Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[ThetaSigma12]

This thread convinced me that Qvist needs to start making community-approved art ratings.

With weighted and unweighted results. Jsh, jamfamsam, and others who have delved into the art ratings business should be the "pros" while the rest of us just get counted like normal

Not really, by that logic anyone who votes will be a pro. I don't think it's right to have a weighted ranking for this.

[jsh357]

This thread convinced me that Qvist needs to start making community-approved art ratings.

With weighted and unweighted results. Jsh, jamfamsam, and others who have delved into the art ratings business should be the "pros" while the rest of us just get counted like normal

Not really, by that logic anyone who votes will be a pro. I don't think it's right to have a weighted ranking for this.

Too bad your opinion on this has less weight than my own.

[jamfamsam]

#274 - Jack of All Trades



This is the start of group S, 12 cards.

The pile of rocks/half wall in the middle of nowhere is a little odd. And Will, nice hat.

[jamfamsam]

#273 - Dame Anna



This is one of the cheesy portraits you'd expect to find in the home of a noble. There's some very nice hedge work there.

[jamfamsam]

#272 - Junk Dealer



Here it is finally. One of my daughters rated this 6 out of 7 which raised it out of the depths it otherwise may have had.

This guy looks like he's been smoking something or perhaps had a few too many drinks. He does seem to look like what you'd expect from a guy carting around a bunch of junk and trying to push it off on other people.

[Seprix]

#273 - Dame Anna



This is one of the cheesy portraits you'd expect to find in the home of a noble. There's some very nice hedge work there.

That's like, Top 20 Dominion Art!

[Roadrunner7671]

Yeah, Dame Anna looks like a photograph to me.

[Deadlock39]

That's like, Top 20 Dominion Art!

Yeah, Dame Anna looks like a photograph to me.

You guys just think she's cute, don't you.

[Awaclus]

Yeah, Dame Anna looks like a photograph to me.

So it makes sense that it'd be ranked lower than things that look better than photographs.

[Seprix]

That's like, Top 20 Dominion Art!

Yeah, Dame Anna looks like a photograph to me.

You guys just think she's cute, don't you.

Some Dominion Cards are just Dominion Cards.

[jamfamsam]

#271 - Upgrade



I really like the pastels here. They really shouldn't be letting those children play up on the scaffolding.

[jamfamsam]

#270 - Bank



Welcome to the local pub. Oh, we are a bank as well. The green shadows are weird here.

[jamfamsam]

#269 - Relic



This isn't Relics. The 2nd one doesn't belong. There can be only one.

[markusin]

#273 - Dame Anna



This is one of the cheesy portraits you'd expect to find in the home of a noble. There's some very nice hedge work there.

Yeah, Dame Anna looks like a photograph to me.

Now I can't understand the image of this being a picture of someone sticking their head through the hole of one of those big roleplay picture boards.

Oh and if you had asked me before, I would have never guessed that there are two gems on Relic.

Edit: I meant I can't unsee the image. Would you believe my phone auto-corrects "unsee" to "understand"?

[Awaclus]

Edit: I meant I can't unsee the image. Would you believe my phone auto-corrects "unsee" to "understand"?

What has been seen cannot be understood.

[markusin]

Edit: I meant I can't unsee the image. Would you believe my phone auto-corrects "unsee" to "understand"?

What has been seen cannot be understood.

Now I'm wondering if my phone is trying to reveal to me a universal truth.

But I'm sure your quote applies to some of these Dominion cards.

[jamfamsam]

#268 - Save



This is some nice art and she has a little glow about her. If we didn't have the name Save on the card, I'm not sure we would know what she is doing.

[jamfamsam]

#267 - Temple



The sky is beautiful but distracting. My daughters think the temple looks more like a gazebo. The temple is leaning one way and the trees the other.

[jamfamsam]

#266 - Catapult/Rocks



These aren't just regular rocks; they are explosive rocks. I don't think the bombardment of a castle by a catapult normally caused it to catch fire.

[Co0kieL0rd]

#267 - Temple

The temple is leaning one way and the trees the other.

That's just the earth's curvature playing tricks on your eyes.

[Aleimon Thimble]

These aren't just regular rocks; they are explosive rocks. I don't think the bombardment of a castle by a catapult normally caused it to catch fire.

You have clearly never played Age of Empires.

[Co0kieL0rd]

These aren't just regular rocks; they are explosive rocks. I don't think the bombardment of a castle by a catapult normally caused it to catch fire.

You have clearly never played Age of Empires.

We've learned from AoE that literally everything will set a building on fire eventually, even a villager attacking it with a club. I guess it's just friction heat.

[Seprix]

Age of Empires was the bomb. I miss it so much.

[faust]

Age of Empires was the bomb. I miss it so much.

Especially the Gunpowder units.

[jamfamsam]

#265 - Crumbling Castle



Almost looks like petrified castle. There are a lot of yellow tones here.