. That doesn't mean I am for sure scum, though. Show me the outright, condemning scum has to do what PPS did here behavior. AFAIK it doesn't exist. Yes, I've been erratic and the point was to get copped and to also get a full read on yuma one of which succeeded.

Firing up the wagon on me at this point doesn't draw scum out, hell that scum can easily stay off the wagon as easy as I can be lynched today. So flipping me just loses the flawless win there is no information to be gained.

[pingpongsam]

Okay, I reread ADK and with the informationw e have from the current flips he's the final scum, there is no doubt. His negotaition of the D1 raerae wagon has scum wirtten all over it. His reads list cover his partners. His reluctance to hammer yuma was a disheartened recognition that he might have to do it for the cred and pray he can make the rest of the game alone.

My negotiation of yuma yesterday makes ZERO SENSE for me to do as his scum partner. Sure, the final hammer for cred but the whole antagonizing thing I did?! No way yuma's remaining scum partner plays that way. Robz appears to be copped by Eevee so I'm saying he has tunnel goggles on. I want to see some damn good explanation for how Town thinks I am yuma's partner after yesterday's display.

If you just have to see my flip then please, for god's sakes, kill ADK tomorrow.

[ashersky]

Vote Count 3.1:

ADK (1): pingpongsam
PPS (1): Axxle

Not Voting (6): scott_pilgrim, Robz888, mail-mi, mcmcsalot, A Drowned Kernel, shraeye

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Day 3 ends at 5:20 p.m. on Wednesday, March 19.

[shraeye]

Vote: PPS

Robz is confirmed

robz is definitely a town read though.

why vote PPS?

[Axxle]

Isn't that what we talked about yesterday?

I might reread scott though.

[mcmcsalot]

Vote: PPS

Robz is confirmed

robz is definitely a town read though.

why vote PPS?

Yesss, vote: pps

[mcmcsalot]

Re quoting my whole case on pps from yesterday.

I cannot believe you people ruined my birthday party.

BMO claim post one?

Vote: pingpongsam

Right, flavor names have zero to do with alignment because of the goo or something. So, yeah, I'm BMO and you continue to ruin my party for completely unsound reasons like not having paid any attention to what is going on around here. You know who doesn't need to pay much attention? scumbags.

Vote: Axxle

Yup really scummy.

I think we should lynch one of the new guys just to help him grow the thick skin he's gonna need moving forward.

Vote: Andrew

Aha! And then Andrew dies, what was that about suspicion early means they wot get lynched later?

Pps and Yuma/robz remaining scum?(they are the huge omg early suspicions makes you invicible)

I think we should lynch one of the new guys just to help him grow the thick skin he's gonna need moving forward.

Vote: Andrew

Somewhat of a townread on PPS based off this post. A desire to kill off newbies has often resulted in the vet pushing the townie instead being lynched. As such I don't think scum would risk sticking their neck out like this (even as a joke..., which I think this probably is?)

So Yuma pps, not robz...

I really like the way Andrew is thinking, but "trying to see if anyone else thought this could be scummy" is definitely a scumtell.

This quip caught my eye. On the face of it is a simple banter with the new guy. But to me I felt a twinge of either scum!Eevee working a town!Andrew or scum!Eevee dancing with a scum!Andrew.

This twinged again when I saw:

I really like the way Andrew is thinking, but "trying to see if anyone else thought this could be scummy" is definitely a scumtell.

It is?

Yes. Looking for validation, or throwing dirt around and waiting to see what sticks until committing to it is natural for mafia, as they want to lynch anyone but one of their own.

It twinged again. Mild suspicion casting, casual interchange keeps the post count up, appear to be moving thee gam forward banter, hmmm.

And then:

Sure, others can weigh in on if what I described would be scummy in their eyes. Either way, I think it is. 

Anyways, what you did was obviously a very mild version of it, as you might have noticed I didn't even vote you for it. Maybe I shouldn't have said anything yet and kept an eye out on if whether you continue to do it before "warning you", but my I didn't think it far enough at the time I guess.

Actual confirmation of what the twinge was saying.

And finally:

Don't be! Way better than no conversation.

Direct confirmation that this might well be all about appearances.

Vote: Eevee

vote: pps strong town read I eevee.

Well, looks like raerae is Town...

Oh...my...scum...

So, here's a question, is anybody even going to listen to me or should I just hammer myself now?  There was no sarcasm there.  I'm not going to waste my time if you're not going to listen.

Oh boo hoo, we've got a victim. This is practically always a scumtell and even if it isn't nobody wants someone around who won't play their wincon.

Aaaand the non-voting bus.

Raerae reaching L-1 that fast makes her more likely to be town I think. I would have unvoted her had I realized I was on her.

vote: scott lack of contributions, seems to be playing it too safe.

The default position scum want to be is not on a wagon that generated a mislynch.

Right, still reading scum in Eevee and do not doubt Andrew is his partner. scotty is playing within his meta.

With the current information at hand I will not lynch raerae. Would lynch ADK.

This brings me back to town on eevee.

I was positive pps was scum yesterday, still positive.

[shraeye]

I was not positive yesterday.  Still not positive.  Axxle, what's the reason?

[Robz888]

Excellent, all excellent. I think we pretty much can't lose now.

Vote: PPS

If PPS flips town, I definitely think mcmc is the next choice for scum. After that, I would give some consideration to PPS's case on ADK, I suppose.

[scott_pilgrim]

I could see PPS as scum but I think it's much more likely ADK, he's played the whole game safe until the very end of yesterday where he intends to hammer yuma, but I think at that point he realizes he has to for town cred.  Again, his D1 RVS vote for raerae and then quickly jumping off the wagon when it hits L-1 still looks bad, nothing has happened to change that.  But then D2 when people bring it up, he basically says "either you believe me or you don't", which isn't how I would expect town to respond (I would expect more frustration, but maybe that's just how I would be in that position).  His intent to hammer yuma is totally what I would expect from scum, that's not to say town couldn't do it too, but the fact that he does it even acknowledging that it would look bad if he hammers and yuma flips town makes me think he was really going for town cred.

vote: A Drowned Kernel

[Robz888]

I guess, one thing to consider with PPS... he was super, super, super willing to bus when he was scum in Diffusion of Power. Even on Day 1. If he's scum here, he was NOT willing to bus on Day 1.

[pingpongsam]

Excellent, all excellent. I think we pretty much can't lose now.

Vote: PPS

If PPS flips town, I definitely think mcmc is the next choice for scum. After that, I would give some consideration to PPS's case on ADK, I suppose.

I can see this working out. Can we please try ADK first, though?

Can anyone postulate why Eevee was the NK? I think it points to ADK since he was the only other one truly looking into the ADK lynch yesterday.