Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[jamfamsam]

#315 - Catapult



We can't tell if those are clouds above the green mountains or snow covered peaks on top of or behind the green mountains. If the latter, the transition is very stark. The catapult is nice.

[faust]

We can't tell if those are clouds above the green mountains or snow covered peaks on top of or behind the green mountains. If the latter, the transition is very stark.

Winter is coming.

[jamfamsam]

#314 - Dame Josephine



Her beauty mark is leaking. What's with the pool of blood? I thought Donald said no gore. Oh, it's a banner.

[jamfamsam]

#313 - Moneylender



Something is off with the shadows and that feather is way too white for the lighting. A face only a mother could love.

[jamfamsam]

#312 - Great Hall



I'm not sure Great Hall deserves to be this high on the list. It looks more like Haunted Great Hall, +1 Card, +1 Action, each other player with 5 or more cards in hand puts one on top of their deck. It's a lot of green and a little blurry.

[jamfamsam]

#311 - Black Market



Why the long face? My daughters said it is ghostly.

I really like the feel of this card. It captures the shadiness of the black market and the type of creepy people you would expect to find peddling their wares.

[Co0kieL0rd]

#311 - Black Market

I really like the feel of this card. It captures the shadiness of the black market and the type of tin people you would expect to find peddling their wares.

FTFY

[jamfamsam]

#311 - Black Market

I really like the feel of this card. It captures the shadiness of the black market and the type of tin people you would expect to find peddling their wares.

FTFY

I do feel some obligation to present my daughters' comments even if I don't agree with them.

[Co0kieL0rd]

#311 - Black Market

I really like the feel of this card. It captures the shadiness of the black market and the type of tin people you would expect to find peddling their wares.

FTFY

I do feel some obligation to present my daughters' comments even if I don't agree with them.

And that's just fine. Children have a lot of interesting things to say.

[ThetaSigma12]

I don't get how Ritual got rated so low because it looked like a video game, but Junk Dealer still hasn't turned up?

[jamfamsam]

It's still going to get worse before it gets better.

[jamfamsam]

#310 - Oracle



The leg of the tub makes it look like her leg is bent funny. That scarf is really long.

I actually like this art as well.

[jamfamsam]

#309 - Patrician/Emporium



What is everyone looking at? Those clouds are weird. We have either leaves falling out of nowhere or a bunch of deformed birds falling out of the sky.

[jamfamsam]

#308 - Merchant Guild



There is way too much red going on here. That's a nice xylophone he's wearing on his head, some kind of hazing ritual.

[jamfamsam]

#307 - Rabble



More weirdness with hand proportions here. Normally the mob would be going after the vampire woman in the back, but she has somehow found a way to mingle. The lady in the bottom left is apparently having a heart attack from all the excitement.

Edit: This was the end of group V.

[markusin]

#314 - Dame Josephine



Her beauty mark is leaking. What's with the pool of blood? I thought Donald said no gore. Oh, it's a banner.

Where did Donald say that?

Because, you know, Conquest.

[jamfamsam]

#314 - Dame Josephine



Her beauty mark is leaking. What's with the pool of blood? I thought Donald said no gore. Oh, it's a banner.

Where did Donald say that?

Because, you know, Conquest.

Reply #1989 in Interview with Donald X. "Treasures often say "no people" because some of the Prosperity ones showed people and I didn't like that as much. A few times I've pointed out things not to do like "no New World crops" or "no gore." Sometimes I've noted the frame color or that something is an attack; I stopped doing that eventually but probably should have kept it up. In rare cases there has been something special to communicate, like the Ruins being ruined versions of things, or the Hermit/Madman connection."

[Co0kieL0rd]

#309 - Patrician/Emporium



What is everyone looking at? Those clouds are weird. We have either leaves falling out of nowhere or a bunch of deformed birds falling out of the sky.

What the shackles? This is a really well drawn picture! The clouds look like clouds and the leaves look like leaves.

[jamfamsam]

As was stated previously in this thread, Dominion contains a lot of good art. I did a little averaging this morning and this is what I found.

Based on our scale of 1 to 7 (1 being worst), the average for group Z was 2.4. The average for group W was 3.3, nearly 1 point difference.

Average in group T was 3.7, group Q 3.9, and group N 4.1. So the difference between Z and W is greater than the difference between W and N. As we move into the large group of pretty good art, the slight change in a single vote could move a card several groups up or down. There is going to be a lot of head scratching in the next 200 cards or so. Teenage preference is going to weigh heavily into where any card ranks.

By the way, the average of all cards was 4.2 which is very close to the center of the 1 to 7 scale.

[jamfamsam]

#306 - Donate



This is the start of group U, 15 cards.

This looks more like he is putting in his ante at a gambling table. He could probably do with a little extra fiber in his diet. The hair dominates the picture.

[jamfamsam]

#305 - Tax



These soldiers have been busy. After they finished guarding the lady salting the earth, they are back around shaking people down for taxes. Everything seems squarish.

[Accatitippi]

#306 - Donate



This looks more like he is putting in his ante at a gambling table. He could probably do with a little extra fiber in his diet. The hair dominates the picture.

That's surely a she...?

[jamfamsam]

#304 - Possession



Can't figure out the gender of the main character in this picture but he/she has run into the closed sliding glass door a few times too many. Those are some creepy fingernails.

[jamfamsam]

#306 - Donate



This looks more like he is putting in his ante at a gambling table. He could probably do with a little extra fiber in his diet. The hair dominates the picture.

That's surely a she...?

I guess we called it like we saw it. On 2nd look, it could be either.

[2.71828.....]

#306 - Donate



This looks more like he is putting in his ante at a gambling table. He could probably do with a little extra fiber in his diet. The hair dominates the picture.

That's surely a she...?

That looks more like an 18th century wig than a she to me. But possible