Ok, so y'all are being played. I will gladly admit, I was hoping to be able to prove scum without actually claiming last night's action because I wanted to scum to have to worry about it the next night, but I did use the shield last night. I had Haddock, myself, EFHW, and chairs in 1 group, and e, iguana, Jake, and Space in the other. If I had wanted to maximize chances of protecting someone, I would have just had me, haddock, and e in one and everyone else in the other, but e had done so little for an IC that I decided to go for something that would maximize information.
So at this point, it's pretty clear that either Haddock is really town, or he's truly a mafia mastermind (pun completely intended). I know I'm town, and I believe chairs' claim since I was blocked then night he claimed to JK me. So from that group, if a kill went through on my side, I would have been convinced it was EFHW.
On the other side, I had the IC and Space (also IC but also not going to be killed). Iguana had claimed a killing ability and scummy end of day, but I thought he would be more likely to target Haddock. Also had Jake over there. WW did have a innocent result, so if a kill went through on that side, I knew it would be one of those iguana or Jake with odds leaning iguana.
However, it is still possible that Jake is a Godfather, here's why. Earlier, someone (WW?) mentioned the possibility of Jake being the Big Bad from RMM11. That role could switch from Godfather to ninja when they chose, (likely N3 here). That would explain the change in results there and Jake thinking he was able to claim basically VT. He didn't do anything the first couple or few nights letting his team do it, then switched to ninja after he had already been copped to carry out the kills stealthily.
Basically, either iguana is telling the truth and Jake killed e, or iguana is lying about who he tried to kill knowing no other tracking (watching) roles are left. Also, chairs wouldn't have actually been able to target iguana, because shield. So I'm only either voting Jake or iguana here.