Right. Let's do a reread. All this presupposes that ash is scum, because well he is.
Joseph claims scum. Really I thik more likely a scum move. He also names ash and me as his scum buddies. One off, one on? Sounds legit.
Jimmmmm thinks ash and I are scum together because I said we weren't. Well look at that. I think minor townpoints for Jimmmmm though.
ash has a strong townread on Jimmmmm. That says nothing for now, but you know, noted for later. (By the way, note that ash says "That was not in my PM" with regards to Ghoul powers. But PMs were just links. Only later he corrects to QT.) He immediately reverses his read on Jimmmmm. What does this say? I think it says that the contfrontation wasn't planned, and thus Jimmmmm is likely town. Which means ash was the intended scum kill. Interesting.
ash has a town read on Jimmmmm and J Reggie. If Jimmmmm is indeed town, I would think that J Reggie is scum. These are the only two reads ash has at that point, and thus one is likely on a scumpartner.
gkrieg goes after Jimmmmm. His reasoning was actually decent I thought. Mild town.
I don't like that e diagrees and says we should give reads lists, but doesn't actually push that. It's the faintest of scumreads.
Also, look here! I provided the final piece of the plan:
It is still one guaranteed scum NK if we do the plan. It fails if anyone uses their power on a different night or outside the plan. I think we should do it N1.
I would assume that scum can no-kill.
Except they cannot:
The Mafia NK is compulsory. A town-player will be randomized if no choice was submitted.
Well, then let's do it. Looks super-broken, but I guess them's the rules.
How towny is that? (Okay, not very.)
ash votes Egor out of nowhere. Hum.
Town again on gkrieg for tunneling Jimmmmm.
Seprix is weird. Not sure yet if that is alignment-indicative. But the way he argues against the plan is a bit scummy. I mean it's not so great for scum to argue against it because it's obviously good, but I could see scum!Seprix doing it.
And then gkrieg backs off his Jimmmm read after he explains. I'm telling you, this guy is town.
Also don't like Seprix arguing with teamlyle as if he knows that he's town. More scum points.
I think at the point where ash puts teamlyle to L-3, other scum would be afraid to joi the wagon. Haddock says he thinks teamlyle is town after that. Mild scum.
ashersky switches from teamlyle to Joseph, putting both at three votes. Bold move if Joseph/ash are partners.
Egor has some towny posts.
Haddock tries to figure out a coin flip hack. Some town points are in order, even if it doesn't work.
Joseph joins the teamlyle wagon, ash puts him to L-1. Coordination? That is probably too tinfoil-y.
iguana say "No idea why we lynch teamlyle, but the wagon is good". That's a towny statement.
Seprix does not want to hammer teamlyle. Scummish caution.
That's D1. I don't think there is a whole lot to be seen from D2. I will just look at the ash wagon at peak:
gkrieg13, Seprix, faust, J Reggie, ashersky
Naturallly, all those people are less likely to be scum. Well except ash. On the other hand, maybe scum was on it and that's why ash self-voted. Meh.
Overall, let me group my reads, town to scum:
gkrieg
Jimmmmm
Egor
iguana
Haddock
e
Joseph
J Reggie
Seprix
Author
Topic: M83: Duel Mafia (Game Over, Town Wins!) (Read 101571 times)