I voted MiX purely as an experiment to see if he would vote for me in retaliation, and he didn't disappoint.
But I actually think if he was scum, his buddies might have explained to him that he has to stop doing this pure retribution stay-alive-at-all-costs sort of thing.
Unvote
I was wondering what was going to happen after I voted you, since you had voted me. It was a bit of a coincidence though.
I wouldn't change my playstyle because of my buddy though.
Bolded: Townslip from Robz? I doubt it.
Possibly town slip IFF we didn't already know that Robz had read the setup in order to have his opinion that daychat would be the only power taken... However, we know he did read it, which makes that assumption look really bad to me.
If scum did pick the option to convert traitor to goon, this could actually be a scumslip, with Robz knowing that scum has multiple buddies but forgetting that town doesn't know that. So it's either a townslip or a scumslip, which kind of makes it a nothingslip.
I mean, if we didn't already have evidence that Robz had actually paid attention to the setup and that he was publicly of the opinion that scum wouldn't recruit the traitor, I would agree with you. But, from a truthful town!Robz perspective, he read it and was of the opinion scum most likely didn't recruit the traitor, and so he just momentarily forgot about what he'd read before and just used default language from other setups.
The scum!Robz narrative is that he publicly suggested that scum took different power(s) than what they really took since he knows they took the recruit option, and then just slipped with the plural "buddies."
If he hadn't read the setup at all, townslip all the way, but we know he did. There's still a possibility he just made a town!mistake based on the fact probably most games here have 3 man teams, but I don't know. This is an ironic conversation after the earlier convo about scumslips not being a real thing... I lean like 70% to it being scummy, but last time I latched onto something like this D1, I was wrong, so idk...