Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[LibraryAdventurer]

oops. Once again, I pressed the quote button thinking I was pressing 'modify post'.

[scott_pilgrim]

well played!
also nicely done LA, you managed to fool everyone into thinking you're town.

thanks

was your frustration with forum mafia also faked, or was that real?

That wasn't faked. I just think IRL mafia is much more fun, but it was fun to watch the game after I was lynched.
It's possible that it's partly because I was mafia for my first game, but I doubt I'll try again. It also takes more time than I had hoped, and I don't want to spend that much time on a forum mafia game, especially not if players are expected to go back and reread the other players' posts. I'm glad I gave it a try anyway.

You should still stick around and spectate though.  It's like playing, but without the pressure and time commitment!

The game is very different for town and scum too, you might enjoy being town.

[faust]

Well, we managed to pull it off even without having to kill off one of us

I think town was very much hurt in this game by sort of implicitly assuming that scum was all vanilla. I mean this is RMM, did you really expect that? I brought up potential scum powers multilple times, you didn't ever consider that scum might have messed with anything. It's obviously a stretch to get to what really happened here on the final day, but at least there was one scum guaranteed in lio/me, so lynching outside of that was quite bad.

I blundered a bit through the middle, partly due to VLA and pit being gone. Vanillaising the same player twice and not using Swamp Hag on the extra night was not great... but it worked out beautifully.

As for the setup, I feel 3 scum in 11 players already gave us a good starting position, not necessarily overpowered, but strong. The random role distribution ended up kinda swingy... it would have been much harder for us if the Swamp Hag had fallen to town hands, and much easier if we had gotten the Page. I'm not sure I'm a fan of that. The game had some interesting ideas though, the Page neighborhood stuff was quite cool.

[faust]

Huh.

Not sure my sub was needed.  Why'd you kill me?

Man, you had such a huge target on your back. You were loved, you were going to be tested and IC'd, you were likely the Page due to silver's (and only silver's) death, and you were a wildcard, bringing in a fresh viewpoint and potentially shaking established opinions (like "faust is town").

[silverspawn]

right, I wanted to ask - faust, were your scumslips actually scumslips this game?

[faust]

right, I wanted to ask - faust, were your scumslips actually scumslips this game?

I wouldn't say that - I mean, there was daytalk, so yes I also posted in the QTs, but I also did a lot of editing QTs in preparation for Buffy/Angel, so it could have happened just as easily had I been town.

[liopoil]

Doesn't everyone just highlight and click the bold "B" in the upper left?

[silverspawn]

Doesn't everyone just highlight and click the bold "B" in the upper left?

no.

[skip wooznum]

Doesn't everyone just highlight and click the bold "B" in the upper left?

<b>ye i do that</b>