Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Eevee]

Peoples opinions?

Morgrim7 is Kaatniss?
FTL is Legolas?

Both possible, I'd say morgrim looks scummier but then again he always does. I don't remember a single post from FTL in the whole game.. which is scummy too actually.

Lol @Watno for saying I'm scummy for saying I don't think we should try to break the game by checking who is online and who is not. Really man?

Insomniac, you haven't claimed either by the way. I take it I'm allowed to claim now, I'm a Scarecrow (in the magical land of Oz). No idea what that means. The doctor-guy with the bad medicine was called scarecrow in the first (and I guess third) Batman-movie from Nolan's trilogy, so me saying batman for no reason earlier was sort of a breadcrumb/proof I'm not lying (although why would I lie about that anyways + I'm confirmed town now, but Batman is awesome and I like saying it. Been watching HISHE.)

[Eevee]

Alright, here I am giving you more info than you need or deserve:

eHalcyon was killed earlier in the day than his death was posted.  He was PM'd his death, and it was supposed to be like in BMMM1 - his body (chassis?) would be found under a pile of rocks a little before deadline. However, eHalcyon failed to read his PMs before posting and ruined my beautiful plans.

TL;DR looking at who was online really is misleading.

I suppose you can't tell us if he got killed before or after saying he caught someone lying?

[Insomniac]

Peoples opinions?

Morgrim7 is Kaatniss?
FTL is Legolas?

Both possible, I'd say morgrim looks scummier but then again he always does. I don't remember a single post from FTL in the whole game.. which is scummy too actually.

Lol @Watno for saying I'm scummy for saying I don't think we should try to break the game by checking who is online and who is not. Really man?

Insomniac, you haven't claimed either by the way. I take it I'm allowed to claim now, I'm a Scarecrow (in the magical land of Oz). No idea what that means. The doctor-guy with the bad medicine was called scarecrow in the first (and I guess third) Batman-movie from Nolan's trilogy, so me saying batman for no reason earlier was sort of a breadcrumb/proof I'm not lying (although why would I lie about that anyways + I'm confirmed town now, but Batman is awesome and I like saying it. Been watching HISHE.)

go read my posts, I've claimed jotheonah, and put it in all posts with claim lists

[Galzria]

Peoples opinions?

Morgrim7 is Kaatniss?
FTL is Legolas?

Well, that's still focused on the arrow in the NK flavor, but nothing to do with eHal.

However, Morgrim fits both theories then, doesn't he? If he's who he claims, then trap setting is right down his allyand could be the cause of eHal's death. If he's lying and is Katniss, then he would fit the arrow profile. So in his case specifically you could have two justifiable scum scenarios.

ftl being Legolas is also possible, but I've developed a bit of a softspot for him for defending my claim - and if my suspicion is true, I know how he would know. So I don't think he's a good target today, and I hope that someone could clear him tonight - at least as town/not town.

[Insomniac]

Unvote

Vote: Morgrim7 I honestly think this is our best chance to get scum and is probably who was lying.

[Galzria]

Unvote

Vote: Morgrim7 I honestly think this is our best chance to get scum and is probably who was lying.

I'll join that wagon. Vote: Morgrim7 - for either lying and being an arrow shooter, or for telling the truth and killing eHal.

[Voltgloss]

Note:  I was amused to find Ned here as the poster boy for "catch-22" on Quickmeme

[Eevee]

Sorry Insomniac, I read that and instantly forgot it somehow.

Morgrim wagon looks okay to me, although I still think Watno could be (at least partially) truthful about his role and still scum.

[Robz888]

Vote: Morgrim, because of traps and shooting arrows and also this is a bastard game so I don't care as much about contemplating the dreaded Morgrim Insanity Defense.

[jotheonah]

Vote Count 2.2.4

Dsell(1): Watno
Watno(4): O, Eevee, cayvie, Archetype
Morgrim7(3): Insomniac, Galzria, Robz888

not voting(7): ashersky, Cuzz, Captain_Frisk, Dsell, Morgrim7, ftl, theorel

With 15 alive it takes 8 to lynch.

Deadline is 4:00 p.m. EDT on September 7.  24 hours to go.

[Watno]

Lol @Watno for saying I'm scummy for saying I don't think we should try to break the game by checking who is online and who is not. Really man?

To prevent missunderstandings: That wasn't me, it was Cuzz.

I'd be fine with lynching Morgrim. I'm convinced he's not town, but i fear lynching him might be exactly what he wants. But we probably won't get around getting rid of him sooner or later, so we can as well do it today.

[Voltgloss]

[cayvie]

Watno: why didn't you tell me you'd turned me into a whale?

[Watno]

What benefit would that have had for anyone?

[cayvie]

What benefit would that have had for anyone?

For one, I might not have pushed the wagon on you so hard!

[Robz888]

Watno: why didn't you tell me you'd turned me into a whale?

That's a good point. You'd think Watno would mention in the QT, "Hey Cayvie, funny story, I inadvertently turned you into a whale."

"WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA," Cayvie replied.

[Insomniac]

Watno: why didn't you tell me you'd turned me into a whale?

That's a good point. You'd think Watno would mention in the QT, "Hey Cayvie, funny story, I inadvertently turned you into a whale."

"WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA," Cayvie replied.

Its the same case cayvie already made thats strong though, Watno didn't engage cayvie if he didnt share info with her he's definetly not about to say oh btw my power is I turn people into whales.

[cayvie]

Guys! I think the way to win is to somehow get Watno to have ashersky's post restriction.

[Insomniac]

Guys! I think the way to win is to somehow get Watno to have ashersky's post restriction.

Or voting Morgrim

[Watno]

After reading again, I'm also quite suspicious of ashersky. On Day 1, he dodged around the genreclaim-discussion at first and popped in shortly before the deadline with a kinda unrelated vote. On Day 2, pretty much the only thing he said was the Darth Vader-thing. I find it strange that an ability supposedly just had him hear music. Also, if I was suspicious that there's a scum Darth Vader in the game and people are discussing wether to do a nameclaim, i wouldn't ask "Who's Darth Vader?" (because scum Darth Vader wouldn't say "It's me, lynch me" in response to that), but try to get that nameclaim going. Plus he still didnt give us his name if I'm not mistaken.

[Eevee]

Lol @Watno for saying I'm scummy for saying I don't think we should try to break the game by checking who is online and who is not. Really man?

To prevent missunderstandings: That wasn't me, it was Cuzz.

I'd be fine with lynching Morgrim. I'm convinced he's not town, but i fear lynching him might be exactly what he wants. But we probably won't get around getting rid of him sooner or later, so we can as well do it today.

Morgrim always looks like he wants to be lynched. Has always been vanilla town this far..

Oh and sorry for the mix-up, I was already thinking of my 2nd point. Should preview before posting.

I agree with Robz by the way. Evidence is piling. I really think the case on Watno is stronger than the case on Morgrim.

[Insomniac]

I'm much more convinced that Morgrim is scum, but I would switch to Watno if the deadline gets to close and Watno is the only option

[cayvie]

Hunger Games contestants are an awful lot like Serial Killers...

I mean, they have the same win condition and are capable of killing people...

[Robz888]

I'm pretty torn between Watno and Morgrim at the moment, but Watno is a puzzle we might solve at some point. Morgrim, on the other hand...

[cayvie]

Well, from my perspective, all else equal, with the choice between two possible scum, I'd prefer to lynch the one in my neighborhood.

That way, when I neighborize someone else, whatever they say is less likely to get relayed straight to scumville.