Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Teproc]

Is there any way flavour claiming can be good for town without the game being broken ?

[Voltaire]

Oh! But they don't know who to say they are instead . Yes, mass claim immediately

Are we already so sold this is a good idea?  Based on my read of the setup, anybody who actually has a name to claim is a PR.

Really? Maybe that's the source of my confusion.

Huge town read on Robz btw.

[ashersky]

Let's try this.

I'm Zhang Fei.  Does that help anyone figure anything out about how flavor claiming will help us catch scum?

[Teproc]

Wait, what ? We haven't reached an agreement yet !

[Voltaire]

Wait, what ? We haven't reached an agreement yet !

Have you read the last game? 

[Voltaire]

Let's try this.

I'm Zhang Fei.  Does that help anyone figure anything out about how flavor claiming will help us catch scum?

No idea. I think Robz needs to tell us.

Also

Based on my read of the setup, anybody who actually has a name to claim is a PR.

vote: chairs

[Robz888]

Let's try this.

I'm Zhang Fei.  Does that help anyone figure anything out about how flavor claiming will help us catch scum?

Well, there are roles that like Zhang Fei would be more likely to have than others. Zhang Fei is a face officer, so you are a PR? Lets not keep doing this until fake claim existence is clarified. Someone read the PRe game chatter please

[Teproc]

I have not. I'm sure it's hilarious. But I'm pretty worried right now, I don't think flavour claiming can be good for town without being broken here. Unless someone can explain that to me, I'm against it.

Zhang Fei is a random southern general I think. So a good guy, obviously, but probably not a PR. That's just from skimming Wikipedia a few days ago though.

[Robz888]

Ignore teprocs comment, it is ill informed I think. Dam it I really need laptop access

[Teproc]

Also

Based on my read of the setup, anybody who actually has a name to claim is a PR.

The "No Face" is just to remind people that's the flavor for VT (same as last game) I assume.

vote: chairs
[/quote]

Didn't you say the same thing ?

[Robz888]

I don't know how to confirm whether all face officers are PRs and whether scum have fake claims, or even if these things are already known.

[Teproc]

Messed up my quote.

And yeah, ignore me, I only said something because I thought Robz wasn't there right now and I recognized the name. HIt would be nice having someone else knowledgeable though, because if Robz is scum and he's the only one who knows about the flavour, we're kinda screwed ?

[Voltaire]

I have not. I'm sure it's hilarious.

The point is, ash was a PR and claimed immediately. If he's a PR here, he knows revealing his flavor risks revealing that, so he's comfortable with it.

Robz, I have reviewed the pre-game. mcmc pointedly refused to say mafia have fake-claims, but did say that they will be given...something unknown.

And unvote.

I found this:

So how exactly does flavor claiming work? Does that just mean that when we claim we can also claim flavor (names, etc)?

Yes it means if you want you can claim to be Meng Huo of the Nanaman Clan. That would be silly because he has no business being anywhere near Chi Bi but you know you could say that. Flavor will relate directly to alignment so heads up, don't claim Cao Cao

[Voltaire]

Didn't you say the same thing ?

"No Face" doesn't mean "no name".

[ashersky]

Teproc, you are currently voting chairs now, due to your broken quote.  You can unvote or not, but thought I'd point it out.

I believe mcmc would not leave scum out to dry with flavor claims.

[Voltaire]

Just wait for the PM's and Night one info then if ya got stuff to cry about message me!

Also scum may not know things until N1?

[Robz888]

Is ash a PR tho? Do I want us to know that?

[ashersky]

The point is, ash was a PR and claimed immediately. If he's a PR here, he knows revealing his flavor risks revealing that, so he's comfortable with it.

In DW1, I knew the set-up like the back of my hand, and with the IC, I knew claiming my role there was going to help (and it did).

I'm not claiming PR/Not PR right now.  Just willing to out my flavor name to see if it helps us decide if everyone should do it.

[Teproc]

Oh thanks ash, didn't realise that.

unvote

That would be an embarassing hammer if that kind of stuff happened.

[Robz888]

I have to stop posting, I'm on the bus to the metro now and I get carsick. Sorry!

[Voltaire]

The point is, ash was a PR and claimed immediately. If he's a PR here, he knows revealing his flavor risks revealing that, so he's comfortable with it.

In DW1, I knew the set-up like the back of my hand, and with the IC, I knew claiming my role there was going to help (and it did).

I'm not claiming PR/Not PR right now.  Just willing to out my flavor name to see if it helps us decide if everyone should do it.

Well, based on what Robz has said your flavor name makes you more likely to be a PR. I guess the two of you will have to somehow figure out if that is a good thing or not? Hergh.

I've quoted already everything mcmc said about claims & stuff since the day started if you look back at my posts.

Small town read on Teproc I think. Maybe. But a big one on Robz.

[Voltaire]

Where can I find a list of who is a "face officer" and who is a "no-face" officer for these characters? I'm at a loss.

[2.71828.....]

I don't know Dynasty Warriors, so mass-claiming flavor names will not really help me.  However, it could be really useful to certain PR town members (Robz?) as they make decisions for night actions.  I like flavor name claiming. 

I am Zhuge Liang

[Voltaire]

I don't know Dynasty Warriors, so mass-claiming flavor names will not really help me.  However, it could be really useful to certain PR town members (Robz?) as they make decisions for night actions.  I like flavor name claiming. 

I am Zhuge Liang

Hold up. No-one else do this right now. Are you aware we are currently unclear if this just outs all our PRs?

[Teproc]

Why ? Seriously, why ? Why would you do that ? Half the people in the game haven't even posted yet and you guys are claiming flavor names ? What's the rush exactly ?

And Zhuge Liang is a very important guy I think. Robz will confirm/infirm this obviously.