Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[mcmcsalot]

Okay, it's been long enough.

Pretty strong town read on Yuma, I've been following scum Yuma relatively closely(modding helps a lot) scum Yuma at least in recent games has used ate in his defense like a lot and Yuma here is combating posts pretty logically and with a cool disposition(coolly looks dumb) so I read town on him.

[mcmcsalot]

I want to look at the wagons other than raerae that formed and see who formed them, no way scum lets raerae be the only wagon of the day.

[mcmcsalot]

I loaded the entire thread on my phone, prepare yourselves for lots of awkwardly formatted quotes and awesome scum hunting!

[mcmcsalot]

ash would we have been told if raerae was 1-shot?

[mail-mi]

I think that scotty is probably town because that's the alternate raerae wagon yesterday. I was also going to say FTTW was pretty townie, but then I remembered he was dead, oops

[mcmcsalot]

Oh okay not that it matters because ash is a setup ninja, no way claims help us for a loooooong time.

[mcmcsalot]

I cannot believe you people ruined my birthday party.

BMO claim post one?

Vote: pingpongsam

This is actually still really scummy.

[mcmcsalot]

I cannot believe you people ruined my birthday party.

BMO claim post one?

Vote: pingpongsam

Right, flavor names have zero to do with alignment because of the goo or something. So, yeah, I'm BMO and you continue to ruin my party for completely unsound reasons like not having paid any attention to what is going on around here. You know who doesn't need to pay much attention? scumbags.

Vote: Axxle

Yup really scummy.

[mcmcsalot]

Why is no one reacting to my genius pressure votes?

This sounds towny to me. It feels genuine.

[mcmcsalot]

Town read on robz! Seems like he planned to trap scum somehow with that post, I dont really see how but seems like a towny thing to attempt.

Ooh less of a town read, this refers to the ic thingy, scum or town robz would do that, so I don't see it as a reason to have a town read.

[mcmcsalot]

I think we should lynch one of the new guys just to help him grow the thick skin he's gonna need moving forward.

Vote: Andrew

Aha! And then Andrew dies, what was that about suspicion early means they wot get lynched later?

Pps and Yuma/robz remaining scum?(they are the huge omg early suspicions makes you invicible)

[mcmcsalot]

I think we should lynch one of the new guys just to help him grow the thick skin he's gonna need moving forward.

Vote: Andrew

Somewhat of a townread on PPS based off this post. A desire to kill off newbies has often resulted in the vet pushing the townie instead being lynched. As such I don't think scum would risk sticking their neck out like this (even as a joke..., which I think this probably is?)

So Yuma pps, not robz...

[mcmcsalot]

Oh and before some guts all in a fuss I understand I was all like yuma's town, yuma's sccum! It's pre reread and during reread, I'll give some more concise thoughts post reread, I just like rereading this way because I feel like it's genuine and y'all can follow along, at it makes it less boring.

[mcmcsalot]

Okay, so looking at the players in the game, I have a few questions for the people I don't know.

1.  Eevee - no questions here, he's fuzzy and adorable
2.  scott_pilgrim - I don't know you, can you please give a brief recap of your previous mafia experience whether it be in person or online
3.  Robz888 - no questions
4.  mail-mi - no questions
5.  yuma - no questions
6.  mcmcsalot - no questions
7.  A Drowned Kernel - I think you were showing up as I was leaving but I don't remember much, can I get a recap from you too, please?
8.  pingpongsam - I don't believe our paths ever crossed but I think you were around here before I was.  No questions just yet.
9.  raerae - nada
10. AndrewisFTTW - You are completely new to me, recap please?
11. shraeye - no questions
12. Axxle - no questions

She asks all newbies questions, no bets questions and has a very specific response to pps, is this what we would expect from scum? I'm not sure I actually feel like scum wants to puts at least one partner in the largest grouping(at least that's how I think as scum) so that if se flips scum we have a small chance of guessing the partner. So I would guess a partner in the no question group but idk, take out the weird thing with pps and this is literally a null "get newbie info" post.

[mcmcsalot]

Not quoting but next post raerae calls out robz/yuma/eevee about metas, I am thinking this is null as well, these are just the most outspoken metas we have I think. She calls Scott out for having a real name(she later does this with andrew) slight town read on Scott for this.

