Why does two kills disappearing point towards Sudgy being scum? I understand why two kills elsewhere would point to it, but two kills disappearing and two kills elsewhere are not the same.
I'm really confused here. Help me out, please.
You think it's perfectly reasonable for sudgy to have survived the first night after his claim because he was protected somehow.
You also think it's perfectly reasonable for both Eevee and Sudgy to have survived the night after Eevee claimed because doctors or some other life saver are involved.
You think Eevee is scum.
So you think Sudgy is town and was targeted by his lover who happens to be scum.
Am I totally misunderstanding you or are these your positions?
What I think happened N1 was TA was the nightkill and commuted through it. We know TA commuted, so this seems reasonable regardless of whether or not Sudgy is scum or not. If Sudgy were town, I think scum would avoid him N1 because of the high likelihood there's a doctor protecting him.
N2, I don't know what happened. It's possible that scum!eevee declined to NK, because he thought in the current climate he could make his claim, get sudgy lynched, then nightkill for the likely win. It's possible that he tried to kill someone like mail-mi or efhw and the kill got stopped somehow.
I know it's unlikely, but it's just as unlikely had Sudgy been scum. Even more unlikely, perhaps, because Sudgy doesn't have to avoid targeting an obvious doctor target. If Sudgy is scum, his partner and him had to miss twice. That's just as unlikely.