Now who would I lynch:
shraeye:
Theorel pointed out much better than I did why about 2/3 of shraeye's case on me was total junk. Shraeye got a lot of people on board, though so the case had that effect. But I agree with theorel that it looked like a lot of extra filler to make the case seem airtight. About half of it was no more than "Here's another thing Cuzz said." He then kept saying things about how he was becoming "super sure" that I was scum. Sorry, man. You cannot be certain about
anything D1. It's just not allowed in this game. So you're either lying scum, or WAY out of line overconfident and wrong town. Shraeye being "super sure" really rubs me the wrong way here.
ash:
Several things recently really flipped him from townread to scumread pretty quickly.
This quote:
Cuzz's frustration in his response to the shraeye case is something I can relate to. I really can. I also feel like Cuzz has been dying fairly early in recent games, so that can add to the frustration.
Still, I think he's a good lynch option today.
to me sounds like "yeah he's probably town, but lets lynch him anyway." Scum can't know who's town, but this could be ash knowing that I'm not on his team and therefore concluding I'm probably town.
The next two posts combined:
Okay, vote: Cuzz
This is based on his interactions with others and shraeye's well-laid out case.
That's L-2.
Also, shraeye looks terrible if Cuzz flips town.
Ash sheeps shraeye in the laziest way possible (what interactions with which others? what parts of shraeye's case?), and then IMMEDIATELY tried to make sure all the blame will head to shraeye if and when I flip town. It's again like he's anticipating I will flip town, and sorry man, but you do not get off scot free for lynching a townie just because someone else did all the legwork.
Two more things: ash votes nolynch for some reason, and also fails to understand why Dsell should be a top townread and tries to make me sound anti-town for saying so. Also puts words in my mouth saying that I made Dsell an IC, which I took care not to imply.
This quote too:
Cuzz, who are you willing to sheep at this point?
I dunno if it's helpful to answer this right now. If I say a few names here and one of them turns out to be scum then they can use that to manipulate my vote.
That's a good and fair answer.
and this one
@Cuzz -- yeah, probably. Still, at least I feel your pain, right?
both sound kinda like he knows I'm town. It's like "yeah man, I'm on your side. But I still want to lynch you."
Glooble:
Lurked hard, came back with an emotional defense when the wagon built, but yuma made a good point that the wagon probably dissolved too quickly, and the defense would be quite easy to fake as scum. Also his sheep vote of shraeye is weak and does not contribute anything to the case or refer to any particularly convincing part of it.
Shraeye's analysis is extremely convincing to me.
Vote: Cuzz
Also, the lurking thing again. Has contributed more only since being called out for lurking.
Galz:Just don't get usual super pro-town Galz here. I don't love this argument, because it's the same one made against Volt in XVI which I knew was bunk at the time and felt bad about making, but it's still a bad feeling. And his case on me about my early D1 posts is just really bad. Again, such things jump out to me and I will use them as evidence all I want, omgus or not.
Others:I get bad vibes from Munch and mcmc, in that they're kind of hiding in the background a bit. Munch is usually more vocal, so it especially seems out of character there. I'm not sure what to expect from mcmc so not as sure there.
And liopoil is lurking like crazy now, and needs to get some contribution on the table.
raerae is getting a bit bloodthirsty toward me right now, but I dunno if it makes her scum. I think she's probably just got blinders on and can't let go of her thought that I'm scum. I just feel like everything I say is sending her into a rage.
Anyway, most substantial case above is obvious.
Vote: ashersky