Well, nothing really changed from before, so mcmc can come and call this all terrible reasoning, but here we are. I still think your claim of a protective role was strange and unfaust-ish.
Being different is not scummy.
I think this is weird that you're still alive claimed a protective role and, again, being faust. All the last times I remember if you're alive in the beginning of D3, you're scum. And yeah, WIFOM of course, but it did work earlier, though no one lynched you then and you won.
Noone died tonight. So obviously I couldn't have died tonight. It is very much possible that scum targeted me and I was protected. Your case here is only that I wasn't killed N1.
Also, you're really almost the only one scumreading me and this means you think I am an easy mislynch, as I already have mentioned.
If noone else is scumreading you, how exactly are you an easy mislynch?
I don't think you should've done it actually, I'd look at the reactions of people if I were town. No claiming is good before the reaction onto the event. It's like if I am Tracker I start the day with I saw Hydrad targeting gkrieg (this is not the case). Why would I do this?
That is a false analogy. If I am a Tracker seeing something, then I can catch that player in a lie if he claims something else. That is why I won't tip them off that they have to claim their real target. I do not have any information that can catch anyone in a lie. The only thing my claim does is back up the claim of some other player who is a protective role. I claim early so that it is clear that it is genuine. Scum did not expect no kill, I assume. The longer I wait to reveal such information, the more likely would it be in the eyes of the rest of you that I made up some scheme as scum. Claiming early supports me being town.
And why would I do it as scum? It does not help me; in fact, it hurts scum because the player with a protective role might be IC'd, as well as their target. If I claimed to have protected as well as scum, then I could cast doubt on the whole thing. You will say I did it for towncred, which is always the excuse when you have no other thing to say, but really scum!me would know that anything I did was subject to intense scrutiny and would never give me much towncred, and ICing two townies just for the sake of looking a tiny bit townier is a terrible trade for scum.
Actually I think that your partners are some people from the subset [gkrieg/mcmc/Robz]. Maybe Galz, but he tunneled you quite effectively, which of course can be a good play. I don't know. The idea of you/gkrieg/mcmc/X? team is quite settling in my head.
I think gkrieg has also consistently been scumreading me.