Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Archetype]

I think I would have made the Traitor 1-shot Lynchproof instead of Vengeful.

[Jorbles]

Whooaaaa nice work Jimmmm. I did not see that coming.

[ashersky]

I think I would have made the Traitor 1-shot Lynchproof instead of Vengeful.

That's a neat idea.  But in practice, how dose lynchproof work?  I mean, he hits lynch, I reset the votes, day continues.  Then they lynch him again?

[Eevee]

The more I think about it, the more I give credit for ashersky for managing to balance a game this complicated this well. I really like RMM games like this.

[Eevee]

I think I would have made the Traitor 1-shot Lynchproof instead of Vengeful.

That's a neat idea.  But in practice, how dose lynchproof work?  I mean, he hits lynch, I reset the votes, day continues.  Then they lynch him again?

How eHalcyon did it in RMM3 was that the day ended as if the town had nolynched.

[Jorbles]

Also I think I was perhaps the LVP in that game. My insistence on race analysis was detrimental to town because ash thought of fake claims (something I actually should have considered as I modded a game with him where we spent some time planning fake claims for the scum team.) Anyhow this was a great setup. Could you possibly play it open?

[Jorbles]

I think I would have made the Traitor 1-shot Lynchproof instead of Vengeful.

That's a neat idea.  But in practice, how dose lynchproof work?  I mean, he hits lynch, I reset the votes, day continues.  Then they lynch him again?

He gets lynched, doesn't die, night happens.

[Archetype]

I think I would have made the Traitor 1-shot Lynchproof instead of Vengeful.

That's a neat idea.  But in practice, how dose lynchproof work?  I mean, he hits lynch, I reset the votes, day continues.  Then they lynch him again?

How eHalcyon did it in RMM3 was that the day ended as if the town had nolynched.

Bingo.

Would have hurt Town a lot by helping both scum teams, but not too much.

[Archetype]

Could you possibly play it open?

/in

[ashersky]

Also I think I was perhaps the LVP in that game. My insistence on race analysis was detrimental to town because ash thought of fake claims (something I actually should have considered as I modded a game with him where we spent some time planning fake claims for the scum team.) Anyhow this was a great setup. Could you possibly play it open?

I think there's some follow-the-cop stuff if you play it open, given we have two cops and two-half docs.  But it could probably be tweaked to be an open set-up.

I think I would have made the Traitor 1-shot Lynchproof instead of Vengeful.

That's a neat idea.  But in practice, how dose lynchproof work?  I mean, he hits lynch, I reset the votes, day continues.  Then they lynch him again?

He gets lynched, doesn't die, night happens.

Then he gets recruited, then lynched (if the set-up is open .

[ashersky]

Could you possibly play it open?

/in

I think semi-open might work.  Like, 50% chance there is a traitor, etc.

[Eevee]

Reading through the QT's, the dragons definitely deserved a win. Great scum team with elaborate planning and high level discussion.

[Jorbles]

Could you possibly play it open?

/in

I think semi-open might work.  Like, 50% chance there is a traitor, etc.

Yeah, if you could set it up like 2of4 somehow where's there's a chance of some roles not existing. But that's harder as it's hard to balance many roles when some of them might not be in it.

[Archetype]

Could you possibly play it open?

/in

Though you would have to change some things. Probably change Guard into Bodyguard, but whenever they target someone they get results back in the form of Beloved Princess/Not Beloved Princess.

But then there would have to be a way to prevent Beloved Princess from claiming.

[Axxle]

If it was open town just massclaims to start and then wins by lynching the duplicates.

[Jimmmmm]

Reading through the QT's, the dragons definitely deserved a win. Great scum team with elaborate planning and high level discussion.

I was just annoyed that we didn't realise that the Traitor would investigate non-Dragon. If we had, there was a good chance I would have redirected from sudgy.

[Axxle]

Reading through the QT's, the dragons definitely deserved a win. Great scum team with elaborate planning and high level discussion.

I wanted Morgrim to submit the nightkill but he wouldn't respond...

[Axxle]

Reading through the QT's, the dragons definitely deserved a win. Great scum team with elaborate planning and high level discussion.

I wanted Morgrim to submit the nightkill but he wouldn't respond...

(oh yeah, timezones, didn't think about that)

[ashersky]

Reading through the QT's, the dragons definitely deserved a win. Great scum team with elaborate planning and high level discussion.

I was just annoyed that we didn't realise that the Traitor would investigate non-Dragon. If we had, there was a good chance I would have redirected from sudgy.

Yeah, knowing how and how much info to give the scum teams about the Traitor was tough.  More info would have made it easier for scum, which I wasn't trying to do.

I mean, Town was disadvantaged enough--Beloved Princess, closed set-up, Hammerers, Godfather/Framer possibility...that's why we went with Day Masons, who can be really powerful, double docs + Guard, and one cop each.

[Jimmmmm]

I obviously didn't want it to be this one, but I think it's high time Town wins a game.

[Morgrim7]

Thx for the game!

[Jimmmmm]

When sudgy was caught I figured that the only possible way for me to win was to get WS to get a non-Dragon result on me, so I deliberately acted scummy in the hopes that that would cause him (and preferably raerae as well) to investigate me.

[Eevee]

Lol at the spectator QT. NO ONE thought I was town at any point?

[Jorbles]

Lol at the spectator QT. NO ONE thought I was town at any point?

Haha nope. I was convinced you were pulling the wool over everyone's eyes a la RMM3.

[Jimmmmm]

Lol at the spectator QT. NO ONE thought I was town at any point?

Even I didn't think you were Town!