Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Eevee]

I have stated my case against manda. No one has presented anything as strong (imo ofc), so I'm very inclined to just vote for manda. Especially because she seems to be unwilling to defend herself. Getting yourself lynched means game over for your faction if you are town, so I would expect more emotion and more fighting if this was a mistake.

Actually, since this is the only way I see us getting forward:

Vote: manda and pray to god.

I hope my reads are better here than they were in murder mystery.. because if not,  I just lost town the game.

[pingpongsam]

Well, there's this 48 hour thing and then there's the fact I've been pushing manda for 2 days and don'y really have muc else to say and then there's this other vote on the table so I don't feel like the jerk being the 1st to do it. Finally, there's the fact I'm certain manda is scum and once we have a NK I'm going to have a strong read on who the other person is.

Since I'm likely tonight's target, here are my thoughts. Eevee is Town. Either YN or sharky could be scum. I think Sharky is the more obvious scum but my ego says that YN must be the other scum because if manda/sharky were the scum pair I'm embarrassed at Town's play through and through. Put a gun to my head today though and I'd vote Sharky as the other scum partner.

Vote: manda

[Eevee]

Unvote and reading through PPS if can I find any inconsistencies. Sorry buddy, I will likely vote back, just got to make sure your vote seems like a reasonable town play for you specifically.

[pingpongsam]

No, problem, that was precisely what I expected you to do.

[pingpongsam]

Prepare to marvel at the complete lack of follow-up votes because scum has been afraid to be seen on a wagon the whole game.

[Eevee]

Prepare to marvel at the complete lack of follow-up votes because scum has been afraid to be seen on a wagon the whole game.

Scum has it easy when townies pick fights with each other and lynch other townies without any scum votes. :/
Vote: manda, I think PPS is legit. Now all we can do is hope..

[Young Nick]

Vote: manda

[Young Nick]

Prepare to marvel at the complete lack of follow-up votes because scum has been afraid to be seen on a wagon the whole game.

Before Eevee put manda at L-1, I was going to quote this to imply that at least one of you were Mafia, and that's why scum was hesitant to move. However, this proved unnecessary.

[Young Nick]

Saddest d3 ever. No one is here to talk to me about a manda lynch. I don't look too good hammering, but who looks scummier, pps or Eevee?

[Eevee]

Saddest d3 ever. No one is here to talk to me about a manda lynch. I don't look too good hammering, but who looks scummier, pps or Eevee?

I'm here!

So uhm, at least scum didnt quickhammer a townie then!  I would have to say PPS looks the scummiest of us (if manda flips town), but you know.. I know I'm town.
Nick tried his best to steer the town towards sharky, so maybe he is manda's partner and now just decided its better to at least take the town cred if she is going to go anyways, so I wouldnt be surprised if he was scum either. Going to be really interesting to see how dies at night given how we have no confirmed townies.

[Young Nick]

Saddest d3 ever. No one is here to talk to me about a manda lynch. I don't look too good hammering, but who looks scummier, pps or Eevee?

I'm here!

So uhm, at least scum didnt quickhammer a townie then!  I would have to say PPS looks the scummiest of us (if manda flips town), but you know.. I know I'm town.
Nick tried his best to steer the town towards sharky, so maybe he is manda's partner and now just decided its better to at least take the town cred if she is going to go anyways, so I wouldnt be surprised if he was scum either. Going to be really interesting to see how dies at night given how we have no confirmed townies.

The thing is that I find it possible that you and pps are a pair and lured me in. With the amount of inactivity and what with people being offline, I figure that scum have to assume a quick-hammer is off the table. If no two people are ever online at the same time (and that's what it looks like) then how can the Mafia expect to be online at the same time? So, I'm wary of both of you, but if that's the case, it's game over anyway and I got played like a fool.

[Young Nick]

Also, it's not that I want us to steer clear of manda, but that I want us to steer clear of voting, until the week at least. It seems like most of you can play from work, so I'd rather us wait to vote when more people can post. Having said that, I still found manda scummy; I wouldn't vote for her if I didn't (obviously).

I find it interesting that you (and others, if I remember correctly) read me as trying to steer away from manda when that's not what I wanted at all!

[Eevee]

I'm refreshing this like a madman (DA reference!), waiting for PPS or someone else to post "YAYYY WE WON".

Volt the suspense is killing us, get here already!

[Eevee]

Also, it's not that I want us to steer clear of manda, but that I want us to steer clear of voting, until the week at least. It seems like most of you can play from work, so I'd rather us wait to vote when more people can post. Having said that, I still found manda scummy; I wouldn't vote for her if I didn't (obviously).

I find it interesting that you (and others, if I remember correctly) read me as trying to steer away from manda when that's not what I wanted at all!

Well you know what I mean. When I was saying "should we just vote for manda?",  you kept responding with "no we should re-read!!" which obviously is never a bad idea but if you were her scumbuddy, you'd sure appreciate the shift of focus..

[Young Nick]

True, but that's not what I was getting at. I can see how you read it that way, which is why I gave a long-ish post summarizing the History of My Thoughts on manda2014. It should been in the Bible of Young Nick, if theory would be willing to create such a sub-forum.

Because, well, if she flips town, I will have been right in that hasty voting is a most dangerous proposition. Without too much analysis from others or about others, to boot!

I guess we can't do much of anything at this point but sit on our butts and wait for Volt. He never even responded to my prod request earlier. He hasn't been online in ~9 hours.

[pingpongsam]

Wow, just got home and see we just lynched and Mafia isn't claiming victory! I think we just popped scum!

[Young Nick]

Wow, just got home and see we just lynched and Mafia isn't claiming victory! I think we just popped scum!

That or scum is silently popping the champagne, having played a perfect game.

[Eevee]

Wow, just got home and see we just lynched and Mafia isn't claiming victory! I think we just popped scum!

That or scum is silently popping the champagne, having played a perfect game.

The entire wagon is on and no one is claiming victory.. I think we finally found scum, people! Yay!

[Eevee]

Lol PPS just said that.. but yeah, PPS posting something non-celebratory means game is not over yet for sure.

[Young Nick]

Need. Voltgloss.

[Eevee]

Someone wants to send in a night kill already! Nick here is out for blood.

[Eevee]

No but seriously it's like being an addict and not having my dealer show up.

[Young Nick]

Eevee, let's play some Iso to get our other fix in!

[Eevee]

Eevee, let's play some Iso to get our other fix in!

Man's got to sleep, sorry not now.  Nice redirect though!

[Young Nick]

Eevee, let's play some Iso to get our other fix in!

Man's got to sleep, sorry not now.  Nice redirect though!

We get it. You think I am scummy. :/ Let's let Voltgloss do his thing before we jump to conclusions. You really think I would have so obviously buddied up to my scummate throughout d1 and the first half of d2? Conspirator, please.