Dominion Strategy Forum
Dominion => Dominion General Discussion => Topic started by: ycz6 on May 28, 2012, 12:21:18 am
-
http://www.ihigh.com/naqt/broadcast_228025.html?silverlight=1
Check out 17:00 for kicks.
-
Carcassonne?! How even.
-
Blasted kids wouldn't know a good game if it Hagged the Hag off the top of their deck. What are they doing in their free time, studying?
-
Silver/Moon light... *shivers*
-
Oh, man, this is bringing back memories for me. I played NAQT (and other quiz bowl formats too) in high school, and college, and even grad school- it was my big hobby for a long time, though now that I'm no longer a student and can't play any more board games have replaced it. Every once in awhile, they'd have a board game question, and 99 percent of the participants would hate it, denouncing it as "trash" (which has long been the term for everything pop culture, usually as a term of disparagement but some folks embraced it and put together "trash tournaments" in college)- and not just trash, but obscure trash that nobody knows and why are they even asking. So I'm sure the teams here were all thinking "good match, except for that blasted Dominion question".
It's not the first time NAQT has asked about Dominion, though. Back in 2009, I was at the college nationals and they had a question about the number 5 in board games. The first clue was "In Dominion, Witch costs this much". Yeah, I got it, for fifteen.
-
Oh man, I got a text message from a friend of mine telling me that Dominion had come up at Nationals. I was going to be very upset that he didn't get it right...until he informed me that he had been eliminated long ago. Definitely a trash question, though.
-
Reminds me of a time when I did the Geography Bee in high school, where the theme was "The Sounds of Geography" (languages, music, etc), and I think I was the only person to know what Esperanto is.
-
"Trash question" seems like a awfully scruby thing.
-
"Trash question" seems like a awfully scruby thing.
Clearly you've never participated in This Tournament Goes to XI
-
Oh my god, I never thought I'd see the PPR in the NAQT.
I'm so flattered.
-
So, who reads the blog on the... committee(?) that comes up with the questions? It's okay, you can tell us who you are :D
Also, as an outsider, I'm amazed that they would ask such and obscure question as this. I mean, I wish Dominion were super-popular and well-known, but it is not...
-
Questions are basically written freelance; anybody can apply to be a writer (http://www.naqt.com/jobs.html)and start submitting questions. Obviously, it helps to know what you're doing, and it takes some experience before they'll let you submit to the national championships.
-
So, who reads the blog on the... committee(?) that comes up with the questions? It's okay, you can tell us who you are :D
Also, as an outsider, I'm amazed that they would ask such and obscure question as this. I mean, I wish Dominion were super-popular and well-known, but it is not...
I've never written for NAQT, though I thought of doing it at one point, and actually wrote a few questions for one of their (friendly) competitors last year.
I think it's just probably one person who writes for them who's also into boardgames and keeps putting questions in at the rate of one per tournament. Who that is, I don't know. Probably not Ken Jennings (who's of course the one NAQT person that people outside of the quizbowl subculture have heard of).
And Dominion is totally among the top fifteen or so well-known hobby board games these days- but even so I wouldn't ask about anything more obscure than Settlers at HSNCT. Maybe at the college level, or maybe as a hard bonus part.
-
Did anyone else watch the rest of that match? Holy crap, that was close.
-
Questions are basically written freelance; anybody can apply to be a writer (http://www.naqt.com/jobs.html)and start submitting questions. Obviously, it helps to know what you're doing, and it takes some experience before they'll let you submit to the national championships.
So... It was you?
-
So... It was you?
I can neither confirm nor deny this accusation.
(no)
-
What exactly was the question. I am curious, but not curious enough to install Silverlight.
-
Opening gambits hinge on a 4-3 or 5-2 start in this game, whose endgame often turns on who makes the next to last 8-cost play. Isotropic.org hosts online matches of this game. That site was used by creator Donald X Vaccarino to playtest the 2011 expansion "Cornucopia". For ten points name this game with ten randomly chosen Kingdom cards whose Victory cards include "Estate", "Duchy" and "Province".
First team answers "Carcassonne".
Second team answers "Stratego".
-
Opening gambits hinge on a 4-3 or 5-2 start in this game, whose endgame often turns on who makes the next to last 8-cost play. Isotropic.org hosts online matches of this game. That site was used by creator Donald X Vaccarino to playtest the 2011 expansion "Cornucopia". For ten points name this game with ten randomly chosen Kingdom cards whose Victory cards include "Estate", "Duchy" and "Province".
First team answers "Carcasonne".
Second team answers "Stratego".
Holy crap, that's a difficult set of clues. I'm also surprised the Spiel des Jahres win wasn't mentioned.
-
Opening gambits hinge on a 4-3 or 5-2 start in this game, whose endgame often turns on who makes the next to last 8-cost play. Isotropic.org hosts online matches of this game. That site was used by creator Donald X Vaccarino to playtest the 2011 expansion "Cornucopia". For ten points name this game with ten randomly chosen Kingdom cards whose Victory cards include "Estate", "Duchy" and "Province".
First team answers "Carcasonne".
Second team answers "Stratego".
Seriously? Stratego? STRATEGO? What the hell is wrong with those kids? You might as well say "chess" to the clue "this game involves circling a board of real estate, with the most expensive lot titled 'boardwalk' - each player gains $200 each time they pass a game square called 'Go.'"
-
http://www.ihigh.com/naqt/broadcast_228025.html?silverlight=1
Check out 17:00 for kicks.
...and keep watching. That was a really, really good game. :-)
I wrote that question (100% serious). In the 3rd-place game, a player from LASA (Liberal Arts and Sciences Academy, Austin, TX) was all over this. I meant to ask him his Isotropic handle but forgot.
-
That's _awesome_. Does the NAQT allow answering questions before they are completed? If so, I am curious as to what point people here would have answered? I certainly would have hit it at 'game', and very possibly after '4-3'.
That's my second favorite trivia question of all time.
#1 (not in the NAQT style): Name the 5 assumptions of the EOQ model. (no joke)
-
I'm guessing (and not installing Silverlight) that you can to buzz in at any time while the question is being read (unlike Jeopardy) given the incredibly pointless insertion of random information that's useless to someone who has no chance at ever getting the answer with more and more specific information being given at the end of the clue that would give people a higher chance of being able to recall the answer. That said, it seems really stupid to leave out that it won the Spiel des Jahres, and giving a specific year for that win would have made it possible for people to know without having played the game.
-
That's _awesome_. Does the NAQT allow answering questions before they are completed? If so, I am curious as to what point people here would have answered? I certainly would have hit it at 'game', and very possibly after '4-3'.
At the point where it says "4-3", the question could still be referring to Go; that's a very common opening move. 5-2 isn't a typical Go opening move, though, so if the question were being read very very slowly that's the earliest I might buzz in.
http://senseis.xmp.net/?BeginnersGuideToTheOpening