Is there a possibility that Eevee is still lying and he actually does have a faction, or did I miss something? I'm uncomfortable with the idea of letting a scum MA live.
It's definiatally a possibility, and something we shouldn't rule out.
I don't know, I guess it's possible. Just 'Hermit' sounds like a solitary and that he 'slit his throat' sounds Serial Killer-ish.
Plus, I think we have the NKs all accounted for:
Ripped to shreds = Werewolf
Bullet holes = Mafia
Strangled = Strongman Vig (Galz)
Throat slit = Serial Killer (Eevee)
I think that the person that kills Eevee may get an extra benefit--in the same way that Galz who killed Insomniac got an extra benefit--and I think that if Eevee is lynched, it will likely be the person with who hammers? I don't know... maybe I am making this up.
But if someone does get this benefit, it should be the person who is most townie. We don't want to give out this benefit to someone that is mafia!
I agree with you on this, and here's some theory on the last part.
If we look at this through Eevee's perspective:
Let's say he's a normal Serial Killer. He's screwed. Now that we know his kill flavor, if he steps out of line, even once, he's going to be lynched. And even if he listens to us, he's still going to be lynched as the game draws to a close. So he might as well follow along, and then screw Town up at the most pivotal part, risking the next day lynch.
But Eevee isn't a normal Serial Killer, he's a MA, which makes him even more dangerous:
Imagine the above scenario, but instead of just killing 1 Town member, completely screwing with Town by activating some super powerful power. He had Bulletproof and Lightning Rod. There's no telling what else he could be getting.
No, I think if we let him live, we let him live one day so that he could activate the Lightning Rod. Or he could not and kill someone that we need. It makes this tricky, so maybe it's better off that we just lynch him today. I don't know, but I agree with yuma that we should agree on someone to hammer just incase of some 1-shot power distribution.
In case I get called out on this later: I don't want to be called scummy later for not voting for Eevee if he flips scum. Everyone knows I find him scummy. There is a deliberate reason I'm not voting for him, and that reason is to prevent derphammers as well as ensure the towniest player is the one that hammers him instead of some random Joe.