Again, I'm not caught up, and have not reread everything. But yuma, your case on Jimmmm is simply not compelling to me. I am not sure what to think of his interactions with Munch, but even if his reaction is similar, that is not strong enough reason for me to drop my town read. I have made the mistake of comparing people's styles between games too many times, it just does not seem like an effective way of scumhunting to me. I think using general metas and playstyles often works, but it seems that there are too many factors going into any given situation to draw reads by comparing two specific cases. Also, I found his reaction to his case to be quite genuine, it didn't feel manufactured to me at all. I also thought his reaction to others' new cases seemed real.
I dunno, it's easy to point to this and that as things that give you a scum read, but it's harder to quantify town reads. I have one on Jimmm, it is based on the things I pointed out in that post as well as a few other things.
What makes you think I have town reads on everyone else? I have a town read on Jimmmm. That was literally all that post was about. I don't have a town read on you, for example.
It's fine for people to develop their own reads, that's the name of the game, right? But I am so surprised that SO many people are getting scumreads on Jimmm, and from my perspective it is hard to believe that everyone on this wagon or that's expressed interest in this wagon is town.