Nope - I just know he is town so I can trust his opinion, and he is choosing differently than I between the 2 of you, so I would like to know why.
Ok, thanks for clarifying what you meant. I have just done a complete reread of you to try and work out what you meant by the "different pages" thing. And I still didn't really get it. As far as I can see you've been suspicious of both mathdude and Didds, and often Didds more than mathdude.
Here are 3 reasons for preferring Didds:
First one is I am finding it hard to see any team that includes mathdude but not Didds. On the other hand I see a few potential teams that include Didds but not mathdude. I'll leave it a bit vague like that, so as not to influence night kill, hoping we get through to the night at all!
Second reason for stating that preference was to see what reactions I get. And the reactions from EFHW and yourself have been interesting, and make me more keen to exile Didds.
Third reason is that I'm happier using my extra vote to express the opinions of dead towns (e+scola+MiX+joth) - all 4 suspected Didds, rather than just the 2 (MiX+joth) who suspected mathdude.