So I think uncleeurope’s misread of phyphor post it stupid but 100% believable.
Fair
I think umbrage is scummy for thinking he deliberately did it.
Same, but I also just think he is overanalyzing my posts as to not let a scum!me slide past him. Because we know each other outside of this context he is looking at me with a scum bias so that I don't "beat" him.
I do not like the uncleeurope votes at all.
I’m still curious what uncleeurope thinks of my silvercase.
Wcd you mentioned that you didn’t have an opinion on if silverspawns don’t lynch vets argument was scummy but figured it was now void. But I feel like you are missing the point that it was a scummy argument to begin with and just because it is no longer valid doesn’t take away from the objectively scummyness. I can’t see why people found it okay for silver to rule himself out of the lynch pool due to the fear that losing two vets on day one would allow a third scum vet to run away with the game. As I keep explaining the argument is full of logical flaws at all levels because it assumes one vet is scum and then says don’t lynch them and then says we need to look for one scum in the other 6 newbies. That’s worse then a random lynch which means ruling vets out was never ever ever a good idea.
Right, I saw you ask this awhile back and never got around to it. I definitely lean more (generally speaking) to the side that avoiding killing a player group based on player group is bad. I also think he is under-appreciating us newbies, a lot of us are only new to this forum, and who even cares, logically looking at statements isn't something that require hours of gameplay, it's not like we require vets to catch scum.
And yeah, as you said, it assumes the vets are divided between town and scum, and when we kill a vet, we lose the 50/50 (saying there are 2 vets) and kill a town-vet, despite us voting based on sus-levels. It's weird.
I understand where the guy is coming from, though, he is thinking worst possible scenarios. But understanding the logic of something doesn't mean agreeing with it, so I have a mixed opinion on Silver.
Why does my opinion specifically matter here?