Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[sudgy]

With multiple cop-types around, it makes good balancing sense for scum to have a roleblocker.

With a Forced Claim Cop (remember xeiron?), it makes PERFECT sense for scum to have a roleblocker.  That's how you (as scum) deal with a claimed Cop, when the possibility of Doctoring out there somewhere:  you roleblock them.

But would  I, as scum, claim my scum role? No.

(I did in RMM6...)

I seem to remember Robz one time claiming Roleblocker.  I can't remember if he was scum or town though.

[Voltgloss]

So like, where do we go from here? Are we going to wait for Galz/Robz to claim what they saw? I would absolutely like to have them say it.

I propose we let mail-mi get to a computer and give his reads (and anything else he wishes to say).  I would also like to give Voltaire an opportunity to respond, as he specifically requested as such.

[Voltgloss]

And nobody "unvote for safety," please. 

[mail-mi]

With multiple cop-types around, it makes good balancing sense for scum to have a roleblocker.

With a Forced Claim Cop (remember xeiron?), it makes PERFECT sense for scum to have a roleblocker.  That's how you (as scum) deal with a claimed Cop, when the possibility of Doctoring out there somewhere:  you roleblock them.

But would  I, as scum, claim my scum role? No.

Remember when I was Gladiator in LOTR 2?  Yeah.

Remember when you were a compulsive D1 or 2 Gladiator in LOTR 2? Yeah.

[Voltgloss]

With multiple cop-types around, it makes good balancing sense for scum to have a roleblocker.

With a Forced Claim Cop (remember xeiron?), it makes PERFECT sense for scum to have a roleblocker.  That's how you (as scum) deal with a claimed Cop, when the possibility of Doctoring out there somewhere:  you roleblock them.

But would  I, as scum, claim my scum role? No.

Remember when I was Gladiator in LOTR 2?  Yeah.

Remember when you were a compulsive D1 or 2 Gladiator in LOTR 2? Yeah.

What's your point?  That's exactly what I was, and exactly what I claimed.  I just didn't claim my alignment (scum).

[Voltgloss]

Speaking of claims:  mail-mi, why did you support massclaim?

[mail-mi]

With multiple cop-types around, it makes good balancing sense for scum to have a roleblocker.

With a Forced Claim Cop (remember xeiron?), it makes PERFECT sense for scum to have a roleblocker.  That's how you (as scum) deal with a claimed Cop, when the possibility of Doctoring out there somewhere:  you roleblock them.

But would  I, as scum, claim my scum role? No.

(I did in RMM6...)

But whisperer is usually a town role. Roleblocker isn't.

[sudgy]

With multiple cop-types around, it makes good balancing sense for scum to have a roleblocker.

With a Forced Claim Cop (remember xeiron?), it makes PERFECT sense for scum to have a roleblocker.  That's how you (as scum) deal with a claimed Cop, when the possibility of Doctoring out there somewhere:  you roleblock them.

But would  I, as scum, claim my scum role? No.

Remember when I was Gladiator in LOTR 2?  Yeah.

Remember when you were a compulsive D1 or 2 Gladiator in LOTR 2? Yeah.

What's your point?  That's exactly what I was, and exactly what I claimed.  I just didn't claim my alignment (scum).

His point is that you had no choice, so you had to claim it.

Also, I remember the game Robz was a Roleblocker, he was a Survivor/Traitor.

[sudgy]

(RMM7 if you're wondering)

[Voltgloss]

sudgy, how do you know what mail-mi's point is?  That's not what I thought he was saying at all.

[Voltgloss]

And Roleblocker can be a town OR a scum role.  What I'm saying is that, given what we know about the setup (and accepting at least some of the other unforced claims as true), it makes balancing sense for scum to have a roleblocker.

[mail-mi]

Speaking of claims:  mail-mi, why did you support massclaim?

Because 2/3 of town had already claimed, and them I could use my singular Roleblock more effectively.

[Twistedarcher]

sudgy, how do you know what mail-mi's point is?  That's not what I thought he was saying at all.

I saw it the same way Sudgy did. He changed it so that it was the same quote, but added the word "compulsive", meaning that you were forced to claim and you had no choice.

[mail-mi]

sudgy, how do you know what mail-mi's point is?  That's not what I thought he was saying at all.

That was my point.

[sudgy]

It was obvious that was what the point was.  You didn't see it, so I pointed it out.

[Voltgloss]

I thought he was saying I didn't fully claim all aspects of my role.  My bad.

[EFHW]

omg 110 ppe.  I have some thoughts, don't know if they are still relevant. 

[EFHW]

I haven't seen the shows, but it says in my PM that i win when all threats to the Study Group are eliminated.

No one had explicitly stated this before mail-mi.

It's risky b/c if he is mafia or another kind of scum, he wouldn't know for sure that the PM said study group or town in the wincon.

[EFHW]

I have had a thought that contradicts Galz and Robz's assumptions, but not sure if/how to share it.  I don't even know if I have the right post in mind! 

[Voltgloss]

Speaking of claims:  mail-mi, why did you support massclaim?

Because 2/3 of town had already claimed, and them I could use my singular Roleblock more effectively.

I am trying to figure out how much I believe this.  I really don't know.  I need to think more on it.

[Voltgloss]

I have had a thought that contradicts Galz and Robz's assumptions, but not sure if/how to share it.  I don't even know if I have the right post in mind!

Let's hold off for now.

I would like to wait for mail-mi to get to a computer and give his reads.

[EFHW]

mail-mi said his name wasn't on the list of characters.  Is that true?

[EFHW]

I have had a thought that contradicts Galz and Robz's assumptions, but not sure if/how to share it.  I don't even know if I have the right post in mind!

Let's hold off for now.

I would like to wait for mail-mi to get to a computer and give his reads.

If I have the right post in mind, then we do we want him to post anything more? 

[Voltgloss]

mail-mi said his name wasn't on the list of characters.  Is that true?

Yes.

[Voltgloss]

I have had a thought that contradicts Galz and Robz's assumptions, but not sure if/how to share it.  I don't even know if I have the right post in mind!

Let's hold off for now.

I would like to wait for mail-mi to get to a computer and give his reads.

If I have the right post in mind, then we do we want him to post anything more?

Mrrrg.  I know, I know, I am grappling with this too.