Reads, cause I feel lost right now so I need to organise my thoughts, and I might as well do it in the thread.
Voltaire : He has made very little sense this game. As Eevee eloquently proved, this makes him town. Just kidding... except not really. Seriously, his reads and votes are completely all over the place, in a way which I think is too extreme to be scum. He's just town who posts way too much. Town.
Lekkit : Made a good case on Voltaire which helped the transition into scumhunting. Town.
chairs : Not sure why, but this reread has given me a town read on him.
mail-mi : Has an incredibly anti-town meta, but seems slightly less scummy here. Slight town.
ashersky: Flavour claims too early, but it seems like something he'd do. Have we decided that his flavour was irrelevant to figuring out his alignement btw ? His reason for not having a plan was good. Slight town.
faust : His case on ash is weak but not unreasonable. Not much else to say. Null.
yuma: Absent but constructive. That's null for yuma I think.
Robz: I don't know. I have a bad feeling about him, but nothing concrete. Slight scum.
Eeevee : Lurking. Reasonable when he posts. Reminds me of GoT. Slight scum.
liopoil : Lurking. Apparently this might be a scum tell for him ? Slight scum.
Ichimaru : Playing up the newb card. A lot. The OMGUS seems forced newbishness. Surprised Robz hasn't commented on that. Scummy.
2.7 : Flavour claims too early, which I don't like at all. Same question as for ashersky as far as his flavour goes. What really gets me is the faust vote. I have a votes summary whrere I write down reasons, and here I wrote "Unclear why". That's already bad, but there were plenty of those in this game (looking at you, Voltaire). The problem is he then acts as if he had built an incredibly strong case on faust, so much so that he wants everyone to respond to it. There's nothing to respond too ! All you have is "I can't shake the feeling faust is scum." That's fine, but it's not actually a case. Which is exactly his objection to faust's case on ash. So yeah.
Actually, I've talked myself into a vote: 2.7 here. Summaries are scumhuntaries !