I dont insist manda being town anymore. Her recent behavior reads scummy to me, very scummy indeed. I might even be down for lynching her unless she starts defending herself.
Galzria, thanks for clarifying your reasons for suspecting me. My comments:
I did tell you why I thought Frisk had to be town. I'm not going to apologize for realizing he is town and trying to convince others of it as well. Quite frankly, I know you are smart and experienced in this game, I think you should have realized I was right about Frisk. Maybe you didnt want to because you are mafia?
I argued Frisk being town way way harder than I did you being mafia. I was just trying to find alternative lynch targets, I think I had my vote on Robz for some time too. Well, his evasive behavior turned out a power role wanting to lay low. But saying I was equally sure of Frisk's towniness and your scumminess is 100% not correct. I didnt have a town read on you, and you seemed like a good lynch candidate. It was today when I got the scum read on you. I agree 100% with timchens case. I read his "softclaim" as a careless stupid wording, nothing more than that. His explanations make very much sense to me, yours dont.
I absolutely thought we were heading for nolynch. I know I cant prove this and apparently you and some others felt different, but I thought I got you lot convinced and no one was going to vote for Frisk. So your B is entirely incorrect. Town Eevee was happy he got people to see Frisk is town, and was settling on a nolynch until the hammer dropped.
Gloating was stupid and caused unnecessary confusion, also gave scum some weapons to attack me with. However, it was nothing but me being genuinely happy I was right about Frisk. Man it would have sucked if he had somehow fooled me.. I was very relieved to see him flip town, and I felt like a superhuman for my read and got cocky. Sorry about that again!
Today, timchen has written all the cases for me. I 100% agree with his case on you and his explanations for his own actions make perfect sense to (right until the "I give Galzria my vote"-tantrum, but to be fair you voted for yourself too so its not like you are much better in that regard). I dont think saying I've offered very little contribution is fair still. I shared my reads on manda, and why I thought she was town. No one really commented on them so I assume they werent very convincing for other, and her recent behavior has been scummy to me which I've also noted. That and I'm like the only one here who has a clear stance on your situation with timchen.
My reads at this point:
Galzria: Still suspect #1, although I think mafia is yet to "give up" and selfvote.
timchen: Frisk-level town read. Like his case against Galzria a lot.
manda: I had a town read on her, but its fading by the minute. Her lack of participation and refusal to defend herself is not earning her any points.
Young Nick: Hasnt said much, but has seemed townier than yesterday. I understand this game can be hard to keep up with, and he hasnt faced any danger of getting lynched so I sort of understand his quietness better than mandas. I dont think we should lynch Nick today, but I think he could play a little more active and try to help town more.
PPS: Has also seemed townier than yesterday I think. Most active of the inactive bunch, and has made sense when he has posted. I would appreciate some initiative though, weighing in on the timchen-Galz debate is good but actually settling on a lynch target who is mafia is pretty important here and I think PPS could help us more with that.
shark_bait: Awfully quiet today, we need to hear more from him. Could very well be mafia, is getting surprisingly little attention for how scummy he has actually played.
Oh boy I wrote a freaking book, I've got other games to attend to so wont proofread any of this, sorry!