Read list:
Towny:
- faust - He helped getting this game going and I like all his posts. Or he is just scum playing well.
Null - Towny:
- DatSwan - Was interested in getting this game going. Haven’t heard much lately.
- Xxraptorslayer96 - Asking good questions
Null:
- Witherweaver - Nothing much to see yet.
- Awaclus - Not much yet, but thinking of older games that is too be expecte(?)[l/i]
Scummy - Null:
- Seprix - Where is you content?
- stevanzzo - same question
Scummy:
- Skumpy - I voted him in the first place to generate discussion and each of his following posts convinced me to keep my vote there. And he ignores the fact that his wagon has spawned discussion.
PPE: Awaclus
I think this is a townie post.
Agree with this, including the 'think'. No groundbreaking revolutionary reasons, but I feel this stuff is really tough to fake the first time around, even with having read past games.
Skumpy, how many games have you payed before?
New answer: 2. Maybe this explains the bad post of mine earlier, when faust could be thinking, "Geez, you win too much, get lynched already!" It's a joke. Mostly. The plan was for me to self-vote in my next M game after starting off strong in my career...then I didn't when I got to L-2 and then L-1. And now there's no reason whatsoever to have fun with that.
Vote: raptor
Interesting that Raptor doesn't react to this. He just got a firsthand look at an Awaclus tunnel, now he's the victim of one and he's not concerned? And obviously can't read into Awaclus well, but I feel this is kind of townie (this is a decision I know I'm going to backtrack on later. I'm reading a lot of people as town this game).
!!!!! The hell??? Why? I'll read this as an amateur mistake but this looks very bad for you.
Just keeping the vote at 4 so I could see who drops and/or who pushed him over the edge.
That being said, it's down to 3 by my count (probably wrong, I'm bad at counting.) so unvote.
As for it looking bad, sure. From the reactions earlier, unvoting makes it look worse. 
It would look bad except I like the self-awareness. Maybe I'm underestimating newbie talent. No sé!
I understand the faust post about interactions now. But I still don't like being Test Subject #2025
@SirClemens' reads: I've never played with scum!faust before. But I know that to give him towncred for that is a bad call. Even if faust's town, you're severely underestimating scum ability. Unless you already know this.
"Never townread faust" is not a viable solution though. Hard as it may be, you have to figure out a way to read me.
It'll be much easier once I've played against you as scum. I'm still working off the feeling that I'm always going to misread you, town as scum and scum as town. Maybe that's a sign I should unvote. Then again, I'm not actually voting for you right now.
Aside: Who haven't I read yet as town? WW, Swan, Seprix? This is either really good or really bad, I don't think it's in the middle.
I don't know what kind of post this is. Is he always like this?
Yeah it is normal. But occasionally they are extremely entertaining 
Swan's scum because town has no reason to lie
(that winky face just guarantees Swan as scum).
The big Swan post: I don't know. My mentality now is to table this while I try to figure out how to read Swan. Though instincts are leaning a bit towards scum. (I went back and tried again. Really on the fence with this one. I think I want to give Swan time and see if he slips somehow).
I like Skumpy‘s latest post unvote
What about skumpys post made him go from bottom of your list to seprix being bottom?
It just made Skumpy move one tier up and I voted Seprix for lurking. He stopped doing that and stevanzzo is entitled to a day 1 pass as a newbie. So unvote
Newbie passes aren't actually a good idea in a newbie game.
It's not about it being a good idea, it's about being fair. And maybe a bit manipulative. If you're trying to entice new players to join Mafia, then it's a good idea to not kill them D1.
I kind of want to vote DatSwan for being so very wrong. But that's probably just DatSwan. So I suppose vote: Seprix.
Just wanted to LOL at this. Swan's always wrong as town, apparently. But I agree with this stuff. Again. Sigh.
The whole WW wagon is a load of nonsense. WW's play so far is completely normal for him. In fact the only thing to be said against it would be that it is too normal, but that isn't the case people are making.
Would've been nice if you had said this before. It's a not a case for him being town though. Maybe I should be wondering about a team here (I said wonder, don't jump on this!)
I don't know what kind of post this is. Is he always like this?
Well, kind of, but also not really. I mean Skumpy always likes to talk about himself, but here it feels off.
Thank god 110's over. Because now I can say: does my opening remind you more of 105, 110 or neither? I was distracted when this game began, if I were to answer my own question, I'd go with neither.
(can I call you SC?)
Sure.
And now I'm always going to read this as Santa Claus.
Should we decide on the lynch tomorrow? 8th December would be a little rushed, and rushed lynches are bad from what I’ve seen.
I have hardly ever seen this work (that is, deciding to settle on a lynch before deadline and then actually pulling it through).
Also there's no reason to do this. If we decide to settle on a lynch tomorrow, then things will get rushed once we try to settle for something tomorrow evening. The rush can only be prevented by an early quickhammer. Unfortunately, you said these were bad.
Now it isn‘t early in the day. I think the pressure if we try to settle it tomorrow will be a great deal smaller than if done on friday. A situation where we settle on a lynch that we don’t favor because people are absent is smaller on thursday than on friday, since the absent people still can vote on friday. I could be really wrong about this since I have no experience, but to me it sounds good on paper.
Santa's town. EXACTLY how I felt my first game. Talkative, not needing to hold back anything.
Why is nobody else voting for raptor?
Because self-confident Raptor is new and different and fun. And helpful. Why are you voting him?
So the faust-DatSwan-WW is an interesting trio. Though Seprix is there too. My vote's going for somebody in this group, one way or another. I'm good where I am now on WW, agreeing with Raptor. I could see Seprix as scum except faust and WW are both voting there. We'll see where the wind blows, I'll wait for some more stuff.
Author
Topic: NM11: anagrams (over and done) (eOven! dan? ron?) (Read 61742 times)