I agree with Yuma, I also found liopoil scummy before robz claim. vote: liopoil
this is getting frustrating man. D2, you disagreed with me about SB, but didn't vote. Then when yuma said he had a case on me, you decided that I was pushing a SB lynch scummily. Then today, you posted, said nothing about me, then as soon as yuma posts about me, you vote for me. I mean, come on! do you like, not want to be the first on the wagon or something? and the thing is, this isn't anything new. I've been scum exactly once, and you were my scumbuddy. I've been town in every single other game, and in every single other game, you've heavily suspected me.
You aren't sheeping Yuma though, you have different reasons. you're reason is that I was trying to lynch someone who you think is town, and apparently did it in a scummy way because I was taking the easy way out, and would be more likely to do that as scum than town. I mean, that's just SO weak now, we have a dead scum to look at, and you're basing your read off of having an uncomfirmed townread on another player and interpreting the way I don't share that read as scummy.
Look, I'm sure you aren't finding me scummy over and over again on purpose, but it's getting kinda out of hand. Part of me thinks that you're scum because if you were town you would realize that your reasoning is weak and you just always find me scummy.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm going to
Vote: Yuma.
he's awfully certain about me while saying things like:
I see no reason to not to vote: liopoil.
[snip]
Really, I don't have any concerete evidence, but my gut says liopoil, has for most of today and I feel it is correct.
[snip]
And his big post on me:
which is primarily saying that I am trying to steer town to its downfall.
He has other reasons, and plans on making another big case apparently. But here's the deal:
For Yuma, having bad reads is a scumtell. Yes. In my time here, whenever he's town he does really well at catching scum, with few exceptions. And he's gotten it badly wrong this game. He was wrong on nkirbit, and he's terribly wrong on me. Sure, he didn't oppose Robz's lynch, but nobody did, it was the clear lynch of the day.
I'll cite mean girls. He was scum there, and was "wrong" on robz, mcmc, and xeiron, and then won by lynching mail-mi. Scum also won that game by fakeclaiming. Scum fakeclaimed in this game, and in reality, it was probably a good move by robz, just didn't work out. And I think Yuma set robz up to do it. he started the theory discussion in the middle of the day:
Warning: about to do some theory discussion below...
[snip]
... as such I realize that there may be a benefit of having a cop (if there is one) claim today.
Here is why:
[snip]
If people really don't want to discuss this, I am sorry, but I think this specific scenario is worth talking about because it could put town in an incredibly advantageous situation.
and robz replies with:
I think we should do it. I like plans like this. The best case scenario is really good, the worst case scenario is very unlikely, and the middle scenarios are OKAY.
and in his next post:
Yeah, let's just do it. 
I am the Cop.
I really think Yuma set him up to do that, so that his claim didn't come out of nowhere.
So really, I have 3 main points:
- case on me is weak and looks strongly to me like pushing a mislynch.
- town!yuma gets it right, scum!yuma gets it wrong. Yuma has been getting it wrong.
- totally set robz's claim up.
Author
Topic: Mafia XXVI: Back to Basics (Day 3) (Read 99007 times)