Ok, I am not going to have as much time to spend on this as I thought, but will do my best on it specifically focusing on the first four (as well as faust)
From this point I want to try to find scummier players out of: liopoil, eevee, 2.7 and mail-mi and maybe faust, lekkit.
liopoil: started off really slow, picked up the pace after hitting L-2 for lurking. People have said his response was townie? What was townie about it. He started posting to save his own hide. At most that is a null tell and worst a scumtell. I still think that he remained calm and composed indicates kinda scumminess... has anyone checked how he responded in moderncommunity (I haven't yet)... but realize he has a valid point in explaining why he did.... His votes have also felt very self preserving (once he voted) and he doesn't really give reads (he does give some town reads, voltaire for example) until he gives the % post after ash calls everyone out for not doing it (once again, only doing something after being called out) and is mostly defending himself when he does come back
eevee: less posting than liopoil lately, pretty even a while back though, so while liopoil amped up his posting eevee has just kinda maintained the status quo. He was one player I thought started off with the PoE way too early and really hasn't done so since then. Interesting! There is nothing here. Nothing, especially of late he said he chimed in everytime he thought he had something to offer, but I dont' believe that. town!Eevee has more to say on these subjects. Based off this I would vote for eevee before I would vote for liopoil
vote: eevee2.7: up until now I was voting for him. The main point against him was that he lurked until called out and then majorily amped up his posting. And not just a bit like liopoil, but by a lot! If he is scum that takes a tremendous effort and had it happened before being called out would have been worthy of being taken off the potential lynch list. Other stuff he has done has been weird: sheeping ashersky in a way, voting for chairs recently, voting and unvoting lekkit a few days ago. So there is stuff I am concerned about here, but I am beginning to think that his substance and posting will help us learn his alignment better on a later day. This does set a precident for scum, if he is scum. if you are called out for lurking and triple or quadruple your posts afterward you probably won't get lynched... I am fine with this sort of a precident and don't think scum will successfully be able to get away with it. If 2.7 is scum, I am impressed.
mail-mi: only a few more posts than eevee: Also started PoEing too early I think, but has posted similar posts throughout the thread.... Pretty typical mail-mi early on. I am not sure what voltaire was pinpointing as being different. This isn't to say that mail-mi looks town, but rather that that last few times he has been scum he looked the same as when he was town and by that I mean, willing to vote just about anybody that came up for a lynch, sheepy, lurky and just plain old scummy (his bias/stats post especially and voting for chairs just after 2.7 did)
I am not going to look at lekkit right now. Instead I'll look at faust:
faust: (note that this doesn't include talking about his claim or posts postclaim only stuff before), I'll talk more about his claim stuff if/when after he responds to the questions pending for him... was very active early, but has tapered off into the late game. if I remember correctly I pointed this out about him in GoT and started a wagon on him because of it. I still think it is a scummier trait, but since that sample didn't indicate he was scum I am not sure it is in regard to him.... Again I just don't see the significance of what ash pointed out in the early game.... (does this change with his claim, that I guess is something to think about, but again I'll look at that later), also had the early PoE thing going on, but has also continued to post in similar manner throughout... He reads ash as scum, something I am beginning to disagree with more and more (and hope that he doesn't shoot ash if he is town and is lynched). His whole day really has been focused on conversing with ash and 2.7 and is kinda hard to get a read on...
Conclusion:
2.7 and Lekkit I think are out of my lynch pool. Faust is back in it (w/o the claim at least). I think I prefer eevee over mail-mi over liopoil. and I will continue to
vote: eevee. w/o faust's claim I think I would put faust between mail-mi and liopoil... with it... I am not sure.
Author
Topic: Mafia XXXVI: Dynasty Warriors Mafia 2 The Battle of Red Cliffs(Town wins!) (Read 202102 times)