Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[mameluke]

Hi all,
This seems to be a serious error in Goko. Some cards, like Mandarin and Duchess should not show the other player what gets put back on top of the deck. But Goko does in fact tell the other player (I've been using the log "parser" from this site, and it just came to my attention). Can anyone confirm that the same happens with Ghost Ship, Cartographer, Lookout, and the like?

I've also noticed the same with discarding--if you get hit by Militia, you can see exactly which cards were discarded. Iso didn't do this, but Iso also didn't let you see the top card of the other players' discard. In IRL games, I definitely know at least one of the cards that gets discarded, so I'm less concerned about this one. Is there an official ruling about revealing discarded cards?

PS: http://dom.retrobox.eu/?/20130320/log.50ef27c4e4b01a13905ce40e.1363843344379.txt E.g. turn 26 for Mandarin and Duchess.

[Awaclus]

Is there an official ruling about revealing discarded cards?

You don't have to reveal discarded cards, you just have to show how many you are discarding and obviously the top card is then going to be visible.