Do not want to exile: gkrieg, faust, dylan
Why do you not want to exile gkrieg? Haven't posted anything scummy? That's because has hardly posted anything at all.
Ash's talked about his read on gkrieg.
vote: joth. I don't like the "he assumed he would be alive" argument and it looks like joth is taking the opportunity to jump on the wagon.
mathdude's defense makes sense if you read the offending post as written by someone who is super tired. I'm going to suspend judgement on him for now.
I'm confused about how I am the largest wagon.
I like the argument, I don't like the wagon hopping, but I prefer this vote over one on math. If it weren't for confirmation bias, I'd say this is a townie EFHW thing.
Also, if that moves my mathdude vote, it throws off MiX's wagon placement arguments.
Haha. It also makes it anti-town! Not that I particularly care.
The TLDR version:
I think mathdude slipped that they are either mafia or a PR. My bet is most likely mafia, possibly role cop given the "gather information" focus.
(An aside: If I am right about role cop, mafia selected as least one power, and if they took role cop, I'd say they took at least two more. That's all conjecture though, with no evidence.)
If they're town, they have a PR that gets a result, like Goon Cop or maybe Tracker.
(Imagine that I'm quoting the post above that one) This is the kind of logic that I cannot follow through, but is a sign of town!ash.
I wanted to share that the specific part of mathdude's post that triggered my suspicion was what read to me as their assumption they would be alive on Day 2 to partake in activities.
You know who knows they will definitely not die at night?
Ok, this I find compelling.
Let's give vote: mathdude a try.
Joke's on you; we know you're scum now!
Are you scumreading joth for this? It's not clear.
Could I entice someone to start a wagon on MiX? Every other post I read about him is like "it's just MiX doing MiX things" and I find that very irritating.
You think my scum partner's protecting me, that this reaction is unlike what town!MiX makes people say, or that you have the same first impression about me as everyone else and you find that irritating?
Could I entice someone to start a wagon on MiX? Every other post I read about him is like "it's just MiX doing MiX things" and I find that very irritating.
But people feeling frustrated at MiX's behaviour is such a "just people doing people things" thing...
TBH, I don't hate the idea of running up a few votes on MiX and seeing who jumps. Why do you want to entice someone else to do the dirty work of starting the wagon, though, rather than just dropping your own vote there and then observing who follows?
Do you scumread me? Why would you run a wagon at me in particular?
Could I entice someone to start a wagon on MiX? Every other post I read about him is like "it's just MiX doing MiX things" and I find that very irritating.
But people feeling frustrated at MiX's behaviour is such a "just people doing people things" thing...
TBH, I don't hate the idea of running up a few votes on MiX and seeing who jumps. Why do you want to entice someone else to do the dirty work of starting the wagon, though, rather than just dropping your own vote there and then observing who follows?
I don't want to dismantle the mathdude wagon.
Is MiX a better alterative than Robz, if you're looking to grow a second wagon to compete?
PPE: MiX posted another quote wall.. haven't read it yet, but already wondering whether it will change my query about Robz being a better competing wagon target :-P
Why did you mention Robz all of a sudden?
Hey, it's not my fault I'm playing catchup all day, I've been kinda busy lately.