I don't find Jimmmmm scummy at all for his arguments. It's such a slight thing, and the wording is sufficiently confusing. If anything I'd lean towards a slightly towny Jimmmmm.
Quick note however: as someone who played scum in a multiple scum-team game, scum has the freedom to really scum-hunt in this game. That makes it much trickier to read people IMO, because the scum
are in fact looking for scum, since they'd love to push a lynch through on the opposing team for town-cred.
15 players are just over what I can comfortably handle in my head, but let's see:
Cuzz: hasn't posted for a long time in thread (about as long as me), has his RVS vote sitting on Eevee. He was correcting people's mistakes about the set-up, which reads pro-town to me.
Robz: seems like town-Robz. Although, last time I suspected him he was a town PR, so maybe he'll just get to live for a while this time? I'm pulling for you to live Robz, even if you do lynch my for the loss at lylo.
Galzria: He reads like town-Galz to me. This seems like his typical early game of posting reasonably often with a slight non-seriousness.
Eevee: I've already mentioned that he seems more critical this game than usual. Of course he could just be trying to up his game as he claims. But I still find it scummy given my note above about multi-ball (game with multiple scum-teams).
Ashersky: I'm not sure I can read him at all. He apparently always thinks I'm scummy. I've only barely seen him in play, he died night-1 in XII and hosted XVII. I don't really count BMV (and wouldn't here anyways since he had a post restriction). XI I was scum, so I wasn't really analyzing him, but I wasn't going to try to push a case on him. For what it's worth, I don't care for the self-pity...I lost every game before XVII, and was essentially the cause of the loss in VIII and XII by picking up the first town-vote at lylo, drop the pity and try to help town more.
mcmcsalot: No meta. He seems vaguely town.
shraeye: He seems his usual abrasive self.
raerae: I haven't really tried to read her before since she was IC. This game, I've not got much read here. Her posts are sort of intertwined in my mind with shraeye's (which seems reasonable regardless of alignment).
yuma: First to speak out in favor of Eevee. (The following also applies to shraeye and raerae): I think the defense of Eevee is reasonable, since I think the case was made out to be stronger than it was. I may still have a slight scum-read of Eevee, but defending people usually reads town-ish to me, since I do it as town. I do recognize a tendency for scum to defend town for the town-cred, but the particular defenses of Eevee read townie to me rather than "I know this player is town and will defend them".
liopoil: He seems town to me. Has all the markings of a new-player that rolled town in my mind.
sparky: he'll need to post something for me to have a read. Obviously sparky often lurks a lot. Does he usually post on weekends though? Opening Friday night means that I'm willing to give a bigger pass for early-game lurking than usual...but I want to know if I should for any given specific case.
Well, that's what I've got so far after catching up from my last post last night. Too many town-reads, but the game-day is still early. I'm going to
vote: sparky (this is apparently how I give people passes for early game lurking on the weekend). Because I'd like to hear him post, and I like to use my vote for reasons other than voting for my biggest scum-read who is only a hair scummier than neutral. This post lacks scumScores obviously, I'll try to get those in sometime later.