Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Eevee]

Watno's role could as well be a scum role, right?

[Voltgloss]

Vote Count 2.2.2

Dsell (1): Watno
Watno (4): O, Eevee, cayvie, Archetype
O (1): Robz888

Not voting (9): Everyone else

With 15 alive it takes 8 to lynch.

Deadline is 4:00 p.m. EDT on September 7.  27 hours to go.

[Insomniac]

People need to finish roleclaiming

so far claimed.
Watno - Zaphod Beeblebrox.
Galzria - Fluttershy
Robz - General Iroh
ftl - Samwise Gamgee
cayvie - Ned Flanders
Cuzz - Jigglypuff
Theorel - Snapcaster Mage
Morgrim7 - Peeta Mellark
O - Donald X Vaccarino
Insomniac - jotheonah

Needs to claim (in order)

1. Captain_Frisk
2. Archetype
3. Eevee


DSell go ahead and breadcrumb it.

[Cuzz]

ashersky is still missing from that list. And Frisk claimed a while ago (emphasis added):

I am opposed to O leading a mass claim, and i'm opposed to wasting time going through the process of everyone claiming 1x1.  we wasted a ton of time day 1 doing genre claims, and what did it get us?  What's it going to get us for name claims?  We're searching for someone with bow and arrow flavor?  Scum is gonna lie, and you might end up outing a vig by accident.

I am Jubilee.  If we're going to do it - then just have everyone post ASAP.  If we're going to do it directed - then we're going to end up waiting forever.

FOS Everybody who is in favor of name claiming.

Also, I'm not ok with Dsell's refusal to claim at this point. Once 2/3rds of the living players have claimed, any hesitation to do so seems really scummy.

[Captain_Frisk]

People need to finish roleclaiming

so far claimed.
Watno - Zaphod Beeblebrox.
Galzria - Fluttershy
Robz - General Iroh
ftl - Samwise Gamgee
cayvie - Ned Flanders
Cuzz - Jigglypuff
Theorel - Snapcaster Mage
Morgrim7 - Peeta Mellark
O - Donald X Vaccarino
Insomniac - jotheonah

Needs to claim (in order)

1. Captain_Frisk
2. Archetype
3. Eevee


DSell go ahead and breadcrumb it.

Haven't read hardly anything for a few days - but if we're talking about name claims - then was the first to claim a few days ago.  Still wasting time with this BS?

I'm Jubilee.

[Cuzz]

Insomniac, you missed Archetype's claim too:

Does anyone mind if I jump ahead and claim my name now?

Did you guys know that I'm The Mad Hatter? Does anyone else still feel that Watno is scummy? Who else thinks we should grill those who name-claimed before eHalcyon's death?

Vote: Watno

And Frisk, I don't really think this has been a waste of time. Sure it took a while, but we still have a whole day till deadline and we know two important things: Shared universes are possible, and someone who nameclaimed before eHalc died was lying.

But you also admit you haven't been reading so I'm not sure why you'd even make an uninformed comment like that before catching up.

[Insomniac]

Ok so updated list.

Claims

Watno - Zaphod Beeblebrox.
Galzria - Fluttershy
Robz - General Iroh
ftl - Samwise Gamgee
cayvie - Ned Flanders
Cuzz - Jigglypuff
Theorel - Snapcaster Mage
Morgrim7 - Peeta Mellark
O - Donald X Vaccarino
Insomniac - jotheonah
Captain_Frisk - Jubilee
Archetype - The Mad Hatter

Missing

1. ashersky
2. Dsell
3. Eevee

[Watno]

@theorel Well, i think you can see it both ways. the opposite of saying the truth is lying. If Dsell meant it the way you think he did, don't you think he could tell me himself?

@Cuzz Don't you think now is a bit late to start complaining about Dsell not wanting to tell his name?

Regarding Morgrim: Do people really think he has a restriction? To me it rather looks like he's crying to be lynched. The question is wether he's a jester or just wants us to believe so.

[Insomniac]

Also Morgrim7 was the last to claim before eHal caught a liar.

Galz and CF had claimed well before eHal came forward with that information so excluding them the list of possible liars is pretty short.


Morgrim7 - Peeta Melark - unknown
FTL - Samwise Gamgee - Lord of the Rings
Cayvie - Ned Flanders - Unlikely, she was basically known on day 1. - Simpsons, Must be friendly
Cuzz - Jigglypuff - Pokemon
Watno - Zaphod Beeblebrox - Sci-fi
Robz - General Iroh - Avatar: the Last Airbender

[Dsell]

I am fluent in every language. Including whale!

Theorel is wrong about my restriction.

Breadcrumb: H H.

The goal of my breadcrumb to NOT avoid breaking the cryptography rule while still making it mysterious enough that it WILL be guessed by those with evil intentions, all while NOT giving accountability to me later.

[Cuzz]

@Cuzz Don't you think now is a bit late to start complaining about Dsell not wanting to tell his name?

I supposed I'd hoped he might come around once everyone else claimed. And I wanted to put additional pressure on him, since I think even if Dsell is town, letting someone get away with withholding important information leaves the door open for scum to do the same without consequence later on. And we still have over a day left.

And you're currently the only person voting for him, and presumably you might want others to as well, so I'm not sure why you're arguing with me about it.