[mcmcsalot]

I really like the way Andrew is thinking, but "trying to see if anyone else thought this could be scummy" is definitely a scumtell.

This quip caught my eye. On the face of it is a simple banter with the new guy. But to me I felt a twinge of either scum!Eevee working a town!Andrew or scum!Eevee dancing with a scum!Andrew.

This twinged again when I saw:

I really like the way Andrew is thinking, but "trying to see if anyone else thought this could be scummy" is definitely a scumtell.

It is?

Yes. Looking for validation, or throwing dirt around and waiting to see what sticks until committing to it is natural for mafia, as they want to lynch anyone but one of their own.

It twinged again. Mild suspicion casting, casual interchange keeps the post count up, appear to be moving thee gam forward banter, hmmm.

And then:

Sure, others can weigh in on if what I described would be scummy in their eyes. Either way, I think it is. 

Anyways, what you did was obviously a very mild version of it, as you might have noticed I didn't even vote you for it. Maybe I shouldn't have said anything yet and kept an eye out on if whether you continue to do it before "warning you", but my I didn't think it far enough at the time I guess.

Actual confirmation of what the twinge was saying.

And finally:

Don't be! Way better than no conversation.

Direct confirmation that this might well be all about appearances.

Vote: Eevee

vote: pps strong town read I eevee.

[mcmcsalot]

Right now the two points that I like the most so far in the game have been brought up by PPS in regard to eevee and by axxle in regard to shraeye

I think I like the point about shraeye more than the point about eevee (the first point in PPS's post resonated, the rest seemed kinda like stretches) and shraeye has more votes...

so vote: shraeye

This is the fourth vote on shraeye, town read in shraeye, scum read on Yuma.

[mcmcsalot]

Oh they killed Andrew because after what raerae did and flipped scum he was obvi town...

[mcmcsalot]

Well, looks like raerae is Town...

Oh...my...scum...

[mcmcsalot]

Okay, so I think from all this that the wagon, IMO, is a scum wagon run up by scum. Scum who wanted to get their partner,  raerae, up on an early wagon so she wouldn't be suspected later in the game. This is because of how quickly it rose/fell. So, based on this, vote: raerae.

Pretty scummy in my opinion, I thin the raerae wagon was run up by town, this is mail-mi possibly bussing and wanting us to look at the wrong part of the wagon for sccum.

[mcmcsalot]

Okay, so I think from all this that the wagon, IMO, is a scum wagon run up by scum. Scum who wanted to get their partner,  raerae, up on an early wagon so she wouldn't be suspected later in the game. This is because of how quickly it rose/fell. So, based on this, vote: raerae.

So who are my partners, mail-mi?  Because everybody in the damn town was on that wagon with the exception of the two people who didn't happen to log in in that twelve hour time-span.  (And for those of you who need a raerae-translation, there was approximation and exaggeration utilized in that sentence.)  And what actually makes you think I'm scum, let's hear it.

Relevant, similar to her big post though I'm not sure if this is for or against mail-mi being scum.

[mcmcsalot]

So, here's a question, is anybody even going to listen to me or should I just hammer myself now?  There was no sarcasm there.  I'm not going to waste my time if you're not going to listen.

Oh boo hoo, we've got a victim. This is practically always a scumtell and even if it isn't nobody wants someone around who won't play their wincon.

Aaaand the non-voting bus.

[mcmcsalot]

Raerae reaching L-1 that fast makes her more likely to be town I think. I would have unvoted her had I realized I was on her.

vote: scott lack of contributions, seems to be playing it too safe.

Seems like a big deflection, slightly scummy.

[mcmcsalot]

Raerae reaching L-1 that fast makes her more likely to be town I think. I would have unvoted her had I realized I was on her.

vote: scott lack of contributions, seems to be playing it too safe.

The default position scum want to be is not on a wagon that generated a mislynch.

Right, still reading scum in Eevee and do not doubt Andrew is his partner. scotty is playing within his meta.

With the current information at hand I will not lynch raerae. Would lynch ADK.

This brings me back to town on eevee.

[mcmcsalot]

Stopping here, gotta get to work.
Scummy>townie
Scum: pps
Slight scum: mail-mi,  Adk, shraeye, Yuma
Slight town: axxle, robz, Scott, eevee

I think that's everybody, note the slight are pretty slight like a lot slight. Well the towns are a bit less slight.