/// Voltgloss - being replaced. Could possibly be scum and we are all deciding which of our town selves to kill because scum isn't actually present ///
The following list is ordered from Towny to Scummy on my radar:
mail-mi - I'm reserving him Town status for now. His play was definitely pro-town but it doesn't earn IC.
Jimmmmm - Pro-town play all around. Jimmmmm was onto both EFHW and ashersky which is exceptionally good play regardless of his alignment. I will allow that he isn't Witch or Wof aligned. He could easily be Mafia. I am my most pro-town when I am scum precisely because I know where I can be and how to avoid looking scummy.
XerxesPraelor - well, this guy is not putting much out there to work with. He's staying off wagons entirely. He's definitely more interested in defending self than scum hunting. He's a noob at the game so I cut him lots of slack. There has been a clue that corresponds with something in my QT that suggests he may be friend. Otherwise I'd have him ranked far lower. The clue is not something I feel comfortable revealing today. Basedon the current game state I think tomorrow may be appropriate. Without the clue I'd vote him to pressure something out of him. So, xerxes, if you're reading this start talking.
chairs - what meta I have on mafia!chairs is that he loves to be on a wagon. chairs sheeped me on Jimmmmm early but I beleive he saw a scumslip same as I. He was rightly on ashersky,everyone but a Wolf was rightly on ashersky. His question about his alignment was perfectly sound and in line with garnering information for Town. Mafia would know quite well that ashersky wasn't Mafia. If chairs is scum then Jimmmmm is town thus the ordering.
Morgrim7 - ah, morgrim.... wtf. This guy is the archetypical wild-card. He's the proverbial box-of-chocolates. The cop-claim. Holy hell, claiming cop while under zero pressure to do so?! If I had copped someone as clean in RMM I would consider my read with a grain of salt. I'd also make some kind of defense that didn't outright broadcast arguably the strongest possible Town role. But, I'm not Morgrim and I can see Morgrim nonchalantly claiming cop just for the fun of it. The claim protonates an otherwise null read which is what I generally have on Morgrim. It's a great scum ploy if you're scum, Morgrim. I'm not sure that if I were the doctor I'd follow you right now, I think your claim was entirely premature.
faust - faust is always on the critical side as Town. questions everything and everyone regardless. he develops independent reads and sticks with them even when other wagons are forming. Made a believable claim that is evidenced to be true. I had actually categorized faust as likely scum ranked lower when I started this list but upon research he fits his meta. I'll give him more of a null read at this juncture.
xeiron - I am very uneasy here. There seems to be some genuine scum-hunting. But look, if there are multiple scum factions then those factions are definitely scum-hunting too. If there is a Mafia then they are in just as good of shape as Town right now. If xeiron were say, EFHW's witch partner (and I believe that a Watcher role would require a partner) then his scum-hunting is not necessarily in Town's best interests. xeiron and faust seem to be attached at the hip in how they are voting and analyzing the game. I could see them being a scum pair except the mailman bit contradicts them having a shared QT.
BoxOfDog - I've only seen Box as town. He looks just like town box. meta aside, he strikes me as a liability to his alignment regardless of his alignment. thus, if he is town he is a liability to me and losing him isn't a big deal. If he is not Town then I want him dead. I really want to see this guy step up his game someday. His current style makes him an easy lynch any day by any alignment. He reminds me of early Morgrim not in style but just in the sense that he is the easy lynch for being a liability.