Okay, here's my thoughts:
If we can jump the fleet in, we have some nice space superiority which will cause significant problems for the humans. Especially seeing as there are 4 civvies out there.
This makes me feel like Basestar Bridge might be ideal.
OTOH:
humans currently have some significant problems with skill cards...So, a skill-check crisis will probably be failed. Otherwise, anything hitting food or fuel is a good option for us. BUT making the admiral, CAG, or president discard cards is practically worthless. Anything sending people to sick bay from a Galactica location is worthless, destroying active vipers, hitting population or morale is weak-ish.
So, crisis has better potential, but also has some potential to be effectively nothing except at least bypassing Boomer's crisis. Trying to jump in the fleet with 3 extra raiders is pretty good, and if you hit their jump track instead, still decent.
I'm torn between them...I think I lean slightly towards trying to jump in the fleet. (after all, if we get a raider activation later, that could get a few civvies which might hurt some tracks also.)