Ash, I don't recall, but were you in Chicken Mafia (I get so lost with these games after they're done)?
The two biggest things I have against Insomniac are:
A) That his play was very off-putting early on. That's a little harder to pinpoint, but I've been decent at gut reading Insomniac lately. His interactions with Dsell were particularly... Forced sounding to me.
B) And this is why I ask about Chicken Mafia - but town!Insomniac is an extremely reactionary and passionate player. He doesn't take kindly to being voted on, and yells and screams when people make what he feels are bad cases on him. He hasn't at all done this here. Yes, he was a LITTLE jumpy when I listed him as possible scum and lynch target, but after I explained I got a "well, I didn't get that from before, but ok".
I just really feel like I'm looking at calculating scum!Insomniac, not play by your passion town!Insomniac.
I'm willing to vote Dsell, but his reaction to being voted by the IC's reads a little more townie than Insomniac's reactions.
---
Insomniac, if something is wrong, I'm truly sorry. I'm not picking on you because of it, and it has no bearing on my case here. We really don't want to lose you too.