I have to admit I'm scared of rereads... 91 pages is a lot of stuff. Could there be scum intentionally spamming the thread to make rereads hard? I know someone proposed that way back in my first scum game (M31). None of my then-teammates is in this game sadly.
For the sake of avoiding to sound like a broken record and because I am slightly worried that WW might not happen, let's look at other options though. I will go way back to the Awaclus wagon; I don't think anyone has done proper wagon analysis so far.
Before the Awaclus wagon gets started, the main wagons are
Ampharos (4): Hydrad, e, faust, silver
e (3): Egor, Teproc, WW
with focus on e.
Then I vote, and WW joins in (he has been switching between Ampharos/Awaclus before, i.e. was on all three wagons). Then igauna:
Vote: Awaclus
I've already given my reasons. They haven't changed, they've just been aggravated.
This is the post where iguana talks about Awaclus before that:
If it was Awaclus OTOH pushing a Yuma lynch, one would expect him to know better. Oh wait, Awaclus was pushing a Yuma lynch.
Everyone is saying they're fine with an Awaclus lynch. Well, I'll say that I like it a lot better than an Ampharos lynch.
Any takers?
Then comes e's vote, basically making Awaclus the only real wagon at the time. It is consistent with e' earlier attitude:
oh good. Now we can move on and lynch either Awaclus or Ampharos.
Ampharos because he is scummy
Awaclus because he is a lurker who tried to take advantage of the whole yuma disappearing act to lynch yuma. Which I think is scummy.
At this point, RR votes Ampharos over Awaclus. That is somewhat towny. yuma comes in and does not comment about the Awaclus wagon at all. Weird. Scummy. Teproc makes a long e case. silver votes e in response. Haddock thinks silver's post is towny and joins in on e. Now it's pretty much e vs Awaclus.
RR says his lynch preferences are Ampharos>e>Awaclus (these are actually his top three. Ugh. Blending in much?). Hydrad makes a scummy post:
well awaclus's lynch at worst gives us info on who has been defending him and stuff. So i think awaclus lynch here is ok also.
Haddock makes a post in which he reverts his read on Awaclus and votes for him. People have suggested this is scummy; I disagree. It would be very bold play to make a 180° turn on the most popular wagon. Then this:
How many votes are on Awaclus?
5 (aka L-2)
This may look scummy, but Vote: Awaclus
Yes, it does look scummy indeed. And then the hammer.
So I think the most scummy stuff here is Hydrad and RR. I'm also concerned about e and yuma. Haddock and Teproc are tentatively townie.
PPE: 9