[Insomniac]

To consider:

Bullet and Arrow hole in Axxle.

FTL/Morgrim7 are characters that likely have access to bows/arrows, maybe Robz too? (I know like nothing of Avatar)



Online Crosssection for when eHal died
Morgrim7
Robz
FTL


I think those are the only 3 on that list that were online?

[Cuzz]

To consider:

Bullet and Arrow hole in Axxle.

FTL/Morgrim7 are characters that likely have access to bows/arrows, maybe Robz too? (I know like nothing of Avatar)



Online Crosssection for when eHal died
Morgrim7
Robz
FTL


I think those are the only 3 on that list that were online?

Iroh's weapon is fire/lightning. No bows for Robz.

Also, I'm not sure which list you mean, but me, Eevee and Galz all posted within 10 minutes or so of the daykill.

I remember Eevee mentioned that using the "who was online" information was outside the spirit of the game, which seems scummy (I actually somewhat agree in principle, but why even say anything?). On the other hand, let's not forget jotheonah's warning about reading too much into that.

[Watno]

Theorel is wrong about my restriction.

Which you didn't notice before he told you?

@Cuzz I think there are multiple scum players in this game. So if someone does something i don't understand, i question it. Dsell has been explicitely saying he wouldn't claim for ages.

Insomniac: With "that list" you mean the one of people who you think have a bow?
Also, eHal died to the rock benath him attacking him, not to a shot. I dont think the online list will get us far, since you can conceal being online.
I don't think Morgrims vote was a claim. He could take semi-normally on day 1 too and didnt make use of it.

[Insomniac]

Ok to clarify this is the list im talking about.

Also Morgrim7 was the last to claim before eHal caught a liar.

Galz and CF had claimed well before eHal came forward with that information so excluding them the list of possible liars is pretty short.


Morgrim7 - Peeta Melark - unknown
FTL - Samwise Gamgee - Lord of the Rings
Cayvie - Ned Flanders - Unlikely, she was basically known on day 1. - Simpsons, Must be friendly
Cuzz - Jigglypuff - Pokemon
Watno - Zaphod Beeblebrox - Sci-fi
Robz - General Iroh - Avatar: the Last Airbender

From that list FTL and Morgrim7 are people that make sense to have a bow

And also from that list we know that FTL, Morgrim7, Robz, and Cuzz were online when eHal died.

[Insomniac]

Ignoring the online portion, Morgrim7 has been actively trying to die.

So my suspicion goes to the other bow holder Vote: ftl

[Insomniac]

Wait wait wait, who was it that mentioned Katniss Everdeen...SHE would make sense as the bow killer and Morgrim7 claimed Peeta from the same world.

[Dsell]

Theorel is wrong about my restriction.

Which you didn't notice before he told you?

*sigh*

Theorel is WRONG about my restriction. I do NOT live on planet earth.


Also, in the Hunger Games, Peeta's thing is NOT setting traps and snares.

[Insomniac]

ftl could be scum Legolas!

vote: FTL

It occurred to me.  But I wanted to let people claim.

Also, would Legolas really be scum?  Again, based on Axxle's modifier, flavour may actually be important.  Of course, there are scum archers in LotR right?

eHal mentions Legolas which seems like a breadcrum legolas is in the game.

Dsell is the one that mentions Katniss.

But Morgrim7 could be lying and could be Katniss.

[Insomniac]

Theorel is wrong about my restriction.

Which you didn't notice before he told you?

*sigh*

Theorel is WRONG about my restriction. I do NOT live on planet earth.


Also, in the Hunger Games, Peeta's thing is NOT setting traps and snares.

What Im getting at is I think eHal caught either Morgrim7 and that he is actually Katniss or that ftl is Legolas.

[Dsell]

Theorel is wrong about my restriction.

Which you didn't notice before he told you?

*sigh*

Theorel is WRONG about my restriction. I do NOT live on planet earth.


Also, in the Hunger Games, Peeta's thing is NOT setting traps and snares.

What Im getting at is I think eHal caught either Morgrim7 and that he is actually Katniss or that ftl is Legolas.

It's NOT possible that ftl is Legolas and Morgrim is a daykill trap-setting Peeta Mellark. But this isN'T mostly speculation I suppose. Both areN'T firmly within the realm of possibility.

[jotheonah]

Vote Count 2.2.3

Dsell(1): Watno
Watno(4): O, Eevee, cayvie, Archetype
O(1): Robz888
ftl(1): Insomniac

not voting(: ashersky, Cuzz, Captain_Frisk, Dsell, Morgrim7, ftl, Galzria, theorel

With 15 alive it takes 8 to lynch.

Deadline is 4:00 p.m. EDT on September 7.  25.5 hours to go.

[Insomniac]

Peoples opinions?

Morgrim7 is Kaatniss?
FTL is Legolas?

[jotheonah]

Alright, here I am giving you more info than you need or deserve:

eHalcyon was killed earlier in the day than his death was posted.  He was PM'd his death, and it was supposed to be like in BMMM1 - his body (chassis?) would be found under a pile of rocks a little before deadline. However, eHalcyon failed to read his PMs before posting and ruined my beautiful plans.

TL;DR looking at who was online really is misleading.

[jotheonah]

(Promise I'm not lying)