I'll say this:
If Cayvie and/or Robz are town, they are going up for awards this year as "worst town play in a Mafia game". They're honestly sitting there thinking that the two most active players in this thread - the two that, without whom this thread would be going nowhere, are sitting there openly coaching each other as scum buddies about how not to appear too suspicious.
A) Do you know what crappy scum play that would be? I'm honestly completely insulted that you think that I, as scum, would give a damn about my scummate on D1 - or that I would care SO much about protecting him that I would go out of my way to "coach" him on not getting himself lynched.
B) Absolutely classic reason why scum so very, very rarely get lynched D1 on f.DS - Because they can just sit back and not say a damn thing, not lead the town, or offer thoughts or suggestions, and for those that DO speak up - OH MAI GOD THEY SO SCUMMY!
C) You're both ridiculous. I can't speak for Dsell's alignment, but honestly the case on him is complete crap - and I'm highly suspect of those who 1) Made it, and 2) Sheeped it.
D) See points A-C, and welcome yourself to confirmation bias.