Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[RiemannZetaJones]

The interaction of Throne Room and duration cards is, for the most part, well-known:
http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?topic=1585.msg25425#msg25425

also well-known is that a Tactician played discarding cards does not have an effect next turn, and consequently does not stay in play after clean-up.

If I play TR-TR-Caravan-Tactician, the Tactician is played twice by the TR, but only discards cards once. What remains in play after clean-up?

[Jimmmmm]

The Caravan, the Tactician and one Throne Room.

[Morgrim7]

The only cards left out are the cards that have direct interaction with the durations. In this case, the second TR was being played twice, and you chose a duration both times. Even though you had to have another TR to actually TR your TR, the first had no direct interaction with the duration cards. Same for KC.

[qmech]

The only cards left out are the cards that have direct interaction with the durations. In this case, the second TR was being played twice, and you chose a duration both times. Even though you had to have another TR to actually TR your TR, the first had no direct interaction with the duration cards. Same for KC.

In particular, if the Tactician was a Caravan then you would still only leave one TR on the table (so the Tactician here is a distratction).

[Morgrim7]

The only cards left out are the cards that have direct interaction with the durations. In this case, the second TR was being played twice, and you chose a duration both times. Even though you had to have another TR to actually TR your TR, the first had no direct interaction with the duration cards. Same for KC.

In particular, if the Tactician was a Caravan then you would still only leave one TR on the table (so the Tactician here is a distratction).

Yes, thats what I said.

[RiemannZetaJones]

The only cards left out are the cards that have direct interaction with the durations. In this case, the second TR was being played twice, and you chose a duration both times. Even though you had to have another TR to actually TR your TR, the first had no direct interaction with the duration cards. Same for KC.

No, both TR stay out: http://boardgamegeek.com/article/4119598#4119598

[heron]

RZJ, that ruling was revised again later to agree with what the others in this thread are saying.

Edit: http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?topic=210.msg14030#msg14030

[RiemannZetaJones]

RZJ, that ruling was revised again later to agree with what the others in this thread are saying.

Edit: http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?topic=210.msg14030#msg14030

Thanks. Looking at the Seaside rulebook, I am surprised there was ever any question about this. The original interpretation was convoluted.