You're presenting your constraints as a lot stronger than I think they are, and I'm busy and I have more productive things to spend what time I have to spend on this game on.
I'm pointing out what I believe to be a significant issue with your analysis that some one needs to point out because a lot of people are inclined to just nod along with these things, but that doesn't mean you can assign me 2 hours of game homework that I focus on instead of the more productive things I could be looking at.
I laid it all out so that you don't
have to spend two hours recreating it from scratch. A couple of random spot-checks can reassure anyone that the wagons I'm singling out actually happened: scum!me could
not get away with pulling out false evidence here and presenting it to the whole thread. So, let's assume that the wagons I pulled out all happened. Okay so far?
Next, I listed the constraints in a short form, and I kept myself in all the relevant groupings, just so I'm not accused of trying to make myself look any less likely to be scum.
Third, I went through every possible scum-pairing out of every player including me in the game, and I counted by hand (so I
would appreciate it if anyone wants to take 5 minutes to check that!) how many of the constraints each possible pairing violated. I did
not apply them as hard constraints, and I made it clear that I expect numbers other than only zero to indicate a likely scumteam. I tabulated the entire thing so that nobody else needed to repeat it, even for the really unlikely teams like, Ash-Awaclus, which met zero of my five constraints.
There could well be actual valid criticisms of my reasoning. I would like for more than one other person to respond to say they've looked at it and it seems valid, because that way more people could trust it and use it to catch scum when the PoE narrows later. I'm frustrated that the only person engaging is instead claiming to have this clever insight about how everything I'd done is wrong or worthless
while insisting you're not going to read it properly.
If anyone wants assistance in coming up with a better dialog about it, the latter parts are based on a two-person scumteam assumption, and there are plenty of people who were arguing against that earlier. For another thing, there are places where the fact I did the calculations by hand as I posted mean I could have made simple counting or typing errors.